FAQ
Home / FAQs / Human Rights / How Does the Principle of “Proportionality” Apply When a Public Authority Tries to Justify Interfering With My Rights?

How Does the Principle of “Proportionality” Apply When a Public Authority Tries to Justify Interfering With My Rights?

To understand “proportionality,” it is first necessary to understand the distinction between “absolute” and “qualified” rights under the “Human Rights Act 1998.”

The Distinction That Matters

  • The law recognises that not all rights are created equal.
  • Absolute Rights: These are rights that can never be lawfully interfered with by a public body, under any circumstances. Any breach of an absolute right is an automatic violation of the “Human Rights Act 1998,” and the public body has no defence. Examples include the prohibition of torture and inhuman or degrading treatment (“Article 3”) and the prohibition of slavery (“Article 4”).
  • Qualified Rights: These are rights that can be lawfully interfered with by a public body, as long as the interference meets a strict legal test. “Proportionality” is the final and most important part of this test, and it is a key legal tool for challenging an interference with a qualified right.
  • This distinction is of paramount importance because the legal strategy for challenging a breach of a qualified right is fundamentally different from a claim based on an absolute right.

Examples of Qualified Rights

Many of the most commonly cited human rights are “qualified rights,” including:

  • The Right to Respect for Private and Family Life (Article 8 ECHR): This protects your personal life, home, and family relationships from unlawful interference by the state.
  • Freedom of Expression (Article 10 ECHR): This protects your right to hold and express opinions and to receive and impart information without state interference.
  • Freedom of Assembly and Association (Article 11 ECHR): This protects your right to protest peacefully and to join groups and organisations. These rights are crucial for a free and democratic society, but the law recognises that they must be balanced against the rights of others and the wider public good.

The Three-Part Test for Lawful Interference

For a public body to lawfully interfere with a “qualified right,” they must be able to prove that their action met a three-part test. A human rights lawyer will scrutinise each part of this test to build a claim.

Step 1: Was the Interference Lawful?

The first part of the test requires the public body to prove that its action had a legal basis. The interference must be in accordance with the law, meaning it must be provided for in an Act of Parliament or in common law. This ensures that a public body is not acting arbitrarily or without any legal authority. The law must also be sufficiently clear and accessible for a person to understand what is and is not permitted.

Step 2: Was There a Legitimate Aim?

The second part of the test requires the public body to prove that the interference was for a “legitimate aim.” The “legitimate aims” are set out in the relevant articles of the ECHR and include:

  • National security.
  • Public safety.
  • The prevention of disorder or crime.
  • The protection of health or morals.
  • The protection of the rights and freedoms of others.
  • The public body must be able to demonstrate that its action was for a valid reason that falls within one of these categories.

Step 3: Was the Interference Proportionate?

  • This is the most crucial and often most contentious part of the legal test. Even if a public body has a lawful basis and a legitimate aim for its actions, a court can still find that the interference was unlawful if it was not “proportionate.” The principle of “proportionality” requires the public body to prove that its action was no more than is necessary to achieve the legitimate aim.
  • A court will ask a series of questions to decide if an action is proportionate:
  • Is the measure suitable? Does the public body’s action actually help to achieve the legitimate aim?
  • Is the measure necessary? Could the public body have achieved the legitimate aim in a less restrictive way? The court will look at whether there was a “less intrusive measure” that could have been used.
  • Was a fair balance struck? The court will weigh the rights of the individual against the interests of the community as a whole. This is a difficult balancing act, and the court will consider the severity of the interference on the individual’s rights. The more severe the interference, the more compelling the justification for it must be.
  • The courts use the analogy of a “steam hammer to crack a nut” to explain “proportionality.” A proportionate action is one that is a “nutcracker,” not a “steam hammer.”

The Importance of Proportionality in Practice

The principle of “proportionality” is not an abstract legal concept; it is a powerful legal tool that can be used to challenge a wide range of public body decisions.

Challenging Unjustified Decisions

In a human rights claim involving a “qualified right,” the public body bears the burden of proof to demonstrate that its action was “proportionate.” Your solicitor will not have to prove that the public body acted unlawfully; they only must prove that your rights have been interfered with. The burden then shifts to the public body to justify its actions. This is often where a human rights claim is won or lost. Your solicitor will scrutinise the public body’s justification, challenging whether it has used the least restrictive option and whether it has struck a fair balance between your rights and the interests of the community.

The principle of “proportionality” is vital for your legal case because it is the key legal tool for challenging a public body’s interference with your rights. It is the legal test that ensures a public body cannot simply say that they had a good reason for their actions; they must prove that their actions were a “proportionate” response to that reason. This gives you a clear and structured legal argument to challenge their decision and to seek a “remedy” for the harm you have suffered.

Examples of Proportionality in Action

Freedom of Expression (Article 10): A local authority might try to ban a protest on the grounds of “public safety.” A human rights lawyer would challenge this decision on the grounds of “proportionality,” arguing that a total ban was not the least restrictive option and that the local authority could have achieved the same aim by imposing conditions on the protest (e.g., a change of location or a time limit).

Right to Private and Family Life (Article 8): A local authority might try to evict a family from their home on the grounds that they have fallen into arrears with their rent. A human rights lawyer would challenge this decision on the grounds of “proportionality,” arguing that the eviction was not a proportionate response to the arrears and that the local authority should have considered a more supportive approach, particularly if there were children involved.

How TSABI Can Assist You

At TSABI Solicitors Advocates and Barristers Inc., we are committed to fighting for individual rights and holding public bodies accountable for their actions. Our team of expert human rights lawyers has a strong track record of success in challenging public body decisions on the grounds of “proportionality.”

Strategic and Expert Advice

Our human rights lawyers are experts in assessing and categorising breaches of human rights. We will review the circumstances of your case, identify any potential breaches of your rights, and provide you with a clear, honest assessment of your chances of success. We will then build a legal strategy tailored to the specific type of right that has been breached, focusing on whether we can prove that a breach of an absolute right has occurred or whether we can challenge the “proportionality” of a public body’s interference with a qualified right.

The TSABI Difference: Integrated Legal Support

TSABI is unique in its integration of solicitors, advocates, and barristers. This means that from the moment you instruct us, you have a team working on your behalf. This ensures continuity of service and expert legal counsel at every stage of your case. Our integrated model provides you with the peace of mind that you have a comprehensive team protecting your interests, no matter where your legal journey takes you. We are your legal voice, your guide, and your advocate, and we will be with you every step of the way.

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
What is a “Declaration of Incompatibility” and What Does it Mean for My Case? 
The power to make and unmake laws rests with Parliament. This constitutional principle, known as parliamentary sovereignty, is a cornerstone of the UK's legal framework. However, with the introduction of...Read More
Toggle Icon
Is it Possible for a Human Rights Claim to be Brought by a Group or an Organisation, or Only by an Individual? 
When a human right is violated, the immediate question often revolves around who has the legal standing to challenge the breach and seek justice. In England and Wales, the "Human...Read More
Toggle Icon
What is the Role of the European Court of Human Rights, and Do I Have to Go There to Seek Justice?  
When a person believes their human rights have been violated, a common question is whether they must take their case to the "European Court of Human Rights" (ECtHR) in Strasbourg....Read More
Toggle Icon
I Believe My Right to a Private and Family Life Has Been Infringed. What Does This Right Actually Protect?  
Everyone is entitled to a life free from unwarranted interference by the state. This fundamental right, to respect for your "private and family life," is a cornerstone of individual liberty...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can I Challenge a Government Policy or Law that I believe is Incompatible with My Human Rights? 
In a democratic society, the power of the state is not absolute. Individuals have a fundamental right to challenge government policies, decisions, and even laws that they believe are incompatible...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link