In the legal framework of England and Wales, an assault is frequently misunderstood by the public as requiring physical contact. However, under the Criminal Justice Act 1988, a “Common Assault” is an offence committed when a person intentionally or recklessly causes another to apprehend immediate and unlawful personal violence.
A verbal threat, even in the absence of a physical strike, constitutes the actus reus of common assault if the victim believes that violence is about to be inflicted upon them instantly. At TSABI, our solicitors emphasise to clients that the “threat” is the essence of the crime; the moment the fear of immediate harm is instilled, the legal threshold for a criminal offence may have been crossed.
In the eyes of the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), not every heated argument constitutes a crime. For a verbal threat to lead to a criminal record, the prosecution must prove specific elements of the offence beyond a reasonable doubt.
For a verbal threat to be classified as an assault, the victim must fear immediate violence. If a person says, “I am going to find you next week and hurt you,” this may constitute a different offence (such as harassment or threats to kill), but it technically fails the “immediacy” test for common assault. At TSABI, we scrutinise the timeline of the alleged threat to determine if the “immediate” criteria were truly met.
The defendant must have the mens rea (guilty mind). This means the person making the threat either intended to cause the victim to fear violence or was reckless as to whether such fear would be caused. If the words were uttered in a context where no reasonable person would expect fear to be elicited, the defence may argue a lack of criminal intent.
It is vital to distinguish between a “pure” assault (the threat) and “battery” (the application of force). The following table outlines the distinctions handled daily by the criminal defence team at TSABI.
| Feature | Common Assault (Verbal/Gestural) | Battery (Physical) |
| Physical Contact | None required. | Any unlawful touching, however slight. |
| Primary Element | Apprehension of immediate violence. | Actual application of force. |
| Max Sentence | 6 months imprisonment. | 6 months imprisonment. |
| Legal Basis | Section 39 Criminal Justice Act 1988. | Section 39 Criminal Justice Act 1988. |
| Examples | Raising a fist, shouting “I’ll hit you.” | Pushing, slapping, spitting, or striking. |
A conviction for a verbal threat carries the same weight on a DBS check as a physical assault. If found guilty, the repercussions extend far beyond the courtroom:
When TSABI takes on a defence case, our barristers look for specific legal avenues to protect our clients’ reputations.
In some instances, the specific words used can actually cancel out the threat. For example, if a person says, “If it weren’t for the police standing right there, I would hit you,” the presence of the police makes the threat conditional rather than immediate. We analyse the exact phrasing used to find such nuances.
While provocation is not a complete defence to the charge, it can be a significant mitigating factor. However, lawful self-defence applies if the verbal “threat” was a necessary and proportionate response to prevent an attack from another person.
Navigating the Magistrates’ Court or Crown Court without an expert is a significant risk. The law regarding “assault by words” is nuanced and relies heavily on case law, such as R v Constanza (where 800 letters were deemed an assault) and R v Ireland (where silent phone calls were deemed an assault).
TSABI ensures that the nuances of your specific situation are articulated clearly to the court, often preventing a moment of anger from turning into a life-altering criminal record.
At TSABI, we understand that being accused of a criminal offence is a harrowing experience. Whether you are facing allegations of a minor verbal spat or the most serious indictable-only offences, our firm stands as a shield for our clients across England and Wales.
Our expert solicitors and barristers are highly experienced in a vast array of criminal matters, ensuring that no matter the complexity, you have a robust defence:
If you are concerned about a verbal threat leading to a criminal record, or if you are facing charges for assault, motoring offences, or serious crime, contact TSABI today. Our legal experts are ready to provide the professional and aggressive defence you deserve to safeguard your future and your freedom.