Home / News / Criminal Defence / Modern Slavery as a Statutory Defence in 2026 County Lines Cases

Modern Slavery as a Statutory Defence in 2026 County Lines Cases

09 May, 2026 | TSABI Team
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

Table Of Contents

The Legal Framework of Section 45 in England and Wales  +
The Statutory Test for Child Victims (Under 18) 
The Statutory Test for Adult Victims (18 and Over) 
Understanding County Lines and Criminal Exploitation  +
Indicators of Grooming and Coercion 
The Role of the National Referral Mechanism (NRM) 
Proving the Nexus: Linking Exploitation to the Offence  +
Challenging the Prosecution’s Disbelief of Victim Status 
Excluded Offences Under Schedule 4 
How TSABI Law Defends Victims of Exploitation  +
Expert Evidence and Psychological Assessments 
Courtroom Advocacy by TSABI Barristers 
Contact TSABI for Compassionate Legal Support 

Modern slavery in the context of “County Lines” drug trafficking involves the criminal exploitation of vulnerable individuals who are forced, groomed, or coerced into transporting and selling controlled substances. This exploitation often targets children and vulnerable adults, moving them across the country to establish new drug markets. The Section 45 statutory defence under the Modern Slavery Act 2015 provides a vital legal shield for these individuals, ensuring that victims are not wrongly criminalised for acts they were compelled to commit. 

At TSABI, we serve as a trusted partner for those facing the weight of the criminal justice system under these difficult circumstances. Our solicitors and barristers provide an inclusive and expert service, recognising the signs of exploitation that others might miss. We advocate for the rights of the vulnerable across England and Wales, using our deep legal knowledge to secure justice and protection for those caught in the grip of organised crime. 

The Modern Slavery Act 2015 introduced a specific statutory defence for individuals who commit crimes as a direct result of being a victim of slavery or exploitation. Under the Sentencing Act 2026, the courts place an even greater emphasis on identifying these circumstances early to prevent unnecessary imprisonment. The law makes a clear distinction between how it treats children (those under 18) and adults, acknowledging that younger individuals possess a higher level of inherent vulnerability. 

The Statutory Test for Child Victims (Under 18) 

For a child to rely on the Section 45 defence, the legal threshold is lower than it is for an adult. The court applies a two-part test: 

  1. Direct Consequence: The criminal act must be a direct consequence of the child being a victim of slavery or exploitation. 
  1. Reasonable Person Test: A reasonable person in the same situation, with the same relevant characteristics (such as age and background), would have committed the act. 

Crucially, for children, there is no requirement to prove “compulsion” or physical force. The law recognises that grooming and psychological manipulation are sufficient to remove the child’s free will. 

The Statutory Test for Adult Victims (18 and Over) 

Adults face a more rigorous three-stage test to successfully use the Section 45 defence: 

  • Compulsion: The person must have been compelled to commit the criminal act. 
  • Attributable to Exploitation: That compulsion must be directly linked to their status as a victim of slavery or trafficking. 
  • No Realistic Alternative: A reasonable person in the same situation would have felt they had no other choice but to comply. 

Understanding County Lines and Criminal Exploitation 

“County Lines” is a term used to describe urban gangs extending their drug-dealing operations into smaller towns and rural areas, often using a dedicated mobile phone line. This model relies on the exploitation of people from all backgrounds, including those facing economic hardship, mental health challenges, or social isolation. 

Indicators of Grooming and Coercion 

Recognising a victim of County Lines requires looking for specific indicators that suggest a lack of autonomy. These often include: 

  • Being in possession of multiple mobile phones or large amounts of unexplained cash. 
  • Frequent travel to unfamiliar areas with no clear purpose. 
  • Signs of physical harm or “debt bondage,” where a person is told they owe the gang money for lost drugs or “protection.” 
  • “Cuckooing,” where a vulnerable person’s home is taken over by the gang to store and deal drugs. 

The Role of the National Referral Mechanism (NRM) 

The National Referral Mechanism (NRM) is the UK’s framework for identifying and supporting victims of modern slavery. When a suspect is identified as a potential victim, they are referred to the Single Competent Authority (SCA). 

  • Reasonable Grounds: An initial decision made within days of referral. 
  • Conclusive Grounds: A final, more in-depth decision. 

A positive NRM decision is a powerful piece of evidence that our legal team uses to persuade the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) to discontinue a case before it even reaches trial. 

Proving the Nexus: Linking Exploitation to the Offence 

Simply being a victim of modern slavery does not automatically grant immunity for all crimes. The defence must prove a “nexus,” or a direct link, between the exploitation and the specific offence charged. In County Lines cases, we focus on proving that the individual was acting as a “runner” or “store” specifically because of the control exerted over them by the gang. 

Challenging the Prosecution’s Disbelief of Victim Status 

The prosecution often attempts to “adultify” young defendants or claim that an adult victim chose to participate for financial gain. We challenge this “culture of disbelief” by presenting a complete picture of the defendant’s life, highlighting the subtle psychological chains such as threats to family members that the prosecution often ignores. 

Excluded Offences Under Schedule 4 

It is important to note that the Section 45 defence is not available for certain serious crimes listed in Schedule 4 of the Modern Slavery Act 2015, such as murder, kidnapping, or serious sexual offences. However, it remains a robust defence for the drug supply and possession charges typical of County Lines operations. 

How TSABI Law Defends Victims of Exploitation 

At TSABI Law, we provide a specialist service for those wrongly accused while being exploited. TSABI provides an integrated legal defence through a unified team of solicitors and barristers. Our solicitors provide this service by identifying the signs of slavery at the police station, while our barristers provide the expert advocacy needed to present this defence in court. 

Expert Evidence and Psychological Assessments 

Our solicitors do not rely solely on the defendant’s word. We instruct independent forensic psychologists and social work experts to produce reports that document the trauma and coercion our clients have faced. This expert evidence is essential for satisfying the “reasonable person” test required by the court. 

Courtroom Advocacy by TSABI Barristers 

Our barristers are experts in cross-examining police officers and prosecution experts who may have missed the signs of trafficking. They ensure that the jury understands the reality of gang control, turning the focus from the criminal act to the criminal exploitation that caused it. 

If you or a loved one are being prosecuted for actions taken under duress or exploitation, you need a team that understands the nuances of the Modern Slavery Act. At TSABI, we offer a professional and reassuring environment where your story will be heard and your rights defended. Contact us today for a confidential consultation to discuss your defence strategy. 

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link