The right to consult a solicitor is not merely a formality; it is a pillar of the justice system in England and Wales. Under Section 58 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE), a person held in custody is entitled to consult a solicitor privately at any time. Importantly, this right extends to a solicitor of your own choice. You are not obligated to use the “Duty Solicitor” provided by the police; you have the legal freedom to instruct a specialist firm like TSABI to represent your interests.
However, many detainees find themselves in a position where they are told their chosen solicitor “cannot be reached” or that their access must be “delayed.” While the law allows for a delay in very specific, high-level circumstances, it is rarely a total denial. Understanding the boundary between a lawful police procedure and an unlawful obstruction is essential for anyone facing a criminal investigation.
Strictly speaking, the police cannot permanently deny you access to a solicitor. However, they can delay that access under certain conditions. For such a delay to be lawful, the police must satisfy rigid criteria set out in PACE 1984. A delay is not a decision that a regular arresting officer can make; it requires authorisation from a senior officer of at least the rank of Superintendent.
The law allows a delay of up to 36 hours (or longer in terrorism cases) only if the police have reasonable grounds to believe that allowing you to speak to your chosen solicitor will:
In extremely rare cases, the police may try to block a specific solicitor while still allowing you to see a different one. This only happens if they believe that the chosen solicitor would, inadvertently or otherwise, pass on a message that would lead to the risks mentioned above. This is a very high bar to clear, and the police must record the exact reasons for such a decision in your Custody Record.
When the police attempt to delay your access to TSABI, we do not simply wait for the clock to run down. Our team of solicitors and barristers is trained to push back against procedural obstructions using the full force of the law.
The moment we are alerted that a client has requested TSABI but is being “delayed,” we contact the Custody Suite immediately. We demand to see the written authorisation for the delay. If the “reasonable grounds” cited by the Superintendent do not meet the legal threshold, we can challenge the detention as unlawful. This proactive stance often leads to the police “reconsidering” their position and granting us immediate access.
If the police proceed to interview you while they have blocked our access, the law provides a significant protection. At TSABI, we advise all clients that they have an absolute right to remain silent. If the police have unlawfully or unfairly delayed your solicitor, a “No Comment” interview carries much less risk. In fact, if your right to legal advice was improperly handled, the court may rule that no Adverse Inference can be drawn from your silence during that period.
We are not just a “general” law firm; TSABI is a multidisciplinary legal powerhouse specialising in the most serious allegations. We provide an A-Z service, meaning our in-house team of Solicitors and Barristers handles your case from the first phone call at the police station through to the final trial.
Allegations of Murder or Manslaughter are where the police are most likely to seek extensions and delays. TSABI provides a rigorous defence, analysing every forensic detail and challenging the prosecution’s narrative from the outset. We ensure that you are not pressured into “confession” interviews while isolated from your legal team.
In cases of Section 18 GBH or Assault, the initial police interview is where the “Self-Defence” argument is either built or broken. We intervene to ensure your side of the story is recorded correctly and that the police provide Full Disclosure of any witness statements or CCTV that might exonerate you.
Motoring Offences often involve technical procedures, such as breathalyser or blood tests. The police often try to argue that legal advice should not “delay” these tests. TSABI understands the fine line here; while you cannot delay a breath test, you are entitled to advice immediately afterward. We have a track record of getting motoring cases dismissed due to procedural errors made by the police during these samples.
To help you understand if your rights are being infringed, we have outlined the differences in this comparison table:
| Scenario | Lawful Action (Under PACE) | Unlawful Obstruction |
| Rank of Officer | Authorised by a Superintendent or above. | Authorised by a Sergeant or Inspector only. |
| Duration | Delay lasts no more than 36 hours. | Delay exceeds 36 hours without a court warrant. |
| Reasoning | Clearly stated risk of alerting co-suspects. | Vague claims of “it’s not convenient right now.” |
| Documentation | Recorded immediately in the Custody Record. | No written record or justification provided to you. |
| Alternative | You are offered a Duty Solicitor if yours is blocked. | You are told “you don’t need a lawyer for this.” |
Choosing TSABI over a random Duty Solicitor is a tactical decision. A Duty Solicitor is often overworked and may only meet you minutes before an interview. At TSABI, we bring a legacy of excellence and a multidisciplinary approach that starts from the second you are cautioned.
If a Custody Officer tells you that you cannot have TSABI, stay calm but firm. State clearly: “I wish to exercise my right to legal advice under Section 58 of PACE, and I wish to wait for my chosen solicitors, TSABI.” Once you have made this request, the police are generally forbidden from questioning you until we have spoken.
Being in a police cell is a lonely and frightening experience, but you are not alone. TSABI is on hand to provide the calm, professional, and formal representation you deserve. Whether you are facing a Road Traffic matter or a Serious Criminal allegation, we bridge the gap between the law and your liberty.