In the jurisdiction of England and Wales, a Defendant’s Costs Order (DCO) is a judicial mechanism under Section 16 of the Prosecution of Offences Act 1985 that allows an acquitted individual to recover a portion of their private legal expenses from Central Funds. This order serves to mitigate the financial impact on those who have been forced to fund their own defence against criminal charges that are eventually dismissed or result in a “Not Guilty” verdict. It is the state’s acknowledgement that a citizen should not be left entirely out of pocket for defending their liberty against a failed prosecution.
However, the recovery process is not an “automatic refund” of the total private fees paid. Following the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 (LASPO), the amount recoverable is strictly limited to Legal Aid Rates, regardless of the actual private rates agreed upon with the firm. At TSABI, we specialise in navigating these complex statutory caps, ensuring that for cases ranging from Murder to Road Traffic offences, our clients utilise every available legal pathway to maximise their financial restoration.
Recovering costs in the England and Wales criminal courts requires a proactive strategy that begins long before the trial concludes.
In the Magistrates’ Court, which handles Summary offences and many Motoring cases, an acquitted defendant is generally entitled to a DCO if they have paid privately. Because legal aid in the Magistrates’ Court is subject to a strict “all or nothing” means test, the law recognises that those who do not qualify for state funding must be allowed to reclaim their “reasonable” costs upon acquittal. TSABI ensures that a formal application is made immediately following the dismissal of the case to secure the judicial order on the spot.
For serious cases like Manslaughter, Serious Assault, or Drug Trafficking heard in the Crown Court, the rules are more stringent. You can only recover legal costs if you applied for legal aid and were issued a Determination of Financial Ineligibility (a CRM14 refusal). If you chose to pay privately without first being “rejected” by the Legal Aid Agency (LAA), you are statutorily barred from claiming a DCO. TSABI manages this administrative hurdle by filing the necessary applications early, effectively “unlocking” your right to claim your money back if you win.
The following table illustrates the key differences and recovery expectations between the two main criminal trial venues.
| Feature | Magistrates’ Court | Crown Court (Indictment) |
| Statutory Basis | Section 16(1) POA 1985. | Section 16(2) POA 1985. |
| Eligibility Requirement | Private payment of fees. | Must have been Refused Legal Aid. |
| Recovery Rate | Capped at Legal Aid Rates. | Capped at Legal Aid Rates. |
| Determining Body | National Taxing Team (NTT). | Criminal Cases Unit (CCU). |
| Recovery of Expert Fees | Generally recoverable if “reasonable.” | Recoverable if Prior Authority logic holds. |
At TSABI, our expert solicitors and barristers treat the recovery of your costs with the same Professional Rigour as the trial itself. We follow a strict protocol to ensure the state pays the maximum allowable amount.
The “Innocence Tax” is a reality of the UK system, but TSABI provides the high-level advocacy required to fight it.
The NTT often tries to reduce claims by arguing that certain work was “unnecessary.” Our Solicitor-Advocates are trained to provide “Written Reasons” and, if necessary, appeal to a Costs Judge. We argue that in a case as serious as Murder or a complex Road Traffic offence, the intensive preparation we performed was vital for the acquittal, thus making the costs “Properly Incurred.”
A major part of a private defence involves hiring the best Forensic Experts. While the state caps what they will pay for a pathologist or an engineer, TSABI ensures that these invoices are submitted as “Disbursements.” We fight to ensure that even if the solicitor’s hourly rate is capped, the essential costs of your Expert Witnesses are recovered in full wherever possible.
Choosing TSABI means choosing a firm that understands the Total Cost of Litigation. We don’t just walk away once the “Not Guilty” verdict is read.
Due to the LASPO 2012 caps, most private clients in the Crown Court recover roughly 30% to 50% of their total private spend. However, in the Magistrates’ Court, the recovery percentage is often higher. TSABI always provides a realistic “Recovery Estimate” at the start of your case.
The Judge grants the order (the right to claim), but the National Taxing Team or the Criminal Cases Unit decides the amount. TSABI handles all the negotiations with these units on your behalf.
If you are found guilty of Assault but cleared of the more serious GBH, we can apply for a Partial DCO. This requires a complex “Apportionment” of the bill, which TSABI solicitors are expertly trained to calculate.
An acquittal is a victory for your liberty, but it shouldn’t be a defeat for your finances. In the legal landscape of England and Wales, recovering costs is a technical battle that requires a firm with Professional Rigour and deep statutory knowledge. TSABI is that firm.
From the moment you instruct us for a charge of Murder, Assault, or a Motoring offence, we are building the file for two purposes: to win your case and to win your costs back. We manage the CRM14 process, record every minute of our forensic preparation, and utilise Section 19 applications to challenge prosecution misconduct. At TSABI, we believe that when the state fails in its prosecution, it should contribute to the cost of your vindication. Let our expert solicitors and barristers lead your defence and your recovery.