In the legal system of England and Wales, the discovery of evidence during a search does not automatically mean that evidence can be used against you in a trial. If the police obtained that evidence through an unlawful search whether due to an expired warrant, an incorrect address, or a breach of PACE (Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984), the defence has a powerful mechanism to challenge its admissibility.
At TSABI, we believe that the ends do not justify the means. A trial is only fair if the evidence brought before the jury has been gathered according to the law. Our solicitors are experts in identifying procedural failures in murder, manslaughter, assault, and motoring offence investigations to ensure that “tainted” evidence never sees the light of day in a courtroom.
The primary tool for excluding evidence in England and Wales is Section 78 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984. This section gives the trial judge a discretionary power to refuse to allow prosecution of evidence if its admission would have an “adverse effect on the fairness of the proceedings.”
Unlike the “Fruits of the Poisonous Tree” doctrine used in other jurisdictions, the English courts do not automatically exclude evidence just because it was obtained illegally. Instead, the judge performs a balancing act. They consider:
Not every minor mistake will lead to evidence being thrown out. However, certain “significant and substantial” breaches often trigger the court’s power under Section 78.
The following table illustrates how the court typically views different levels of procedural impropriety.
| Nature of the Breach | Impact on Trial | Likelihood of Exclusion | TSABI Strategy |
| Minor Clerical Error | Low impact on fairness. | Low | Focus on mitigating the weight of the evidence. |
| Expired Warrant | Serious breach of authority. | High | Argue that the police were “trespassers.” |
| Bad Faith / Deceit | Compromises court integrity. | Very High | Apply for an Abuse of Process stay. |
| Privileged Material Seized | Fundamental right violation. | Near Certain | Immediate application for return and exclusion. |
Challenging evidence is a technical process that requires precision and deep knowledge of the Criminal Procedure Rules. At TSABI, we follow a rigorous three-step process to protect our clients.
We conduct a forensic analysis of the Search Record, the Warrant Application (Information on Oath), and the Officer’s Pocket Notebook. If we find a discrepancy—such as a search conducted at 4:00 AM when the warrant only allowed daytime entry—we flag this as a potential Section 78 trigger.
If the prosecution insists on using the evidence, TSABI solicitors will request a voir dire. This is a mini-hearing held in the absence of the jury where the judge hears arguments on the lawfulness of the search. We cross-examine the officers involved to expose any lack of “reasonable belief” or procedural shortcuts.
In extreme cases where the police conduct has been so egregious that a fair trial is simply impossible (e.g., planting evidence or systematic lying), we can apply for a Stay of Proceedings. If successful, the entire case is stopped, and the charges are dismissed.
The difference between a conviction and an acquittal often rests on the ability of your legal team to dismantle the prosecution evidence before it ever reaches the jury. TSABI provides specialist legal services across England and Wales, with a proven track record in high-stakes litigation.
In murder, manslaughter, and assault cases, the “circumstantial” evidence found during a search is often the foundation of the prosecution’s case. By getting that evidence excluded, TSABI can often collapse the case entirely.
In road traffic offences, the police frequently rely on breath, blood, or digital data obtained under specific statutory powers. If the police failed to follow the exact “procedure” required by law, we use those failures to ensure your driving record—and your liberty are protected.
We are not a “plea-only” firm. TSABI is known for its vigorous representation and its willingness to challenge the state at every turn. We ensure that the Police and Criminal Evidence Act is used as it was intended: as a protection for the citizen against the overreach of the state.