FAQ
Home / FAQs / Probate / What Happens if a Will Is Proved to Be Fraudulent?

What Happens if a Will Is Proved to Be Fraudulent?

A Will proven to be fraudulent is treated by the court as a legal nullity, meaning it is void ab initio as if it had never existed, triggering the immediate revocation of any Grant of Probate and opening the door for asset recovery and criminal prosecution. Unlike a Will that is merely contested due to a misunderstanding, a fraudulent Will involves a deliberate and dishonest act designed to deceive the testator or the court. The discovery of such an act sets in motion a rigorous judicial process aimed at restoring the estate to its rightful beneficiaries and ensuring that those who perpetrated the fraud face the full weight of both civil and criminal liability. 

Defining the Two Faces of Will Fraud: Forgery vs. Fraudulent Calumny 

“Fraud” in the context of a Will falls into two distinct categories. While both result in the invalidity of the document, they require different types of evidence to prove in the Chancery Division of the High Court. At TSABI, our forensic approach allows us to distinguish between these categories early in the investigation to build a robust litigation strategy. 

Forgery and False Execution 

This is the “mechanical” aspect of fraud. It involves the literal faking of the testator’s signature or the signatures of the witnesses. It can also include the “cutting and pasting” of pages or the insertion of fraudulent clauses into a genuine document after it has been signed. Proving forgery requires expert handwriting analysis and a detailed audit of the original document. Because TSABI houses expert advocates with a background in criminal defence, we are uniquely skilled at identifying the “chain of custody” failures that often accompany forged documents. 

Fraudulent Calumny 

This is a more subtle, psychological form of fraud. It occurs when a person “poisons the mind” of the testator by making dishonest and disparaging comments about a natural beneficiary (such as a child or spouse) to ensure they are disinherited. To prove fraudulent calumny, it must be shown that the person making the false claims knew they were false, or was reckless as to their truth. This is distinct from undue influence, as it relies on deception rather than pressure. 

The Procedural Fallout: Revoking the Grant of Probate 

When fraud is suspected after an estate has already begun to be administered, the priority is to halt the process. If a Grant of Probate has already been issued, the court must be petitioned to revoke it. 

Issuing a Claim for Revocation 

If the Probate Registry has already granted the executors power to deal with the assets, a claim must be issued to set aside the grant. Once the court is satisfied that there is a prima facie case of fraud, the executors’ powers are suspended. At TSABI, we act with strategic precision to ensure that a caveat is lodged or an injunction is sought to prevent the further dissipation of assets while the case is litigated. 

Reverting to a Prior Will or Intestacy 

Once the fraudulent Will is struck down, the estate does not simply vanish. The court will look to see if there is a previous valid Will. If one exists, it is reinstated. If no prior valid Will can be found, the estate is distributed according to the Rules of Intestacy. This ensures that the testator’s true intentions or the statutory default are honoured instead of the fraudster’s design. 

Comparison Table: Fraudulent Calumny vs. Undue Influence 

Claimants need to understand which legal path they are taking. The following table highlights the key differences between these two often-confused grounds. 

Feature Fraudulent Calumny Undue Influence 
Core Element Deception: Lying about a third party. Coercion: Overpowering the testator’s will. 
Testator’s Mindset They believe the lie and act “freely” on it. They may know the act is wrong but feel they have no choice. 
Burden of Proof High: Must prove the person knew the statement was false. High: Must prove the testator’s will was overborne. 
Strategy Focuses on proving the falsity of the information. Focuses on proving the vulnerability and pressure. 
TSABI Approach Forensic investigation into communications and motives. Robust advocacy regarding the testator’s social isolation. 

Asset Recovery and the Principle of Restitution 

If a fraudster has already spent the inheritance, the legal battle moves into the realm of asset recovery and civil restitution. A fraudster does not gain a good title to assets obtained through a void Will. 

  1. Clawback Actions: The rightful executors can bring claims against the fraudster to recover the specific assets or their equivalent value. 
  1. Tracing Assets: If the fraudster has used the money to purchase a house or other property, the law of Equity allows for the “tracing” of those funds into the new asset. 
  1. Personal Liability: Executors who were part of the fraud are personally liable for the losses to the estate. At TSABI, we utilise our civil litigation mastery to pursue these individuals, ensuring that the quantum of loss is fully recovered. 
  1. Third-Party Recovery: If assets were sold to third parties who were aware of the fraud, those transactions can sometimes be unwound under the principles of unjust enrichment. 

Criminal Implications: The Interface with the State 

Fraud in a Will is not just a private dispute; it is a criminal offence. In England and Wales, those involved in creating or using a fraudulent Will can face significant prison sentences. 

The Forgery and Counterfeiting Act 1981 

Creating a false document with the intent to use it to someone’s prejudice is a crime. This applies to the person who faked the signature and anyone who “uttered” (presented) the document as genuine. TSABI’s criminal defence background allows us to advise clients on how to refer these matters to the Police and the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) effectively. 

The Fraud Act 2006 

Under Section 2 (Fraud by false representation) or Section 4 (Fraud by abuse of position), an executor or beneficiary can be prosecuted for dishonestly seeking a gain for themselves or causing a loss to another. Our unified legal model means that while we are fighting the civil case in the High Court, we can also manage the complex interface with criminal investigators, providing a comprehensive legal shield for our clients. 

How TSABI Secures Your Justice 

Proving fraud requires a level of tenacious advocacy and forensic detail that standard probate firms often lack. TSABI provides an elite advantage through our fused legal structure. 

The Unified Advantage of In-House Barristers 

At TSABI, we do not just prepare the paperwork and send it off to an external set of chambers. We have Solicitors, Solicitor Advocates, and Barristers working as a single unit. This unified model means that the strategic precision required for a fraud case is maintained from the moment you walk into our office until the final day of trial. Our in-house barristers are trial-ready, meaning we can move from discovery to a High Court hearing with incredible speed, preventing fraudsters from hiding assets. 

Multidisciplinary Expertise in Property and Criminal Law 

Fraudulent Wills often involve complex property transfers or landlord and tenant disputes within an estate. Because TSABI has leading departments in Property Law and Civil Litigation, we can untangle these issues simultaneously. 

  • Our property specialists can handle the “rectification of the land register” if a house was fraudulently transferred. 
  • Our criminal defence team understands how to cross-examine a fraudster to expose inconsistencies that a purely civil lawyer might miss. 
  • Our solicitors provide the empathetic support and fiduciary integrity needed to guide you through the emotional turmoil of a family fraud. 

Robust Representation and Litigation Risk Management 

We understand that litigation is a “high-stakes” environment. TSABI focuses on litigation risk management, providing you with a clear assessment of the costs versus the likely recovery. Our reputation for robust representation in the Chancery Division sends a clear message to the opposition: we have the advocacy power to see the case through to a successful conclusion. 

Why Immediate Action is Critical 

When a Will is fraudulent, time is the fraudster’s greatest ally. As days pass, money is spent, property is sold, and evidence is destroyed. The court has the power to set things right, but it requires a proactive and legal team to trigger those powers. 

By choosing TSABI, you are engaging a firm that combines clinical legal expertise with the firepower of seasoned trial advocates. We provide the authoritative representation needed to dismantle a fraudulent estate and ensure that the rightful beneficiaries receive what they are owed. If you suspect a Will has been forged or that a loved one was the victim of fraudulent calumny, do not wait. Contact TSABI today and let our solicitors, advocates, and barristers provide the bespoke legal strategy your case deserves. 

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
What Are the Legal Duties of a Will Trustee?
A Will Trustee is the designated legal custodian appointed under a last will to hold, manage, and protect specific assets for the benefit of third parties after the initial estate administration is...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Is a Trustee Different From an Executor?
The fundamental difference between an executor and a trustee lies in the temporal scope and the specific statutory objectives of their roles: the executor is the short-term officer responsible for...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can a Beneficiary Also Act as a Will Trustee?
A beneficiary acting as a Will Trustee is a dual-role fiduciary arrangement where an individual holds the legal title to trust assets while simultaneously possessing a beneficial interest in the residue of...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Many Trustees Should Be Appointed in a Will?
Will Trustees are the individuals or corporate entities legally appointed within a last will to hold, manage, and protect specific assets known as the trust fund for the benefit of...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Happens if a Will Trustee Dies or Resigns?
The death or resignation of a Will Trustee triggers a formal process of fiduciary succession, governed primarily by the Trustee Act 1925, to ensure the continuous management of trust assets...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link