Discriminating against a tenant with children is a complex area of law because “family status” is not explicitly listed as a protected characteristic under the Equality Act 2010. However, a blanket “no children” policy almost always constitutes indirect discrimination on the basis of sex. The legal rationale is that women are disproportionately more likely to live with children than men and, therefore, a policy that disadvantages tenants with children has a greater impact on women. Such a policy is, therefore, unlawful unless the landlord can prove that it is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim, which is a very high legal hurdle to clear.
‘Family status’ is not a protected characteristic under the Equality Act 2010. However, discrimination against families is often linked to the protected characteristic of pregnancy and maternity. The Act protects a woman from discrimination for 26 weeks after she gives birth, and a refusal to let a property to a mother and her newborn could constitute direct discrimination. Beyond this, as explained above, a blanket ban on children is most likely to be treated as indirect discrimination on the grounds of sex. Legal rulings and guidance from bodies like the Property Ombudsman have reinforced this position, stating that a “no kids” specification can breach equality rules because it disproportionately affects women.
The legal position on pets is distinct from that of children. Having a pet is not a protected characteristic. Historically, landlords have had the right to include a “no pets” clause in tenancy agreements, and it was a common practice. However, this position has been fundamentally altered by new legislative reforms. The legal framework now reflects the growing understanding of the importance of pets in people’s lives and aims to make renting with pets easier.
Prior to recent reforms, a blanket “no pets” clause was generally lawful. The Renters Reform Bill (and related legislation) has now established a new legal framework that gives tenants a right to request a pet. A landlord’s refusal must be reasonable. This change will be implemented through an implied term in all new assured shorthold tenancies, meaning that a landlord cannot unreasonably withhold consent for a tenant’s pet request.
The Renters Reform Bill introduces a statutory process for pets in tenancies. A tenant must make a request in writing, and the landlord has 42 days to respond. The landlord can only refuse the request if they have a “good reason.” What constitutes a good reason is not exhaustively defined but can include:
Crucially, the law allows a landlord to require a tenant to take out pet damage insurance to cover potential damage. This new framework means that a tenant can challenge an unreasonable refusal through the new Private Rented Sector Ombudsman or the courts, making blanket bans a thing of the past. It is important to note, however, that this right is for existing tenants, not for applicants. Therefore, a landlord can still advertise a property with a “no pets” policy, but as soon as a tenancy is established, a tenant can make a request to have a pet.
The legal risks for a landlord who fails to comply with the Equality Act or the new regulations on pets are significant and can lead to financial penalties and legal action.
A landlord with a blanket ‘no-children’ policy risks a claim of unlawful indirect discrimination. If a female applicant with a child is rejected, she could bring a claim to the county court. If the court finds in her favour, the landlord could be ordered to pay damages for injury to feelings and any financial losses incurred by the applicant. These awards can be substantial, often falling into specific bands based on the severity of the discrimination. The landlord would also face legal costs.
Similarly, an unreasonable refusal of a pet request under the new rules could lead to a tenant challenging the decision through the courts, where the landlord may be forced to grant consent and potentially face legal costs.
Let’s consider a landlord, Mr. Thompson, who owns a ground floor flat. He advertises the property with the phrase “ideal for a single professional or couple, no children or pets allowed.”
The legal landscape surrounding children and pets is complex and evolving. A lack of up-to-date knowledge can lead to significant legal and financial consequences for landlords. At TSABI, our team of expert solicitors, advocates, and barristers is uniquely equipped to provide comprehensive legal support on all matters related to these issues.
For Landlords: We offer proactive legal advice to ensure your tenancy agreements and tenant selection processes are fully compliant with the Equality Act 2010 and the new legislation on pets. We can review your policies, advise on advertising language, and help you establish fair and defensible criteria for tenancy applications. If a claim is made against you, we provide a robust legal defence, ensuring your case is presented with precision and expertise.
For Tenants: If you believe you have been subjected to unlawful discrimination on the basis of having children, or if your request for a pet has been unreasonably refused, we can provide expert advice and representation. We will assess the merits of your claim, help you gather the necessary evidence, and represent you in court to ensure your rights are upheld and you receive the compensation you are entitled to.