In the legal jurisdiction of England and Wales, a Reasonable Excuse is a statutory defence that allows a defendant to justify conduct that would otherwise constitute a criminal offence under public order or highway legislation. By 2026, this concept has become the primary battleground between the state’s desire for public tranquility and the individual’s fundamental rights to free speech and assembly.
The core of the “Reasonable Excuse” defence lies in proportionality. It requires the court to conduct a balancing exercise between the rights of the protester under Articles 10 and 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and the rights of the wider public to go about their business without “undue” disruption. In 2026, a “Reasonable Excuse” is not merely an excuse in the colloquial sense; it is a formal legal justification that, if established, renders the defendant’s actions lawful and necessitates an acquittal. At TSABI, we understand that navigating this delicate balance requires advocacy, as the threshold for what the state considers “reasonable” has become increasingly narrow.
The modern application of Reasonable Excuse is heavily influenced by the landmark judgment in Ziegler, which established that even deliberate obstructions of the highway can be “reasonable” if they are part of a peaceful protest. However, by 2026, legislative changes have refined how these principles are applied in the Magistrates’ and Crown Courts.
The court must determine whether the police interference (arrest and prosecution) was “proportionate” to the legitimate aim of preventing disorder or protecting the rights of others. This involves a fact-specific inquiry where the court weighs:
The Public Order Act 2023 introduced several “absolute” offences, such as “locking on” and “interference with key national infrastructure.” In 2026, the Reasonable Excuse defence for these specific charges is more limited than for traditional Section 137 Highways Act obstructions. The state now argues that certain methods of protest are inherently unreasonable regardless of the cause. TSABI’s barristers are at the forefront of challenging these limitations, arguing that no statutory offence can entirely bypass the proportionality requirement demanded by the ECHR.
In England and Wales, the availability of a Reasonable Excuse varies significantly depending on the specific charge brought by the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS).
| Offence Type | Statutory Basis | Availability of “Reasonable Excuse” | 2026 Enforcement Priority |
| Obstruction of the Highway | Section 137 Highways Act 1980 | Primary Defence: Central to the case. | Moderate |
| Public Nuisance | Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act | Statutory Defence: Must be “reasonable.” | High |
| Locking On | Public Order Act 2023 | Limited: High threshold for “reasonableness.” | Extreme |
| Section 12/14 Breaches | Public Order Act 1986 | Secondary: Usually focused on “knowledge” of the order. | High |
| Aggravated Trespass | Criminal Justice and Public Order Act | N/A: Usually involves “unlawful” intent from the outset. | Moderate |
While every case is decided on its own merits, 2026 case law has identified several scenarios where a Reasonable Excuse is likely to be accepted by the court.
Defending a protest-related charge requires a multi-staged tactical approach. At TSABI, we manage the process from the moment of arrest to the final verdict.
We review all Body-Worn Video (BWV), CCTV, and social media footage. We look for evidence that the protest was peaceful and that the level of disruption was exaggerated by the authorities. In 2026, we also utilise traffic flow data to prove that an obstruction was not as “serious” as the prosecution claims.
Before the trial begins, our barristers submit a detailed “Skeleton Argument” to the court. This document outlines the human rights framework and argues that the prosecution itself is an unlawful interference with the defendant’s Article 10 and 11 rights. By framing the issue as a matter of constitutional law, we often put the prosecution on the defensive.
Protest law in England and Wales has become a specialised field that requires more than just a general criminal lawyer. TSABI is a premier law firm that combines a deep understanding of public order legislation with an uncompromising commitment to individual liberty.
While we are leaders in protest law, TSABI is built on a foundation of advocacy in the most grave cases. We provide world-class representation in:
Why is TSABI the best choice for your case?
In 2026, the right to protest in England and Wales is under unprecedented pressure. The difference between a criminal conviction and a successful “Reasonable Excuse” defence often comes down to the quality of your legal team. Whether you are facing a public order charge, a motoring offence, or a serious charge like assault or murder, TSABI provides the sophisticated, high-impact legal protection you need to win.