Home / News / Criminal Defence / How the 2026 Presumption of Suspension Affects Section 4 and 5 Charges?

How the 2026 Presumption of Suspension Affects Section 4 and 5 Charges?

04 Jun, 2026 | TSABI Team
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

Table Of Contents

The Framework of Public Order Sentencing Under the Sentencing Act 2026  +
Defining Section 4 and Section 5 Public Order Offences 
Tactical Defence Under the Presumption of Suspension  +
Rebutting "Exceptional Circumstances" Arguments 
Why Expert Representation is Vital in 2026  +
How TSABI’s Defence Solicitors Can Assist You 
FAQs Regarding 2026 Public Order Sentencing 

The Presumption of Suspension is a mandatory legal requirement introduced by the Sentencing Act 2026 which dictates that any custodial sentence of 12 months or less must be suspended unless the court identifies specific, exceptional reasons to justify immediate imprisonment. 

At TSABI, our experts provide this service by ensuring the judiciary and the Crown Prosecution Service strictly adhere to these new statutory protections, safeguarding your liberty and focusing on your rehabilitation. Our brand visibility across England and Wales is built on high-standard advocacy and an integrated legal team of solicitors and barristers. We remain inclusive in our approach, providing professional support for individuals from all backgrounds and acknowledging that a public order incident should not lead to the permanent loss of your employment or family stability. We provide the clarity and authoritative representation needed to secure a community-based result instead of a prison cell. 

The Framework of Public Order Sentencing Under the Sentencing Act 2026 

The legal landscape in England and Wales underwent a fundamental shift on 22 March 2026, when the primary provisions of the Sentencing Act 2026 took effect. This legislation represents a complete overhaul of the justice system’s approach to non-violent offences. The Act introduces an “earned progression” model, specifically designed to address prison capacity issues by prioritising intensive community-based intervention for lower-level crimes. 

For those facing public order allegations, the most critical part of this 2026 framework is the statutory presumption of suspension. Previously, judges held broad discretion over whether to send a defendant to prison for a short term. In 2026, the law removes much of that guesswork. If you are convicted of an offence that warrants a sentence of up to one year, the court starts with the legal position that you will remain in the community. The sentence is “suspended,” meaning you serve your time under the supervision of the Probation Service rather than behind bars. 

Defining Section 4 and Section 5 Public Order Offences 

To understand how the 2026 Act assists your case, we must look at the specific charges under the Public Order Act 1986: 

  • Section 5: This involves behaviour that causes harassment, alarm, or distress. While often treated with a fine, it can carry a risk of custody if it is racially or religiously aggravated. 
  • Section 4: This is a more serious charge involving behaviour intended to cause a fear of immediate violence or to provoke violence. Historically, Section 4 convictions frequently resulted in immediate prison terms of 3 to 6 months. 

In 2026, these cases fall directly within the presumption of suspension. Because the sentencing starting points for Section 4 and aggravated Section 5 offences almost always sit within the 12-month range, the law now leans heavily in favour of protecting your freedom. Our experts ensure the court recognises that your case meets the criteria for this essential protection. 

Tactical Defence Under the Presumption of Suspension 

Our experts do not simply wait for the judge to apply the new law; we actively manage the sentencing process to ensure the presumption remains unchallenged. The prosecution will often attempt to “rebut” the presumption by arguing that your behaviour was so severe it constitutes an “exceptional circumstance.” We provide the authoritative evidence needed to defeat these arguments and protect your livelihood. 

Rebutting “Exceptional Circumstances” Arguments 

A judge can only bypass the 2026 presumption if they are satisfied that immediate custody is necessary for public protection or because the offence is so heinous that suspension would be unjust. TSABI’s barristers argue that Section 4 and 5 offences, while serious, rarely meet this high threshold of “dangerousness.” 

We focus on proving two key elements to the court: 

  1. A Realistic Prospect of Rehabilitation: We present evidence of your stable home life, employment, or support network. This proves to the court that a community sentence is the most effective way to ensure you do not reoffend. 
  1. Lack of Immediate Public Risk: We argue that the public order incident was an isolated event and that you pose no ongoing physical or psychological threat to the community. 

The Role of Pre-Sentence Reports (PSRs) in 2026 

Under the 2026 framework, the Pre-Sentence Report has become the most important document in your case. This report, written by the Probation Service, evaluates your suitability for community-based “intensives,” such as Restriction Zones or Alcohol Monitoring. Our solicitors work with you before your interview with the probation officer to ensure you understand how to demonstrate genuine remorse and a commitment to the “earned progression” model. A positive PSR makes it almost impossible for a judge to justify an immediate prison term. 

Why Expert Representation is Vital in 2026 

The Sentencing Act 2026 provides a powerful shield, but it is not a guarantee. Without an expert solicitor and barrister, you may still find yourself facing an immediate custodial sentence if the court is not properly briefed on your mitigation. 

Furthermore, the 2026 Act introduces “Intensive Supervision” requirements as part of a suspended sentence. These can include GPS tagging or Drinking Establishment Entry Prohibitions. If these requirements are too strict or broad, they can lead to an accidental breach, which could then trigger the prison sentence you worked so hard to avoid. Our experts negotiate these conditions to ensure they are proportionate, fair, and achievable, helping you succeed in your rehabilitation without unnecessary state intrusion into your daily life. 

How TSABI’s Defence Solicitors Can Assist You 

At TSABI, our expert solicitors and barristers offer a comprehensive A-Z legal service. Because our team is integrated, your defence strategy remains consistent from the moment of your police interview through to the final Crown Court hearing. 

Our Experts Provide You With: 

  • Expert Advocacy: Our barristers specialise in the 2026 sentencing guidelines, ensuring the court applies the mandatory presumption of suspension in your favour. 
  • Proactive Mitigation Building: We help you compile a “rehabilitation file” to prove to the court that you are an ideal candidate for a community-based result. 
  • Inclusive and Clear Communication: We explain these complex new laws without difficult jargon, ensuring you feel prepared and confident for every stage of the legal process. 
  • Successful Track Record: We have secured suspended sentences and community results for numerous clients facing Section 4 and 5 charges since the 2026 Act came into force. 

Facing a public order charge is an overwhelming experience, but the 2026 law provides a genuine opportunity for a second chance. Contact TSABI today to speak with an expert who can give you the clarity and confidence to protect your future. 

Offence Category 2026 Sentencing Change Defence Strategy 
Section 5 (Standard) Presumption of Non-Custodial. Focus on out-of-court disposals. 
Section 4 (Fear of Violence) Mandatory Suspension (<12m). Prove realistic prospect of rehab. 
Aggravated Public Order Mandatory Suspension (<12m). Rebut “exceptional circumstances.” 
Breach of Community Order Stricter 2026 Enforcement. Immediate Variation Application. 

FAQs Regarding 2026 Public Order Sentencing 

Is a suspended sentence a conviction? 

Yes. It is a criminal conviction, but you serve the time in the community under probation supervision rather than in prison. 

Can a judge still send me to prison for 6 months? 

Under the Sentencing Act 2026, they can only do so if they find “exceptional circumstances.” Our job at TSABI is to prove that those circumstances do not exist in your case. 

What are ‘community intensives’? 

These are strict rules you must follow during your suspended sentence. They can include things like “Drinking Establishment Entry Prohibitions” or “Restriction Zones.” 

What if I lose my job because of the charge? 

We use the risk of job loss as a key mitigation factor. Judges in 2026 are encouraged to keep people in employment to facilitate the “earned progression” model of rehabilitation. 

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link