FAQ
Home / FAQs / Human Rights / Can I Challenge a Government Policy or Law that I believe is Incompatible with My Human Rights? 

Can I Challenge a Government Policy or Law that I believe is Incompatible with My Human Rights? 

In a democratic society, the power of the state is not absolute. Individuals have a fundamental right to challenge government policies, decisions, and even laws that they believe are incompatible with their human rights. This is a powerful mechanism of accountability that is enshrined in the “Human Rights Act 1998” (HRA), which allows citizens to hold the state to account for its actions in a UK court. The legal framework provides specific tools, such as “judicial review” and a “declaration of incompatibility,” that can be used to challenge unlawful government action. This guide is designed to provide you with a comprehensive overview of how you can challenge a government policy or law, the legal mechanisms involved, and the crucial role an expert solicitor plays in navigating this complex and often challenging area of law.

The Foundational Legal Principles

The ability to challenge a government policy or law is built upon a foundation of key legal principles that ensure the state acts within the bounds of the law and respects the rights of its citizens.

The Human Rights Act 1998

The “Human Rights Act 1998” (HRA) is the primary legislation that gives effect to the “European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR)” in domestic law. The HRA makes it unlawful for a “public body,” which includes government departments, to act in a way that is incompatible with a person’s “Convention rights.” This is the foundational principle that allows a person to challenge government action in a UK court. The courts have a duty to interpret all legislation in a way that is compatible with human rights, and if they cannot do so, they have the power to make a “declaration of incompatibility.”

The Principle of Proportionality

The principle of “proportionality” is a key legal tool for challenging government policies and laws. Many human rights, such as the right to a private and family life, and freedom of expression, are “qualified rights,” meaning they can be lawfully interfered with by a public body, as long as the interference is lawful, for a “legitimate aim,” and “proportionate.” When a government policy interferes with a “qualified right,” the court will assess whether the interference was a “proportionate” means of achieving a “legitimate aim.” This is a key part of the legal test that a human rights solicitor will use to challenge a government policy.

“Proportionality” means that a government policy or law must not go any further than is necessary to achieve its aim. The court will ask whether the government’s action was the least restrictive option available, and whether it struck a “fair balance” between the rights of the individual and the interests of the community as a whole. The more severe the interference with a person’s rights, the more compelling the justification for it must be.

The Legal Mechanisms for a Challenge

There are two primary legal mechanisms for challenging a government policy or law that is incompatible with a person’s human rights.

Judicial Review

“Judicial review” is the primary legal tool for challenging the lawfulness of a government policy, decision, or action. It is a court procedure where a judge reviews the process by which a decision was made, not the merits of the decision itself. A court will not substitute its own decision for that of the government; it will only find that the decision was unlawful and send it back to the government to be made again lawfully. A human rights violation is a key ground for bringing a “judicial review” claim. The court can find that a government policy is unlawful if it is “irrational,” procedurally unfair, or, most importantly in the context of human rights, is not “proportionate” or does not have a “legitimate aim.”

The Declaration of Incompatibility

A “declaration of incompatibility” is a unique and powerful legal tool that is used when a court finds that a provision of primary legislation is incompatible with a “Convention right.” This remedy is used when it is impossible for the court to interpret the law in a way that is compatible with human rights.

A “declaration of incompatibility” is a formal statement by a court that a provision of primary legislation is incompatible with a person’s human rights. Its legal effect is that it does not invalidate the law. The law remains in force, and the court must still apply it. However, a “declaration of incompatibility” signals to Parliament that the law needs to be changed. This is a powerful legal and political tool, and in most cases, Parliament has responded to a “declaration of incompatibility” by amending the law to make it compatible with human rights.

The Process of Bringing a Claim

Bringing a claim against a government policy or law is a complex legal process that requires expert guidance and swift action.

Strict Time Limits

The most important thing to remember is the need to act quickly. There is a “statutory time limit” for bringing a “judicial review” application, which is typically three months from the date the grounds for the application first arose. This is a strict deadline, and a court will not grant an extension unless there is a very good reason for the delay. This short time limit exists to ensure that challenges to public body decisions are made without delay, which can cause significant disruption to the public service.

You have three months from the date the grounds for the application first arose to bring a “judicial review” application. This is a strict deadline, and a failure to file a claim within this period can result in the court refusing to hear your case. It is vital to contact a human rights solicitor as soon as you believe a government policy or law is incompatible with your human rights.

Seeking a Remedy

If a court finds that a government policy or law is unlawful, it can grant a number of legal remedies. In a “judicial review,” the court can issue a “quashing order,” which nullifies the unlawful decision. The court can also make a “declaration of incompatibility” where the law itself is the problem. In some cases, a person may also be able to claim “damages” (financial compensation) for harm suffered as a result of the unlawful government action.

How TSABI Can Assist You

TSABI Solicitors Advocates and Barristers Inc. is committed to fighting for individual rights and holding public bodies accountable for their actions. Our team of expert human rights and public law solicitors has a strong track record of success in “judicial review” applications and civil “litigation” against government departments.

Expert Legal Assessment and Strategic Litigation

Our human rights lawyers are experts in assessing government policies and laws for potential breaches of “Convention rights.” We will review the circumstances of your case, identify any potential breaches of your rights, and provide you with a clear, honest assessment of your chances of success. We will then build a legal strategy tailored to the specific circumstances of your case, focusing on challenging the government’s action on the grounds of “proportionality” and “lawful aim.”

The TSABI Difference: Integrated Public Law Support

TSABI is unique in its integration of solicitors, advocates, and barristers. This means that from the moment you instruct us, you have a cohesive team working on your behalf. This ensures continuity of service and expert legal counsel at every stage of your case. Our integrated model provides you with the peace of mind that you have a comprehensive team protecting your interests, no matter where your legal journey takes you. We are your legal voice, your guide, and your advocate, and we will be with you every step of the way, fighting for your rights and for a just and lawful outcome.

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
What is a “Declaration of Incompatibility” and What Does it Mean for My Case? 
The power to make and unmake laws rests with Parliament. This constitutional principle, known as parliamentary sovereignty, is a cornerstone of the UK's legal framework. However, with the introduction of...Read More
Toggle Icon
Is it Possible for a Human Rights Claim to be Brought by a Group or an Organisation, or Only by an Individual? 
When a human right is violated, the immediate question often revolves around who has the legal standing to challenge the breach and seek justice. In England and Wales, the "Human...Read More
Toggle Icon
What is the Role of the European Court of Human Rights, and Do I Have to Go There to Seek Justice?  
When a person believes their human rights have been violated, a common question is whether they must take their case to the "European Court of Human Rights" (ECtHR) in Strasbourg....Read More
Toggle Icon
I Believe My Right to a Private and Family Life Has Been Infringed. What Does This Right Actually Protect?  
Everyone is entitled to a life free from unwarranted interference by the state. This fundamental right, to respect for your "private and family life," is a cornerstone of individual liberty...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can I Challenge a Government Policy or Law that I believe is Incompatible with My Human Rights? 
In a democratic society, the power of the state is not absolute. Individuals have a fundamental right to challenge government policies, decisions, and even laws that they believe are incompatible...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link