Human rights law is a crucial and evolving area of public law that governs the fundamental rights and freedoms individuals possess. In essence, it establishes the minimum standards of dignity, equality, and protection that states owe to everyone within their jurisdiction. These rights are inherent to all human beings, regardless of nationality, sex, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, language, or any other status. Human rights law provides a legal framework to hold governments and public bodies accountable when they fail to uphold these obligations. While the concept of human rights is universal, its application is often defined and enforced through national legislation and international treaties. In England and Wales, the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA) is the cornerstone of this legal framework, bringing the rights contained in the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) directly into domestic law. This means that individuals can enforce their convention rights in UK courts, without needing to go to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg.
The legal landscape of human rights in England and Wales is primarily shaped by both international obligations and domestic legislation. Understanding this dual-layered system is crucial for grasping how these rights are protected and enforced.
The European Convention on Human Rights is an international treaty signed by member states of the Council of Europe. It was drafted in 1950 in the aftermath of World War II to protect fundamental rights and freedoms and to prevent similar atrocities from happening again. The ECHR sets out a number of absolute and qualified rights, which form the basis of human rights law across Europe. The UK was one of the first countries to ratify the ECHR, but for many years, individuals could only challenge a breach of their convention rights by taking a case to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, a process that was often lengthy and expensive.
This all changed with the passing of the Human Rights Act 1998. The HRA is the most significant piece of legislation in modern UK human rights law. It had a transformative effect by “bringing rights home.” By incorporating the majority of the ECHR into UK law, the HRA made it possible for individuals to bring claims against public authorities for breaches of their convention rights in domestic courts. This legislation mandates that all UK legislation must, as far as possible, be interpreted and applied in a way that is compatible with the convention rights. Public authorities, including government departments, local councils, the police, and the NHS, have a legal duty to act in a manner that is compliant with the HRA.
The ECHR and, by extension, the HRA protect a wide range of rights, categorised as either absolute or qualified. Understanding the distinction is vital for determining the scope and limits of these rights.
Absolute rights are those that cannot be interfered with under any circumstances. They are non-negotiable and cannot be limited, even in times of national emergency. The prohibition on torture and inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment (Article 3) is a prime example of an absolute right. There can be no justification for torture, no matter the context.
Qualified rights are those that can be limited or interfered with by a public authority, but only under specific, strict conditions. The state must demonstrate that any interference is:
The HRA operationalises the ECHR by providing a clear legal framework for enforcement. Its provisions dictate how human rights are to be respected, protected, and enforced within the UK legal system.
Section 6 of the HRA places a legal obligation on all public authorities to act in a way that is compatible with convention rights. A public authority can include government ministers, local councils, the police, the prison service, and the NHS. If a public authority breaches a person’s human rights, that person can bring a claim against them in a UK court.
Section 3 of the HRA is often referred to as the “golden rule.” It mandates that, as far as is possible, primary and subordinate legislation must be read and given effect in a way that is compatible with convention rights. This gives judges a powerful tool to interpret existing laws in a human rights-compliant way, even if the law’s original wording seems to suggest otherwise.
Where a court finds that it is impossible to interpret a piece of primary legislation in a way that is compatible with convention rights, it can issue a declaration of incompatibility. This is a powerful, though non-binding, statement that highlights the conflict between the domestic law and the ECHR. It does not nullify the law but puts pressure on the government and Parliament to amend it. A prime example of this occurred in the case of Bellinger v Bellinger (2003), which will be discussed in more detail later.
Navigating the complexities of human rights law can be challenging for the average person. Here, we address some common questions to provide clarity.
While the terms are often used interchangeably, there is a subtle distinction. Human rights are fundamental, universal rights that are inalienable and apply to everyone. Civil liberties are rights and freedoms granted by a state to its citizens, often enshrined in a constitution or Bill of Rights. In the UK context, the HRA has blurred this line by incorporating universal human rights into domestic law, effectively making them a form of civil liberty that can be enforced in our courts.
Generally, the HRA only applies to public authorities. However, a private company can be considered a “hybrid public authority” if it is performing a public function. For example, a private company running a prison or a care home on behalf of a local authority could be held accountable under the HRA. Furthermore, the HRA’s protective effect can be felt indirectly in private disputes, as courts are required to interpret and develop common law principles in a way that is compatible with convention rights.
This is a common misconception. Human rights protect everyone, including those accused or convicted of a crime. This does not mean they are given special privileges; rather, it ensures that they are treated with basic dignity and fairness. For example, the right to a fair trial (Article 6) and the prohibition on inhuman or degrading treatment (Article 3) are essential safeguards that apply to all individuals, irrespective of their actions. These rights are designed to protect against state overreach and ensure due process for everyone.
Examining a real-world case provides a concrete understanding of how these legal principles are applied in practice.
At TSABI Law Firm (The Solicitors Advocates and Barristers Inc.), we have a deep understanding of human rights law and its application in England and Wales. We recognise that a breach of human rights can have a profound and distressing impact on an individual’s life. Our team of expert solicitors protect our clients’ fundamental freedoms and holding public authorities accountable.
We offer a comprehensive range of legal services in this field, including: