In the legal framework of England and Wales, an Enhanced DBS check is a high-level vetting tool that goes beyond a standard criminal record. One of its most powerful and controversial features is the inclusion of “Other Relevant Information” (ORI), commonly known as Local Intelligence.
Under Section 113B(4) of the Police Act 1997, a Chief Officer of police has a statutory duty to provide any information that they reasonably believe to be relevant for the purpose of the check and which, in their opinion, ought to be included on the certificate. This means that non-conviction data, such as arrests, investigations that resulted in No Further Action (NFA), or even acquittal at trial, can be disclosed to a prospective employer even if you were never charged with or convicted of a crime. TSABI acts as your legal defender in this administrative arena, challenging the “relevance” and “proportionality” of such data to protect your professional reputation.
The inclusion of local intelligence is not a mechanical process but a discretionary exercise of police power. It is governed by a strict Quality Assurance Framework (QAF), with Version 10 (QAF v10) coming into force on 1st April 2026.
Local intelligence refers to information held on local police databases that does not appear on the Police National Computer (PNC) as a conviction or caution. This can include:
Before the police can include this information, the Chief Officer must satisfy a two-limb test:
Understanding the difference in how these data points are handled is crucial for your Criminal Defence strategy.
| Data Type | Source | Disclosure Rule | Challenge Mechanism |
| Convictions / Cautions | PNC | Automatic (unless filtered). | Correction of record or filtering. |
| Arrest Records | Local Police Systems | Discretionary (Relevancy test). | Representations to the Police. |
| Acquittals / NFA | Local Police Systems | Discretionary (High threshold). | Independent Monitor appeal. |
| Fixed Penalties | Local Police Systems | Discretionary (Low likelihood). | Data Protection challenge. |
For clients involved in high-stakes litigation, the “police trail” remains a risk long after the legal case concludes.
If you were investigated for a violent crime but the case was dropped, the police may still view the “nature of the allegation” as relevant. For example, if a self-employed teacher was accused of Assault, the police might argue that the fact of the investigation is a safeguarding concern, even without a conviction. TSABI specialises in arguing that an NFA decision should be respected as a total exoneration, preventing the “stain” of the allegation from appearing on your certificate.
A professional driver may be stopped on suspicion of Drug Driving but later cleared due to a faulty blood test. However, the “intelligence” of the stop remains on the local record. TSABI’s motoring experts work to ensure that these “suspicions” are not translated into “approved information” that could cost a client their private hire or courier licence.
Being “never charged” does not mean you are “invisible” to the vetting system. TSABI provides a proactive Vetting Defence Service to stop disclosures before they reach your employer.
The solicitors at TSABI recognise that a “No Further Action” result is only a partial victory if it leads to a “dirty” Enhanced DBS check.
In England and Wales, your “Local Intelligence” file is a powerful document. TSABI ensures that the police do not overstep their bounds, protecting your right to work and your right to privacy. We turn “Police Discretion” into a balanced legal process, ensuring that an arrest without a charge does not become a permanent barrier to your career.