Generally, the people with locus standi to contest a will’s validity are:
- A beneficiary of an earlier will: If the will you are contesting is invalidated, and an earlier will would be reinstated, anyone who would have received more under that earlier will has a right to challenge the new one.
- A person who would benefit under the rules of intestacy: If there is no earlier will to fall back on, and the contested will is invalidated, the estate would be distributed under the rules of intestacy (the legal framework for when someone dies without a valid will). The beneficiaries under these rules (e.g., spouses, children) would have locus standi.
- Creditors: In some cases, a creditor who is owed money by the deceased might have a right to challenge a will, particularly if the will’s terms make it difficult for them to be paid.
- This is distinct from making a claim for financial provision, which is a different legal process entirely, as we’ll discuss later.
- Challenging a will’s validity means arguing that the will is not a legal document at all (e.g., due to a lack of mental capacity). A successful challenge would invalidate the will. A claim for financial provision, on the other hand, accepts that the will is a valid legal document but argues that it does not provide for you financially, despite you being a close family member or a dependent. This claim is made under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975.
The Legal Grounds for Contesting a Will’s Validity
There are several specific legal grounds for arguing that a will is not valid. The burden of proof lies with the person challenging the will.
Lack of Testamentary Capacity
The most common ground for challenging a will is arguing that the testator (the person who made the will) lacked the testamentary capacity to do so. This means they did not have the mental ability to understand what they were doing at the time the will was made. The legal test for this comes from the 1870 case of Banks v Goodfellow. The testator must have:
- Understood the nature and effect of making a will.
- Known the extent of the property they were disposing of.
- Understood and appreciated the moral claims to which they ought to give effect (e.g., the claims of close family members).
- Not been suffering from any disorder of the mind that distorted their judgment.
- This is a key ground for challenging wills made by elderly or infirm individuals with conditions like dementia.
Undue Influence
This ground involves proving that the testator was coerced or pressured into making the will in a certain way, to the point where their own free will was overpowered. It goes beyond simple persuasion or advice. For a claim of undue influence to succeed, you must provide strong evidence that there is no other explanation for the terms of the will other than the testator being forced into them. This is often difficult to prove, as the testator is no longer alive to give evidence. Indicators can include the testator being isolated from family, or a sudden, unexplained change in the will’s terms to benefit a person who was previously not a main beneficiary.
Lack of Due Execution
A will must be signed and witnessed correctly to be legally valid. The Wills Act 1837 requires that a will must be:
- In writing.
- Signed by the testator in the presence of at least two witnesses.
- The witnesses must also attest and sign the will in the testator’s presence.
Fraudulent Calumny or Forgery
Fraudulent calumny is a subtle form of undue influence. It occurs when a person poisons the testator’s mind against a potential beneficiary by making false statements about them. The testator believes these lies and, as a result, excludes the person from their will. A claim for forgery is more straightforward, alleging that the testator’s signature was forged, or that the will itself is a fraudulent document.
The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975
Even if a will is legally valid, certain people can still make a claim for financial provision from the estate. This is a separate legal route. The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 allows a court to re-allocate an estate if it determines that the will did not make reasonable financial provision for the claimant.
Who Can Make a Claim?
The Act specifies a limited list of people who can make a claim, including:
- The deceased’s spouse or civil partner.
- A former spouse or civil partner who has not remarried.
- A child of the deceased (including adult children).
- A person treated by the deceased as a child of the family.
- A cohabitee who was living with the deceased for at least two years before their death.
- Any other person who was financially dependent on the deceased.
- The court will consider factors such as the size of the estate, the financial needs of the claimant, and the needs of the other beneficiaries when making its decision.
- While contesting a will is a legal process, most cases are resolved through negotiation and mediation without the need for a full court hearing. The parties involved often prefer to settle to avoid the high costs, time, and emotional stress of a trial. However, the threat of court proceedings and the legal framework around them are what drive the negotiation process.
How TSABI Law Firm Can Assist You
Contesting a will is a sensitive and complex area of law that requires expert knowledge of both legal procedure and human relationships. At TSABI, Solicitors, Advocates and Barristers Inc., we specialise in probate litigation and help our clients handle these difficult matters with a combination of legal expertise and empathy. Our services include:
- Case Assessment: We will assess your claim to determine if you have locus standi and strong legal grounds to challenge the will, or to make a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975.
- Evidence Gathering: Our team will assist you in gathering the crucial evidence needed, which can include medical records, witness statements, and communications to build a robust claim.
- Negotiation and Mediation: We will handle all communications and negotiations with the other parties, seeking to reach a fair settlement on your behalf and avoid the need for court action where possible.
- Court Representation: If litigation is unavoidable, our expert solicitors and barristers will represent you at every stage of the court proceedings, advocating fiercely to ensure your rights and interests are protected.