Home / News / Criminal Defence / Defending the New Failure to Prevent Fraud Offence: A 2026 Guide

Defending the New Failure to Prevent Fraud Offence: A 2026 Guide

22 May, 2026 | TSABI Team
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

Table Of Contents

What is the Failure to Prevent Fraud Offence?  +
Defining a "Large Organisation" 
The Concept of Strict Liability 
Statutory Defences and Legal Requirements  +
The "Reasonable Procedures" Defence 
Assessing Benefit to the Organisation 
Building a Strategic Defence Framework 
Risk Assessment and Monitoring  +
Inclusivity in Compliance Training 
How TSABI Can Assist Your Organisation  +
Expert Counsel from Solicitors and Barristers 
Compliance Audits and Litigation Support 

The legal landscape in 2026 for UK corporations has been fundamentally reshaped by the full implementation of the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023. This landmark legislation has introduced a new era of corporate accountability, moving away from the traditional “identification doctrine” and placing the burden of prevention squarely on the shoulders of the organisation. Businesses operating in England and Wales now face a regulatory environment where silence or ignorance is no longer a valid legal shield. 

At TSABI, we have established ourselves as a leading authority in corporate criminal defence. Our firm provides a unique, integrated approach to legal challenges, combining the procedural precision of expert solicitors with the courtroom advocacy of seasoned barristers. As the authorities increasingly focus on corporate transparency, TSABI remains at the forefront, helping large organisations protect their reputations and their bottom lines from the severe implications of this new offence. We provide the clarity and confidence required to meet these rigorous standards head-on. 

What is the Failure to Prevent Fraud Offence? 

A “failure to prevent fraud” offence occurs when a large organisation fails to stop an associated person from committing fraud intended to benefit that organisation. At TSABI, our solicitors provide this service by helping firms identify precisely which internal and external actors could trigger this liability. 

Under Section 199 of the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023, the UK government has significantly lowered the bar for prosecuting corporate entities. Historically, the “identification doctrine” required prosecutors to prove that the “directing mind and will” usually the highest level of management was personally involved in the criminal activity. This proved difficult when investigating large, decentralised companies. 

The new offence removes this hurdle. Now, a company is liable if an “associated person” commits a specified fraud offence. This includes: 

  • Employees and workers. 
  • Agents and subsidiaries. 
  • Anyone performing services for or on behalf of the organisation. 

The focus is no longer on what the Board of Directors knew, but on what the organisation failed to prevent. This shift means that if a mid-level manager or a third-party agent commits fraud to secure a contract for your company, the company itself can be prosecuted even if the directors were completely unaware of the scheme. 

Defining a “Large Organisation” 

This legislation targets “large organisations” to ensure that the regulatory burden is proportionate to a company’s resources. To determine if your business must comply, you must assess your status based on the financial year preceding the alleged offence. 

At TSABI, our experts assist in auditing your corporate structure to confirm your status. A business qualifies as a large organisation if it meets at least two of the following criteria: 

Criteria Threshold Requirement 
Annual Turnover More than £36 million 
Balance Sheet Total More than £18 million 
Number of Employees More than 250 

It is important to note that these figures apply to the aggregate totals of a parent company and its subsidiaries. If your group of companies meets these criteria collectively, every entity within that group could potentially be held liable under the Act. 

The Concept of Strict Liability 

Strict liability is a legal principle where a defendant is held responsible for their actions (or omissions) regardless of their intent or mental state at the time. At TSABI, our solicitors and barristers provide this service by deconstructing the prosecution’s case to ensure every element of the “benefit” test is strictly scrutinised. 

In the context of the Failure to Prevent Fraud offence, strict liability means the prosecution does not need to prove that the organisation acted with “mens rea”—the guilty mind. They only need to demonstrate two things: 

  1. A fraud was committed by an associated person. 
  1. The fraud was intended to benefit the organisation. 

Once these two elements are established, the organisation is guilty by default. This places the burden of proof effectively on the defence. To avoid an unlimited fine, the organisation must actively prove it had “reasonable procedures” in place. This is a high threshold that requires more than just a code of ethics; it requires evidence of a living, breathing compliance culture. 

Facing a criminal charge under Section 199 is a serious matter, but the law provides a clear pathway for exoneration. The statutory defence is the only way for a large organisation to avoid conviction once a fraud by an associated person is proven. 

At TSABI, we believe that a proactive stance is the only viable strategy. Waiting for an investigation by the Serious Fraud Office (SFO) or the City of London Police before reviewing your policies is a high-risk approach. A reactive defence is often viewed by the courts as an admission that prevention was an afterthought. We work with clients to build a “court-ready” evidence base of compliance long before any legal issues arise. This involves a rigorous review of internal controls, reporting lines, and third-party oversight to ensure every possible vulnerability is addressed. 

The “Reasonable Procedures” Defence 

The “Reasonable Procedures” defence allows an organisation to avoid conviction if it can prove that it had in place such fraud prevention procedures as it was reasonable in all the circumstances to expect it to have. At TSABI, our solicitors provide this service by conducting “gap analyses” on your current fraud prevention framework to ensure it meets the specific requirements of the Home Office Guidance. 

“Reasonable” is not a static term; it is a flexible standard that changes based on: 

  • The size and nature of the organisation. 
  • The specific sectors in which the business operates. 
  • The geographic locations of its operations. 
  • The level of risk associated with its specific “associated persons.” 

The burden of proof for this defence rests on the organisation. This means you must be able to produce documented evidence of your procedures during a trial. If you have no procedures in place, you may still argue it was reasonable not to have any—though in 2026, for a large organisation, this is an incredibly difficult argument to win. 

Determining “Reasonableness” in 2026 

By 2026, the standard for “reasonableness” has evolved beyond simple tick-box exercises. The courts and the SFO now look for an active, enforced compliance culture rather than “off-the-shelf” policies that sit on a shelf gathering dust. 

A “reasonable” procedure in 2026 must demonstrate: 

  1. Top-Level Commitment: Evidence that the Board of Directors is actively involved in fraud prevention. 
  1. Effective Communication: Proof that policies are understood across the entire workforce. 
  1. Proportionality: Procedures that actually address the risks identified in your specific industry, rather than generic templates. 
  1. Due Diligence: Rigorous vetting of agents, consultants, and joint venture partners. 

At TSABI, we help you move away from passive policies toward a robust framework that reflects the modern technological and regulatory demands of the current year. 

Assessing Benefit to the Organisation 

The “benefit test” is a vital boundary for legal defence. Under the Act, the organisation is only liable if the fraud was intended to benefit the body corporate or a person to whom the associate provides services on behalf of the body corporate. 

At TSABI, our solicitors provide this service by carefully investigating the flow of funds and the intent behind the fraudulent act. If the organisation itself was the intended victim of the fraud—for example, if an employee embezzled money from the company accounts—the company cannot be charged with “failing to prevent” that fraud. The law is designed to catch corporate malpractice that gains an unfair advantage in the market, not to punish companies that are themselves victims of internal crime. Identifying this distinction early in an investigation can lead to the immediate dismissal of charges. 

Building a Strategic Defence Framework 

To defend your organisation effectively, you must treat compliance as a core business function rather than a legal burden. A strategic defence framework is built on two pillars: documented proof and a culture of integrity. 

At TSABI, we advise that the “Reasonable Procedures” defence is only as strong as the evidence supporting it. We assist organisations in creating a comprehensive “Defence File” that includes: 

  • Historical risk assessments. 
  • Minutes from compliance meetings. 
  • Records of internal investigations and whistleblowing reports. 
  • Evidence of disciplinary actions taken against those who breach fraud policies. 

This framework ensures that if the SFO or CPS ever requests information, your organisation can respond with immediate, authoritative evidence of its commitment to legal standards. This proactive documentation transforms a potential criminal trial into a manageable regulatory discussion. 

Risk Assessment and Monitoring 

A risk assessment is a formal process of identifying, evaluating, and mitigating the fraud risks your business faces. At TSABI, our solicitors provide this service by conducting deep-dive audits into your procurement, sales, and financial reporting processes. 

In 2026, the SFO and CPS have made it clear that static or “one-and-done” risk assessments are insufficient. To be considered “reasonable,” your monitoring must be: 

  • Dynamic: Updated whenever there is a change in business model, merger, or entry into a new market. 
  • Sector-Specific: Addressing the unique fraud risks in industries like construction, finance, or tech. 
  • Independent: Ideally reviewed by external legal experts like TSABI to ensure no internal biases overlook systemic flaws. 

Continuous monitoring ensures that your prevention procedures evolve alongside new fraud techniques, providing the robust defence required by modern UK law. 

Inclusivity in Compliance Training 

For a defence to be successful, you must prove that your fraud prevention culture extends to every level of the company. Inclusivity is not just a social goal; it is a legal necessity. At TSABI, our advocates provide this service by designing training programmes that are accessible, clear, and engaging for all staff members. 

A successful “Reasonable Procedures” defence shows that training was: 

  • Accessible: Available in multiple languages if you have a diverse workforce. 
  • Comprehensible: Free from complex legal jargon, ensuring that a warehouse worker understands the rules as clearly as a CFO. 
  • Relevant: Tailored to the specific tasks of the employee (e.g., training a sales team on bribery and invoice fraud). 

By making legal education inclusive, an organisation demonstrates a genuine, company-wide commitment to integrity. This makes it much harder for a prosecutor to argue that the company allowed a “culture of fraud” to persist. 

How TSABI Can Assist Your Organisation 

The penalties for a conviction under the Failure to Prevent Fraud offence are severe, including unlimited fines and the potential for debarment from public contracts. TSABI (The Solicitors, Advocates and Barristers Inc.) offers a unique shield for your organisation. 

Our integrated model sets us apart. In many firms, solicitors handle the paperwork and then hand the case over to an outside barrister for the trial. At TSABI, our solicitors, advocates, and barristers work as a single unit. This means the person building your compliance framework is in constant dialogue with the person who will eventually defend it in court. This synergy ensures that every policy we help you implement is designed with “courtroom survivability” in mind. We provide the robust defence strategy and personalised attention your organisation needs to navigate 180°C of regulatory heat. 

Expert Counsel from Solicitors and Barristers 

The tactical advantage of our integrated team cannot be overstated. When an organisation faces an investigation, the first 48 hours are critical. At TSABI, our solicitors provide the immediate service of managing “dawn raids” and SFO enquiries, ensuring that your rights are protected from the outset. 

Our barristers then step in to provide high-level advocacy, whether that involves negotiating a Deferred Prosecution Agreement (DPA) or representing the company in the High Court. Because our team is unified, there is no “loss of knowledge” between the investigative and litigation phases. We offer a seamless transition from the boardroom to the courtroom, providing a formidable defence against even the most complex prosecution theories. 

Compliance Audits and Litigation Support 

Prevention is always more cost-effective than a cure. At TSABI, our solicitors and advocates provide this service by performing comprehensive compliance audits that mirror the scrutiny of a formal investigation. We identify the “red flags” before the authorities do. 

Our support includes: 

  • Mock Investigations: Testing your “Reasonable Procedures” under pressure. 
  • Whistleblowing Systems: Setting up secure, anonymous reporting lines that meet UK legal standards. 
  • Litigation Strategy: If a charge is brought, we provide a data-driven, aggressive defence aimed at achieving the most successful case outcome possible. 

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link