In the legal system of England and Wales, the power of the police to enter a private home or business is considered one of the most intrusive powers the state possesses. Because a search warrant is typically obtained via an ex parte application meaning the person being searched is not present to argue their side the law imposes a rigorous ethical and legal burden on the police. This is known as the duty of full and frank disclosure, or the duty of candour.
At TSABI, we recognize that a search warrant is often the “front line” of a criminal investigation. If the police fail in their duty to be honest and comprehensive with the court, the warrant may be declared unlawful. Our solicitors are experts in identifying these failures to protect clients facing the most serious allegations, from murder and manslaughter to complex motoring offences.
The duty of full and frank disclosure requires that any party applying for an order without notice to the other side must provide the court with all relevant information, including facts that might militate against the granting of the order. In the context of a search warrant, this means the police cannot simply “cherry-pick” the evidence that makes a suspect look guilty; they must also disclose information that suggests the suspect might be innocent or that a search is unnecessary.
This duty is rooted in the principle of uberrima fides (of the utmost good faith). Because the Magistrate or Judge only hears one side of the story, they rely entirely on the police to act as “ministers of justice” rather than just advocates for a prosecution.
A breach occurs when the police omit material facts from their application. A fact is “material” if it might have influenced the Magistrate’s decision to grant the warrant.
If TSABI suspects that a search warrant was obtained through a lack of candour, we do not simply wait for the trial. We initiate a Judicial Review in the Administrative Court (High Court).
The following table highlights the difference between a constitutionally sound application and one that TSABI would challenge in the High Court.
| Feature | Lawful Application | Unlawful (Non-Disclosed) Application |
| Evidence Presentation | Balanced view of all known facts. | One-sided; highlights only “incriminating” facts. |
| Source Integrity | Discloses if an informant is paid or unreliable. | Presents informant as 100% credible without context. |
| Necessity Test | Proves why a search is the last resort. | Fails to mention that the suspect is cooperating. |
| Statutory Compliance | Mentions potential for privileged material. | Conceals the nature of the business (e.g., a law firm). |
| Legal Outcome | Warrant is upheld; evidence is admissible. | Warrant is quashed; evidence may be suppressed. |
When a warrant is quashed, the legal landscape shifts dramatically in favor of the defendant. Under the law of England and Wales, the following consequences typically arise:
The duty of full and frank disclosure is the citizen’s primary protection against “police overreach.” At TSABI, we pride ourselves on being the firm that holds the authorities to the highest standards.
Our solicitors don’t just read the warrant; we read the “Information on Oath” behind it. We compare what the police told the Magistrate with the unused material in the case file. If there is a discrepancy, we find it.
Whether you are dealing with a murder investigation or a road traffic offence involving a search of your vehicle and home, we have the specialised knowledge to navigate the High Court. Challenging a warrant requires a deep understanding of public law and criminal procedure, a duality that defines the TSABI legal team.
A search of a home or business is public and embarrassing. By getting a warrant quashed, TSABI helps restore your reputation by proving that the state acted unlawfully. We provide a robust, uncompromising defence for general criminal offences and motoring offences, ensuring that your rights are never sidelined for the sake of a “quick” investigation.