When an individual with ties to England and Wales owns assets or a business abroad, the process of drafting a will becomes significantly more complex than a purely domestic estate. The legal framework of England and Wales provides a robust system for testamentary dispositions, but its reach is not limitless. The interplay between English law and the laws of other jurisdictions—often referred to as private international law—is a critical area of consideration. Navigating this landscape requires careful planning to ensure that a testator’s wishes are respected and that the administration of their estate proceeds smoothly and efficiently, minimising the potential for disputes, delays, and unforeseen tax liabilities.
Key Considerations for Your Will: Navigating International Assets
The fundamental principle governing the law of succession in England and Wales is that a testator has freedom of testamentary disposition. However, this freedom is often challenged when assets are situated in a foreign country. The primary issues revolve around three key legal concepts: domicile, the nature and location of the assets, and the formal validity of the will. Understanding these concepts is the first step in creating a comprehensive and effective international will.
Domicile and its Impact on Your Estate
Domicile is a crucial legal concept distinct from nationality or residence. It refers to the country that a person considers to be their permanent home. While a person can have multiple residences or nationalities, they can only have one domicile at any given time. This legal status is of paramount importance because it determines the law that governs the distribution of a person’s movable assets upon their death.
What is the difference between domicile, residence, and nationality?
Residence is a factual matter, simply referring to where a person lives. Nationality is a legal bond with a state, typically acquired at birth. Domicile, however, is a more nuanced and enduring concept. A person starts life with a domicile of origin, usually that of their father at the time of their birth. They can acquire a domicile of choice by moving to a new country with the settled intention of making it their permanent home. This requires a high degree of proof, and a mere intention to live abroad for an indefinite period may not be sufficient.
The law of the testator’s domicile at the time of their death dictates how their movable assets—such as bank accounts, shares, jewellery, and personal effects—are distributed. For instance, if a person domiciled in England dies owning a bank account in France, the distribution of those funds will be governed by English law. Conversely, if a person domiciled in France dies owning a bank account in England, French succession law will apply.
The Distinction Between Movable and Immovable Assets
Another critical consideration is the type of assets you own. English law distinguishes between two categories of property for the purpose of succession:
What are movable and immovable assets?
Immovable assets are those that cannot be physically moved, such as land and buildings. The law that governs the transfer of immovable property is the law of the country where the property is located, a principle known as lex situs. This means that a property in Spain, for example, will be governed by Spanish succession law, regardless of the testator’s domicile.
Movable assets, on the other hand, are everything else—cash, shares, vehicles, and personal possessions. As discussed, the law of the testator’s domicile governs the succession of these assets.
Can a single will cover both types of assets in different countries?
- While it’s possible to draft a single will that purports to deal with all worldwide assets, it is often not the most efficient or secure approach. The laws of the foreign jurisdiction may not recognise a will drafted under English law, or they may impose restrictions that conflict with the testator’s wishes. For instance, many civil law jurisdictions, such as France and Italy, operate under forced heirship rules, which legally mandate that a certain portion of the estate must pass to specific family members, typically children. This directly contradicts the English principle of freedom of testamentary disposition. In such cases, an English will may be partially or entirely ineffective in respect of immovable property in that country.
- This is where the case of Crowther v Crowther and others provides an insightful parallel. While not directly an international succession case, it highlights the English courts’ approach to the enforcement of financial orders and the importance of a clear understanding of legal principles. The case demonstrates that even within the UK, legal rights and obligations must be clearly established and adhere to the relevant legal framework. When dealing with foreign jurisdictions, these complexities are magnified, as the laws and legal systems may be fundamentally different.
- A more secure strategy is to create a separate will for the assets in the foreign jurisdiction, drafted by a local solicitor and carefully coordinated with the English will to avoid any accidental revocation of either document. The English will would then explicitly state that it only deals with assets in England and Wales and that it does not revoke the foreign will.
- For a will to be valid in England and Wales, it must comply with the requirements of the Wills Act 1837. This typically involves the will being in writing, signed by the testator in the presence of two witnesses, who then also sign in the testator’s presence. However, when a will deals with foreign assets, the question of its validity in that other jurisdiction becomes paramount.
What if my will doesn’t comply with the local law of the country where I have assets?
The Wills Act 1963 provides a measure of flexibility. Under this Act, a will is considered formally valid if it was made in accordance with the law of any of the following jurisdictions:
- The country where the will was executed.
- The country where the testator was domiciled at the time of execution or death.
- The country of the testator’s nationality at the time of execution or death.
- The country where the will deals with immovable property (lex situs).
- While this provides a degree of recognition, it does not guarantee that the will’s substantive provisions will be enforceable. For example, a will may be formally valid under English law but be rejected by a foreign jurisdiction because its provisions violate that country’s forced heirship laws.
What role does the Administration of Justice Act 1982 play?
- The Administration of Justice Act 1982 introduced important reforms, particularly concerning the rectification of wills and the admissibility of evidence. For international wills, the “foreign element” provisions of this Act are particularly relevant. They help clarify issues of interpretation and intention where there is a conflict between jurisdictions. However, its primary function is within the English legal system, and it cannot override the substantive succession laws of a foreign country.
- When the assets in question are a business, the complexities are amplified. A business can be a company, a partnership, or a sole proprietorship, each with its own legal and practical considerations. The testator’s will must clearly and carefully define what will happen to the business interest upon their death.
How does a will deal with a business owned abroad?
- The business’s legal structure and the law of the country where it operates are the primary determining factors. For a company, the articles of association or shareholder agreements may dictate what happens to shares upon the death of a shareholder. A partnership agreement will likely contain similar provisions. The will’s provisions must align with these governing documents.
- Furthermore, a will can appoint a specific person to act as a power of attorney to manage the business while the estate is being administered, which can be a lengthy process. Without such a provision, the business may be left in a state of legal and operational limbo.
- Probate is the legal process of proving a will’s validity and administering the deceased’s estate. When international assets are involved, this process often requires legal intervention in multiple jurisdictions.
Can an English grant of probate be used to deal with foreign assets?
Generally, an English grant of probate has no legal standing in a foreign country. The executor will typically need to apply for a separate grant of probate or a similar document in each country where there are assets. This process, often referred to as “resealing” the grant, can be time-consuming and expensive. The executor may need to instruct local lawyers in each jurisdiction to handle the local administration, and they will be bound by the laws of that country. This is another reason why having separate, locally drafted wills is often a more effective strategy.
How TSABI Solicitors Can Assist
- Navigating the complexities of international estate planning requires specialist legal knowledge and a deep understanding of private international law. As a seasoned firm of solicitors, advocates, and barristers, TSABI Solicitors (The Solicitors, Advocates, and Barristers Inc.) is uniquely positioned to assist clients with these intricate matters.
- We provide comprehensive, tailored advice on drafting wills that account for international business interests and assets. Our approach involves analysis of your specific circumstances, including your domicile, the location and nature of your assets, and the succession laws of the relevant foreign jurisdictions. We will work with you to:
- We will help you understand your domicile status and how it affects the distribution of your worldwide movable assets.
- Where necessary, we will advise on and assist with the preparation of multiple wills to cover assets in different countries, ensuring they are coordinated to avoid conflicts and accidental revocation.
- We provide strategic advice on how to integrate business succession plans into your will, ensuring the continuity of your business interests and a smooth transfer of ownership.
- We will identify and advise on potential conflicts between English law and foreign jurisdictions, particularly regarding issues like forced heirship and the enforceability of trusts.
- We will help you plan for a more efficient probate process by advising on the appointment of local representatives and the potential for a power of attorney, thereby reducing delays and costs for your beneficiaries.