FAQ
Home / FAQs / Probate / How Are Legal Costs Handled in Contentious Probate Cases?

How Are Legal Costs Handled in Contentious Probate Cases?

The default position that the losing party must pay the winner’s legal fees often takes a back seat in the specialised world of probate litigation, where the court’s primary concern is the justice of the distribution and the clarity of the deceased’s final wishes. 

Legal costs in contentious probate are not merely a secondary concern; they are a central component of litigation strategy. While the general rule in civil law suggests that “costs follow the event,” probate courts wield extensive judicial discretion to depart from this rule, sometimes ordering that all parties have their costs paid directly from the estate assets. Understanding these nuances is the first step in effective litigation risk management. 

The Fundamental Principle: Costs Follow the Event 

The starting point for any discussion on legal fees in the High Court or County Court is CPR Part 44. This rule establishes that the unsuccessful party will usually be ordered to pay the costs of the successful party. However, this is never a guaranteed outcome. The court considers the conduct of all parties, whether a party has succeeded on part of their case even if they lost the overall claim, and any admissible settlement offers made during the proceedings. 

The Standard Basis vs. The Indemnity Basis 

When the court orders one party to pay another, it usually does so on the standard basis. This means the court will only allow costs that are proportionate and reasonably incurred, with any doubt resolved in favor of the paying party. This typically results in the winner recovering between 60 percent and 70 percent of their actual spend. In cases of unreasonable conduct or the pursuit of a speculative claim, the court may award costs on the indemnity basis. Under this higher threshold, proportionality is ignored, and any doubt is resolved in favor of the receiving party, often leading to a recovery of 90 percent or more. At TSABI, we focus on cost-benefit analysis from the outset to ensure our clients are not left with a significant “shortfall.” 

The Probate Exceptions: When the Estate Pays 

Contentious probate is unique because it often involves documents that are ambiguous or naturally suspicious circumstances. Two major exceptions to the “loser pays” rule were established in the landmark case of Spiers v English, and they remain the theoretical bedrock of cost allocation in England and Wales today. 

The Testator’s Fault Exception 

If the dispute was caused by the testator’s own actions—for example, if they left a Will that was so poorly drafted or ambiguous that it made litigation inevitable—the court may order that the costs of all parties be paid out of the estate. The theory here is that the estate should bear the burden of clarifying the testator’s confusion. This is common in cases involving homemade Wills or those with conflicting codicils. 

The Reasonable Inquiry Exception 

The court may also depart from the general rule if the circumstances surrounding the execution of the Will were so suspicious that they demanded an investigation. If a claimant has reasonable grounds to suspect a lack of testamentary capacity or undue influence, the court may order that each party pays their own costs (no order as to costs), even if the challenge ultimately fails. This protects individuals who act in good faith to protect the integrity of a deceased person’s wishes. 

Comparison Table: Allocation of Costs in Probate Disputes 

Scenario General Cost Outcome Legal Rationale 
Successful Challenge Defendant (Executor/Beneficiary) pays Claimant. The “loser pays” rule under CPR Part 44. 
Unsuccessful but Reasonable Challenge Each party pays their own costs. The Reasonable Inquiry exception from Spiers v English. 
Ambiguous Will Drafting All costs paid from the Estate Assets. The Testator’s Fault exception; clarification is for the estate’s benefit. 
Unreasonable or Hostile Conduct Losing party pays on the indemnity basis. Penalty for litigation misconduct or refusing Mediation. 
Successful Part 36 Offer Enhanced interest and costs. Reward for a proactive settlement strategy. 

Strategic Risk Management: Part 36 and Mediation 

The court heavily penalises those who refuse to engage in Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). Contentious probate is emotionally charged, but the court expects a clinical approach to settlement. 

The Power of Part 36 Offers 

A Part 36 offer is a high-level tactical tool used to put pressure on the opposing side. If a claimant makes a Part 36 offer and the defendant rejects it, but the claimant later achieves a result at trial that is “as good as or better” than their offer, the defendant faces severe financial penalties. These include paying interest on the judgment and paying the claimant’s costs on an indemnity basis from the date the offer expired. At TSABI, our solicitor advocates and barristers specialise in calibrating these offers to maximise fiduciary integrity and minimise risk. 

Costs Sanctions for Refusal to Mediate 

The court may order a winning party to pay their own costs if they unreasonably refused to attend Mediation. We believe that bespoke advocacy includes knowing when to sit at the negotiating table. By resolving disputes through mediation, TSABI often saves the estate from being entirely consumed by the quantum of legal fees that a High Court trial would generate. 

Funding the Fight: CFAs and ATE Insurance 

Not every client has the immediate liquidity to fund a multi-year dispute. We explore various bespoke legal solutions to ensure that a lack of upfront capital does not prevent a valid claim from moving forward. 

  • Conditional Fee Agreements (CFAs): Often known as “no win, no fee,” these allow a client to pay only a discounted rate or nothing at all if the case is lost. If won, a success fee is payable. 
  • ATE (After the Event) Insurance: This covers the risk of having to pay the other side’s costs if you lose. It provides litigation risk mitigation and is often essential in high-stakes contentious probate. 
  • Third-Party Funding: In very large estates, external funders may provide the capital in exchange for a percentage of the recovery. 

Why TSABI is Your Strategic Partner 

Navigating the financial labyrinth of probate litigation requires a firm that is more than just a provider of legal documents; it requires a unified litigation powerhouse. TSABI is uniquely structured to protect your financial interests in the courts.

The Fused Advantage of In-House Barristers 

Traditional law firms are often forced to “outsource” to external barristers’ chambers for opinions and court representation. This adds an extra layer of disbursements and VAT, and often leads to a “double-handling” of fees. At TSABI, our Solicitors, Solicitor Advocates, and Barristers work in the same office on a single team. This unified model means that we provide authoritative representation with a single, transparent fee structure. Because our barristers are involved from day one, we avoid the costly “learning curve” that happens when external counsel is brought in late in the day. 

Multidisciplinary Expertise and Forensic Precision 

Contentious probate often involves assets beyond simple cash, including commercial property, rental portfolios, and landlord and tenant disputes. 

  1. Property Mastery: Our in-house property litigation team ensures that when costs are ordered out of the estate, the liquidation of property assets is handled with strategic precision to maximise value. 
  1. Criminal Mindset: Our criminal defence specialists provide a forensic edge when investigating executor fraud or forgery, ensuring that the evidence we present is “trial-ready.” 
  1. Civil Litigation Power: We treat probate like the high-stakes civil litigation it is. We don’t just “administer” estates; we robustly represent our clients to ensure the burden of costs falls on the correct party. 

Protecting the Estate with Professional Integrity 

At TSABI, we understand that for many, a contentious probate claim is about more than money; it is about legacy. However, a legacy can be easily destroyed by unchecked legal spending. Our in-house advocates focus on proactive risk management, ensuring that every pound spent is a pound invested in a successful outcome. We are dedicated to providing the bespoke legal strategies and tenacious advocacy required to ensure that your inheritance is not swallowed by the process of claiming it. 

Securing Your Financial Position 

The handling of legal costs is a complex interplay of statutory rules and judicial discretion. Whether you are a claimant seeking your rightful share or an executor defending a Will, the financial risks are significant. 

By engaging TSABI, you are not just hiring a solicitor; you are securing a multidisciplinary team of advocates and barristers who understand how to win the “costs battle” as well as the legal one. We provide the strategic precision and robust representation needed to navigate these waters, ensuring that the quantum of loss to the estate is minimised and your financial future is protected. Contact TSABI today for a consultation with our contentious probate experts. 

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
What Are the Legal Duties of a Will Trustee?
A Will Trustee is the designated legal custodian appointed under a last will to hold, manage, and protect specific assets for the benefit of third parties after the initial estate administration is...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Is a Trustee Different From an Executor?
The fundamental difference between an executor and a trustee lies in the temporal scope and the specific statutory objectives of their roles: the executor is the short-term officer responsible for...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can a Beneficiary Also Act as a Will Trustee?
A beneficiary acting as a Will Trustee is a dual-role fiduciary arrangement where an individual holds the legal title to trust assets while simultaneously possessing a beneficial interest in the residue of...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Many Trustees Should Be Appointed in a Will?
Will Trustees are the individuals or corporate entities legally appointed within a last will to hold, manage, and protect specific assets known as the trust fund for the benefit of...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Happens if a Will Trustee Dies or Resigns?
The death or resignation of a Will Trustee triggers a formal process of fiduciary succession, governed primarily by the Trustee Act 1925, to ensure the continuous management of trust assets...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link