FAQ
Home / FAQs / Human Rights / What is a “Declaration of Incompatibility” and What Does it Mean for My Case? 

What is a “Declaration of Incompatibility” and What Does it Mean for My Case? 

The power to make and unmake laws rests with Parliament. This constitutional principle, known as parliamentary sovereignty, is a cornerstone of the UK’s legal framework. However, with the introduction of the “Human Rights Act 1998” (HRA), the judiciary was given a powerful and unique tool to uphold human rights while respecting the supremacy of Parliament: the “Declaration of Incompatibility.” This is a legal remedy that can be granted by a senior court when it finds that a piece of primary legislation is fundamentally at odds with the “European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR)”.

The Legal Basis: A Judge’s Final Recourse

The power to issue a “declaration of incompatibility” comes from Section 4 of the “Human Rights Act 1998.” This is a last-resort remedy that a “senior court” can use when it finds that a piece of “primary legislation” (an Act of Parliament) is incompatible with a “Convention right” and it is impossible to interpret the law in a compatible way.

What is a Declaration of Incompatibility?

A “declaration of incompatibility” is a formal and public statement by a court that a law is incompatible with a human right. It is a remedy that is only available from a senior court, such as the High Court, the Court of Appeal, or the Supreme Court. The court will not issue a declaration lightly. Before doing so, it will first try to interpret the legislation in a way that is compatible with human rights, as it is required to do by Section 3 of the HRA. A declaration is only issued when such a compatible interpretation is not possible, and the court finds that the law itself is the problem.

Q: Is a ‘declaration of incompatibility’ the same as declaring a law invalid? A: No, a “declaration of incompatibility” is not the same as declaring a law invalid. This is a key distinction that reflects the principle of parliamentary sovereignty. The declaration does not affect the validity, operation, or enforcement of the law. The law remains on the statute book, and the courts must continue to apply it. The declaration is a constitutional signal from the judiciary to Parliament that the law is flawed, but it is Parliament that has the ultimate power to amend or repeal the law.

The Legal and Political Effects of a Declaration

While a “declaration of incompatibility” does not have the direct legal effect of invalidating a law, its political and constitutional effects are significant.

What Does it Mean for My Case?

For a claimant, a “declaration of incompatibility” does not provide an immediate remedy. The court must still apply the incompatible law to your case, and the declaration itself does not change the outcome of your case. However, the declaration is a powerful legal statement that strengthens a person’s case for seeking a separate remedy, such as “damages,” and it can be used to make a future claim to the European Court of Human Rights. The declaration gives a claimant a legal precedent that can be used to argue that the state has violated their human rights, even if the law itself has not been changed.

The Role of Parliament

When a “declaration of incompatibility” is issued, the relevant government department is expected to respond. While Parliament is not legally obliged to change the law, there is a strong political and constitutional convention for it to do so. The government will often use a fast-track procedure, known as a “remedial order,” to amend the legislation and remove the incompatibility. This allows the government to change the law without having to go through the full legislative process, which can take months or even years. The use of a “remedial order” is a direct response to a “declaration of incompatibility” and is a clear sign that the government is taking the court’s finding seriously.

The Difference from Other Remedies

A “declaration of incompatibility” is a unique remedy that is distinct from other legal remedies, such as a “judicial review.” Understanding the difference is crucial for choosing the correct legal pathway for your case.

Declaration vs. Judicial Review

A “judicial review” is the primary legal tool for challenging a specific decision or policy by a “public body.” A successful “judicial review” can result in a “quashing order” that nullifies an unlawful decision.

The key difference is what is being challenged. A “judicial review” is used to challenge a specific decision, such as a “Home Office” decision to “deport” a person. A “declaration of incompatibility,” however, is used when the problem lies not with the decision itself but with the law that the “public body” was required to apply. For example, if a “public body” was required by a piece of primary legislation to act in a way that was incompatible with a person’s human rights, the problem is not with the “public body’s” decision but with the law itself. In this case, a “judicial review” would fail, as the “public body” was acting lawfully under the existing law, and the correct remedy would be a “declaration of incompatibility.”

The Importance of a Solicitor’s Advice

The distinction between a “declaration of incompatibility” and other remedies is a fundamental strategic choice that determines the legal pathway. A solicitor’s role is to assess whether the law itself is the problem or whether it is the “public body’s” decision that is the issue. This is a fundamental strategic choice that requires a deep understanding of human rights law and public law.

How TSABI Can Assist You

TSABI Solicitors Advocates and Barristers Inc. is committed to fighting for individual rights and holding public bodies accountable for their actions. Our team of expert human rights and public law solicitors has a strong track record of success in “judicial review” applications and cases that have resulted in a “declaration of incompatibility.”

Expert Legal Assessment and Strategic Litigation

Our human rights lawyers are experts in assessing government policies and laws for potential breaches of “Convention rights.” We will review the circumstances of your case, identify any potential breaches of your rights, and provide you with a clear, honest assessment of your chances of success. We will then build a legal strategy tailored to the specific circumstances of your case, focusing on whether we should challenge the government’s action through “judicial review” or whether we should seek a “declaration of incompatibility.”

The TSABI Difference: Integrated Public Law Support

TSABI is unique in its integration of solicitors, advocates, and barristers. This means that from the moment you instruct us, you have a cohesive team working on your behalf. This ensures continuity of service and expert legal counsel at every stage of your case. Our integrated model provides you with the peace of mind that you have a comprehensive team protecting your interests, no matter where your legal journey takes you. We are your legal voice, your guide, and your advocate, and we will be with you every step of the way, fighting for your rights and for a just and lawful outcome.

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
What is a “Declaration of Incompatibility” and What Does it Mean for My Case? 
The power to make and unmake laws rests with Parliament. This constitutional principle, known as parliamentary sovereignty, is a cornerstone of the UK's legal framework. However, with the introduction of...Read More
Toggle Icon
Is it Possible for a Human Rights Claim to be Brought by a Group or an Organisation, or Only by an Individual? 
When a human right is violated, the immediate question often revolves around who has the legal standing to challenge the breach and seek justice. In England and Wales, the "Human...Read More
Toggle Icon
What is the Role of the European Court of Human Rights, and Do I Have to Go There to Seek Justice?  
When a person believes their human rights have been violated, a common question is whether they must take their case to the "European Court of Human Rights" (ECtHR) in Strasbourg....Read More
Toggle Icon
I Believe My Right to a Private and Family Life Has Been Infringed. What Does This Right Actually Protect?  
Everyone is entitled to a life free from unwarranted interference by the state. This fundamental right, to respect for your "private and family life," is a cornerstone of individual liberty...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can I Challenge a Government Policy or Law that I believe is Incompatible with My Human Rights? 
In a democratic society, the power of the state is not absolute. Individuals have a fundamental right to challenge government policies, decisions, and even laws that they believe are incompatible...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link