In the legal jurisdiction of England and Wales, a Voluntary Interview frequently referred to by practitioners and police as a Caution Plus 3 is a formal investigative interview where a suspect is not under arrest but is questioned regarding their alleged involvement in a criminal offence. To define this precisely: it is an interview conducted under the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE) where the suspect attends a police station by appointment.
At TSABI, we emphasise to our clients that the term “voluntary” is often a misnomer. While you are not in handcuffs, the legal consequences of what you say during this process are identical to those of a post-arrest interview. Whether the allegation is a minor common assault or a more complex Section 47 ABH, the Caution Plus 3 procedure is a strategic gateway used by the police to gather evidence for a future prosecution.
The “Plus 3” element of the voluntary interview refers to the three fundamental rights that an officer must explain to you before the commencement of any questioning. These rights are designed to ensure that the interview remains “voluntary” in the eyes of the law, but they also serve as a warning that the situation is a formal legal proceeding.
Police often opt for a voluntary interview when they cannot justify the “necessity” of an arrest under PACE Code G. If a suspect is willing to attend an appointment, the police may struggle to argue that an arrest is needed to prevent the disappearance of the suspect or the destruction of evidence. However, an invitation to a voluntary interview for an assault claim indicates that the police believe they have enough suspicion to charge you if the interview goes poorly.
Deciding whether to attend requires a sophisticated analysis of the police’s evidence. At TSABI, we do not allow our clients to attend these interviews “blind.” We engage with the Officer in Case (OIC) to secure Initial Details of the Prosecution Case (IDPC) before any meeting is scheduled.
If you simply refuse to attend a voluntary interview, the police will almost certainly move to a formal arrest. By refusing to cooperate with a voluntary request, you provide the police with the “necessity” criteria required to arrest you: specifically, that an arrest is necessary to allow the prompt and effective investigation of the offence.
Attending a voluntary interview with a TSABI solicitor allows for a controlled environment. Unlike an arrest, where you are held in a cell and interviewed on the police’s timeline, a voluntary interview happens at a pre-agreed time. This allows us to:
Understanding the procedural differences is vital for any suspect. The following table highlights the key distinctions between the two methods of investigation in England and Wales.
| Feature | Voluntary Interview (Caution Plus 3) | Formal Arrest and Detention |
| Liberty | You are technically free to leave at any time. | You are locked in a cell until released. |
| Fingerprints/DNA | Usually taken at the end (can be refused). | Taken immediately (can use force). |
| Custody Record | No formal custody record is opened. | A permanent custody record is created. |
| Duration | Limited to the time of the interview. | Up to 24 hours (or more with extensions). |
| Legal Status | You are a “suspect” not a “detainee.” | You are a “detainee” under PACE. |
| Record | Both result in a record on the National Police Computer. | Both result in a record on the National Police Computer. |
The interview begins with the Caution: “You do not have to say anything. But it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in court. Anything you do say may be given in evidence.”
In an assault claim, the police will ask probing questions about your location, your relationship with the complainant, and the specific physical movements made during the incident. If you remain silent but later claim self-defence in court, the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 allows a jury to draw an Adverse Inference. They may assume you only thought of the self-defence argument after the interview. TSABI experts balance this risk by providing a Prepared Statement that outlines your defence without exposing you to a fishing expedition by the police.
The police are not required to give you all their evidence. They may hold back CCTV footage or witness statements to see if you lie. A TSABI solicitor will demand Disclosure and analyse it for inconsistencies. If the disclosure is poor, we may advise a “No Comment” interview because it is unsafe to provide an account when the full nature of the allegation is hidden.
At TSABI, we believe that a voluntary interview is the first stage of your trial. Our expert solicitors and barristers are on hand to provide the specialised legal services you need to prevent a charge from ever being issued.
We do not just sit in the interview room. Before the interview even begins, your TSABI representative will:
While many voluntary interviews involve assault, TSABI provides expert defence across the entire spectrum of criminal law in England and Wales:
When your reputation and liberty are at stake, you need a firm that understands the nuances of the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) charging standards. TSABI is recognised as a leader in criminal litigation because we focus on results.
Assault allegations are rarely straightforward. They often involve “he said, she said” scenarios where the police are looking for a crack in your story. Do not go to a voluntary interview alone. Do not assume that because the police are being “friendly,” the interview is not a threat. Instruct TSABI to handle the police on your behalf. We are the specialists in criminal offence, motoring offence, and all other aspects of criminal litigation in England and Wales.