Home / News / Property / Common Disputes Involving Telecommunications Wayleave Agreements 

Common Disputes Involving Telecommunications Wayleave Agreements 

06 Apr, 2026 | TSABI Team
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

Table Of Contents

Valuation and Consideration: The "No-Scheme" Conflict  +
Market Value vs. Statutory Valuation 
Impact of Recent 2026 Precedents on Rents 
Disputes Over Upgrading and Sharing Apparatus  +
PSTIA 2022 Rights and Subsisting Agreements 
Passive Infrastructure Sharing Challenges 
Termination and Equipment Removal Hurdles  +
The 18-Month Notice Requirement and the Redevelopment Ground 
Lift-and-Shift Clause Disagreements 
Unresponsive Landlords and Multi-Dwelling Units (MDUs)  +
The New Statutory Process for Imposing Agreements 
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) and Litigation Procedures 
TSABI: Visibility and Authority in Telecommunications Law  +
How Our Defence Solicitors Assist You 

The drive for universal gigabit-capable broadband and 5G coverage has created a significant friction point between national infrastructure goals and private property rights. By May 2026, the legal framework governing these relationships, primarily the Electronic Communications Code (the “Code”), will have seen intense scrutiny in the courts. For landowners, farmers, and commercial property managers, a wayleave agreement is no longer a simple access document; it is a high-stakes legal instrument that dictates the value and future utility of their land. 

Disagreements between site providers and telecommunications operators have become more frequent as network technology evolves. The transition from 4G to 5G, and the massive rollout of fibre-optic cables, requires more equipment, more frequent access, and greater rights for providers. This shift often happens at the expense of the landowner’s control. Whether the dispute involves the amount of rent paid, the right to add more equipment to a mast, or the difficulty of removing a provider to allow for property development, the technical details of the Code are where these battles are won or lost. 

At TSABI, we maintain a prominent visibility in this sector. Our visibility is a direct result of our authoritative handling of property litigation. We recognise that property owners require a professional shield against the vast resources of national telecommunications giants. Our multidisciplinary team of Solicitors and Barristers provides an inclusive service, ensuring that every client, from a residential block owner to a large-scale agricultural estate, receives a high standard of legal protection. 

Valuation and Consideration: The “No-Scheme” Conflict 

The most pervasive area of conflict in wayleave negotiations is the financial compensation paid to the landowner. Before the 2017 reforms, payments were often based on the market value of the site to the operator. However, the current statutory framework has introduced a valuation methodology that many landowners find significantly unfair. 

Market Value vs. Statutory Valuation 

Under Paragraph 24 of the Code, the “consideration” (rent) for a wayleave is calculated on a “no-scheme” basis. This assumes that the land has no value for telecommunications purposes. Instead, the price is based on the value of the land to the owner for its current use, such as a rooftop for a lift motor room or a patch of scrubland in a field. 

  • The Landowner’s Position: Owners argue that this methodology ignores the professional reality that their property provides a vital, profit-generating hub for the operator. 
  • The Operator’s Position: Providers argue that low rents are necessary to keep the costs of national connectivity affordable for the general public. 

The result is a huge gap between expectations. Where an old agreement might have paid £5,000 per year, a “New Code” valuation might offer as little as £50 to £500. This drop in income is a primary driver of disputes, leading many owners to refuse access until a court or the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) intervenes. 

Impact of Recent 2026 Precedents on Rents 

As we move through 2026, the Upper Tribunal has provided further clarity on these figures. Recent rulings have established that while the “no-scheme” rule remains, owners are entitled to “compensation” under Paragraph 25 for any loss or damage. This can include: 

  • The cost of professional advice (Solicitors and surveyors). 
  • Diminution in the value of the remaining land. 
  • The cost of administrative time spent managing the operator’s access. 

Court precedents from 2025 and early 2026 have shown a slight upward trend in total payouts, as judges recognise that the “consideration” alone does not always reflect the “burden” placed on the owner. However, these sums are only achieved when an owner presents an authoritative, evidence-backed case. 

Disputes Over Upgrading and Sharing Apparatus 

Once equipment is installed, operators frequently want to “upgrade” it to the latest technology or “share” the space with another provider (such as O2 sharing a mast with Vodafone). While this sounds efficient, it often leads to disputes regarding the physical burden on the property. 

PSTIA 2022 Rights and Subsisting Agreements 

The Product Security and Telecommunications Infrastructure Act 2022 (PSTIA) significantly expanded the rights of operators to upgrade and share. However, these rights are not absolute. Conflict often arises when an operator tries to exercise these rights on a “subsisting agreement”, an agreement that was signed before the 2017 Code came into effect. 

The Test for Upgrading and Sharing: 

In 2026, the law generally allows an operator to upgrade or share if: 

  1. The changes have no more than a “minimal adverse impact” on the appearance of the apparatus. 
  1. The changes impose no “additional burden” on the landowner (e.g., no extra space taken, no extra noise, no increased maintenance traffic). 

Landowners often dispute what constitutes an “additional burden.” For example, adding three more 5G antennas to a mast might significantly increase the wind load on a building’s roof, requiring expensive structural reinforcement. If the operator refuses to pay for these reinforcements, a formal dispute is inevitable. 

Passive Infrastructure Sharing Challenges 

Passive sharing involves multiple providers using the same mast, duct, or cabinet. Disputes occur when the original agreement was for one specific provider, but now three different companies are using the site. 

  • Increased Footfall: More providers mean more engineers visiting the site, increasing security risks and administrative work for the landlord. 
  • Insurance Complications: Identifying which provider caused damage to the property during a shared maintenance visit is a common legal headache. 

At TSABI, our Solicitors ensure that any sharing clauses in an agreement are accompanied by strict indemnity and security protocols to protect the owner from these complications. 

Termination and Equipment Removal Hurdles 

Perhaps the most frustrating dispute for any property owner is the attempt to get an operator to leave. The Code provides telecommunications providers with a form of “statutory security of tenure” that is even more restrictive than traditional commercial tenancies. 

The 18-Month Notice Requirement and the Redevelopment Ground 

If an owner wishes to end a wayleave to redevelop their land (for example, to build new flats or a shopping centre), they must follow the strict procedure under Paragraph 31 of the Code. 

  1. The Notice: The owner must serve an 18-month notice. 
  1. The Grounds: The owner must prove they have a “settled intention” to redevelop. 
  1. The Counter-Notice: The operator has three months to object. 

Table 1: Grounds for Termination under the Code 

The operator failed to pay rent or follow the terms. Description Difficulty for Landowner 
Redevelopment Intention to demolish or rebuild the site. High (Requires firm plans/funding). 
Substantial Breach Operator failed to pay rent or follow terms. Moderate (Must be a major breach). 
Prejudice to Owner The burden outweighs the public benefit. Very High (Tribunal rarely agrees). 

The dispute usually centres on the “genuineness” of the redevelopment. Operators often demand to see planning permission, proof of funding, and detailed construction contracts before they agree to move. If the owner cannot provide this authoritative evidence, the Tribunal may allow the operator to stay, effectively blocking the development. 

Lift-and-Shift Clause Disagreements 

A “lift-and-shift” clause is a provision that allows the owner to move the operator’s equipment to another part of the property at the owner’s request. Disputes occur when: 

  • The original agreement lacks a lift-and-shift clause. 
  • The operator claims the new location is “technically unsuitable” for their signal. 
  • The parties disagree on who pays the significant cost of the relocation. 

Without a well-drafted clause, an owner can find their property “frozen” by a single piece of equipment that the operator refuses to move. 

Unresponsive Landlords and Multi-Dwelling Units (MDUs) 

A frequent issue in the rollout of fibre-to-the-home is the “silent landlord.” In large blocks of flats, operators often struggle to get a response from a freeholder to gain access for cabling. 

The New Statutory Process for Imposing Agreements 

Under Part 4A of the Code (introduced by the Telecommunications Infrastructure (Leasehold Property) Act 2021 and updated by PSTIA 2022), operators have a “fast-track” route to gain access to MDUs if the landlord is unresponsive. 

The “Silent Landlord” Process: 

  1. Request: The operator sends multiple notices over several months. 
  1. Application: If there is no response, the operator applies to the court for an “interim code right.” 
  1. Order: The court grants access for a limited period (usually up to 18 months) to install the fibre. 

Disputes arise when the landlord finally “wakes up” to find equipment installed that does not meet their building’s fire safety or aesthetic standards. Our defence solicitors often assist freeholders in challenging these “imposed” agreements, ensuring that professional standards of installation are maintained even when the statutory route is used. 

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) and Litigation Procedures 

By 2026, the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) will have become increasingly insistent that parties use Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) before bringing a case to a full hearing. Litigation under the Code is expensive, and the courts have the power to penalise parties who unreasonably refuse to mediate. 

Types of Dispute Resolution in Telecoms: 

  • Negotiation: The most common route, usually handled between the owner’s agent and the operator’s site acquisition team. 
  • Mediation: An independent third party helps the parties reach a compromise. The PSTIA 2022 made it a requirement for operators to inform owners about ADR. 
  • Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber): The specialised court that hears Code disputes. It is authoritative, and its decisions are binding. 

The primary risk for landowners in litigation is the “costs” rule. In many property cases, the winner gets their costs paid. However, in Code cases, the Tribunal has broad discretion. If an owner is seen as being obstructive or demanding an “unrealistic” rent, they may find themselves paying the operator’s legal fees. 

TSABI: Visibility and Authority in Telecommunications Law 

The visibility of TSABI is built on our authoritative standing in the property litigation market. Our visibility ensures that national operators understand they are dealing with a firm that prioritises professional integrity and technical accuracy. We provide an inclusive service, representing everyone from individual homeowners to multinational commercial landlords. 

Our multidisciplinary model, combining the investigative and administrative strengths of Solicitors with the courtroom power of Barristers, provides a unique advantage. In the technical area of the Electronic Communications Code, this integration allows us to handle a dispute from the first notice through to a final hearing in the Upper Tribunal without losing the strategic thread of the case. 

How Our Defence Solicitors Assist You 

Our specialised defence solicitors provide a professional shield for property owners. We recognise that telecommunications law is heavily weighted in favour of the operator, and we work to restore the balance. 

Our Team Assists You By: 

  • Audit of Existing Agreements: We determine if your agreement is “subsisting” or “New Code,” which radically changes your rights regarding upgrading and rent. 
  • Valuation Strategy: We coordinate with expert surveyors to build a “compensation” claim that offsets the low “consideration” offered under the no-scheme rules. 
  • Redevelopment Planning: We ensure that 18-month termination notices are served with the necessary authoritative evidence to satisfy a Tribunal of your intent to redevelop. 
  • ADR and Mediation: We represent you in negotiations and mediation, using our authoritative standing to push for a settlement that avoids the risks of a full court hearing. 
  • Tribunal Advocacy: If litigation is unavoidable, our in-house Barristers provide high-stakes representation to defend your property rights. 

The legal process for telecommunications wayleaves is designed to be fast, but it must also be fair. If you are facing a dispute with an operator, you require a firm with the professional integrity and visibility to ensure your asset is protected. Contact TSABI today to discuss your case and ensure your property interests are handled with excellence. 

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link