In the legal jurisdiction of England and Wales, the decision to challenge a conviction or sentence is a significant undertaking that requires a clinical assessment of risk versus reward. While every defendant has the right to seek leave to appeal, the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) operates with a clear mandate to prevent the judicial system from being overwhelmed by baseless applications.
A common concern for many appellants is whether the court possesses the power to penalise a defendant for an unsuccessful appeal. The answer is found within the Criminal Appeal Act 1968, which grants the court specific powers to deter frivolous or unmeritorious applications. This is primarily achieved through a mechanism known as a Loss of Time Order, but it can also involve a direct increase in sentence under very specific circumstances. At TSABI, our role is to act as your strategic filter, ensuring that every appeal we lodge is built on a foundation of sound legal merit to protect you from these punitive judicial measures.
The Court of Appeal is a senior court of record, and its time is considered a valuable public resource. To protect this resource, the law provides the judges with “teeth” to discourage applications that have no realistic prospect of success.
A Loss of Time Order is the most frequent deterrent used by the Court. Under Section 29 of the Criminal Appeal Act 1968, if a judge considers an application to be totally without merit, they can order that some or all of the time the defendant has spent in custody awaiting the appeal hearing shall not count toward their final sentence. This effectively pushes back the defendant’s release date.
Many clients ask if the Court of Appeal can simply decide that a sentence was too low and increase it during a defendant’s appeal. In a standard appeal initiated by the defendant, the Court generally lacks the power to increase the sentence beyond the original term imposed by the trial judge. However, there are two major exceptions:
The “gatekeeper” of the appellate process is the Single Judge. Their assessment is the first point at which a defendant is warned about the risks of proceeding with an unmeritorious claim.
When TSABI lodges an application for leave to appeal, it is first reviewed by a Single Judge on paper.
A “frivolous” appeal is one that lacks any legal substance or ignores established law and facts. This might include:
The following table illustrates the potential consequences of an appeal, highlighting why expert legal advice from TSABI is crucial before filing.
| Potential Outcome | Legal Consequence | Impact on Release Date |
| Appeal Successful | Conviction quashed or sentence reduced. | Immediate release or earlier release date. |
| Appeal Dismissed | The original sentence stands as it was. | No change to the original release date. |
| Loss of Time Order | Time spent pending appeal is “wasted.” | Release date is delayed by the specified period. |
| Sentence Restructured | The Court alters the “maths” of the sentence. | Could lead to a longer term in rare circumstances. |
| Unduly Lenient Reference | Prosecution-led appeal against a light sentence. | Significant increase in the total sentence. |
At TSABI, we do not believe in lodging appeals simply to “see what happens.” Such a strategy is reckless and can result in our clients spending more time in prison than necessary. We employ a rigorous internal Merit Test before any papers are sent to the Criminal Appeal Office.
Our expert solicitors and barristers conduct a “cold” review of the trial. We look for material irregularities or misdirections by the trial judge. If we do not find an arguable point of law, we provide honest, candid advice. We believe that professional integrity is the best way to protect our clients’ liberty.
If a Single Judge refuses leave, we don’t automatically renew the application. We analyse the Judge’s reasons. If the Judge has identified a flaw in our argument, we address it; if the Judge is correct and the appeal is weak, we advise our clients to accept the refusal to avoid a Loss of Time Order.
Navigating the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) requires a specialist firm that understands the nuances of the Proviso and the Safety Test. TSABI is that firm.
We provide specialist appellate advice for the most serious matters:
How much time can I lose with a “Loss of Time” order?
There is no set limit, but the Court typically orders between 14 and 56 days to be lost. In extreme cases of persistent, meritless applications, the period can be longer.
Does this apply to appeals from the Magistrates’ Court?
No. When you appeal from the Magistrates’ Court to the Crown Court, the process is a Full Rehearing. While the Crown Court can increase a sentence, they do not use “Loss of Time” orders in the same way the Court of Appeal does.
Can the Prosecution ask for a Loss of Time order?
No, this is a power exercised solely by the judges to manage their own court’s efficiency. However, the Prosecution can argue that your grounds are unmeritorious during a full hearing.
The power of the Court of Appeal to issue Loss of Time Orders serves as a stark reminder that the appellate process is not a game of chance. It is a highly technical legal arena where errors in judgment can lead to a direct loss of liberty.
At TSABI, we pride ourselves on being more than just legal representatives; we are your strategic advisors. We combine a deep understanding of the Criminal Appeal Act 1968 with a commitment to our clients’ long-term welfare. Whether you are facing a conviction for murder, assault, or a road traffic offence, we provide the honest, expert guidance you need to decide if an appeal is a risk worth taking.