FAQ
Home / FAQs / Civil Litigation / What Are the Primary Grounds for Suing an Insurance Company? 

What Are the Primary Grounds for Suing an Insurance Company? 

In the legal jurisdiction of England and Wales, an insurance policy is fundamentally a contract of indemnity, whereby the insurer undertakes to protect the insured against a specific loss in exchange for a premium. Insurance litigation involves the commencement of legal proceedings in the Civil Courts, specifically the Business and Property Courts against an insurance carrier when they fail to honor their contractual or statutory obligations. While the historical doctrine of uberrimae fidei (utmost good faith) once heavily favored the insurer, the introduction of the Insurance Act 2015 and the Enterprise Act 2016 has rebalanced the scales, providing policyholders with more robust avenues for recovery.  

Suing an insurance company is not merely a disagreement over a claim; it is a forensic challenge to the insurer’s interpretation of policy wording, their assessment of proximate cause, and their adherence to the duty of fair presentation. Whether the dispute concerns a total repudiation of the policy or a disagreement over the final quantum, a claimant must establish precise legal grounds to succeed in the High Court. 

Breach of Contract: Wrongful Denial of Indemnity 

The most common ground for suing an insurance company in England and Wales is a standard claim for breach of contract. When an insurer refuses to pay a claim that falls within the scope of the policy, they have failed to perform their primary contractual obligation. 

Misinterpretation of Policy Wording and Ambiguity 

Insurance contracts are notoriously complex, often filled with technical exclusions and restrictive definitions. If an insurer denies a claim based on a specific clause, the court will apply the principles of contractual interpretation to determine the “objective meaning” of the words used. Under the doctrine of contra proferentem, if a policy clause is found to be ambiguous, the court will generally interpret it in the light most favorable to the policyholder. At TSABI, we specialise in deconstructing these documents to identify where an insurer has overstepped its interpretive bounds. 

Challenging the Proximate Cause of Loss 

Insurers frequently attempt to avoid liability by arguing that the proximate cause (the dominant or effective cause) of the loss was an excluded peril rather than a covered one. If a fire leads to a structural collapse, but the insurer claims the collapse was due to pre-existing wear and tear, the dispute centers on the “efficiency” of the cause. We utilise expert forensic engineers to prove that the covered peril was the operative trigger, ensuring the indemnity principle is correctly applied. 

Damages for Late Payment: Section 13A of the Insurance Act 2015 

One of the most significant developments in modern English insurance law is the ability to sue an insurer for damages resulting from an unreasonable delay in paying a claim. 

The Statutory Duty of Timely Payment 

Under Section 13A of the Insurance Act 2015 (inserted by the Enterprise Act 2016), it is an implied term of every insurance contract that the insurer must pay any sums due within a “reasonable time.” What constitutes a reasonable time depends on the complexity of the claim and the size of the loss. If an insurer causes a business to collapse or lose significant opportunities due to an unjustified delay in settlement, the policyholder can sue for damages over and above the value of the original claim. 

Proving Losses Beyond the Policy Limit 

Litigating under Section 13A is complex because the claimant must prove that the insurer’s delay directly caused the consequential loss. This is no longer about the indemnity for the property damage, but about the financial ruin caused by the insurer’s conduct. TSABI solicitors are experts in managing these high-stakes claims, utilising forensic accountants to quantify the lost profits and damage to reputation caused by the carrier’s tardiness. 

Breach of Warranty and Conditions Precedent 

Insurers often rely on technical breaches by the policyholder to avoid paying claims. However, the law of England and Wales now restricts how these defenses can be used. 

The Modern Status of Warranties 

Previously, any breach of a warranty in an insurance contract allowed the insurer to escape liability entirely. Following the Insurance Act 2015, a breach of warranty only suspends the insurer’s liability. Once the breach has been remedied, coverage is restored. Furthermore, if the breach had no connection to the actual loss that occurred, the insurer cannot rely on it to deny the claim. TSABI provides advocacy to ensure that minor, irrelevant technicalities are not used to forfeit our clients’ rights. 

Conditions Precedent to Liability 

Many policies contain conditions precedent, such as a requirement to notify the insurer of a claim within 48 hours. If an insurer attempts to repudiate a claim based on a late notification, we challenge whether the clause was truly a condition precedent or merely a “bare condition.” If it is the latter, the insurer must prove they suffered actual prejudice due to the delay, which is a much higher bar for them to meet. 

Comparison Table: Primary Grounds for Litigation 

Legal Ground Statutory/Common Law Basis Core Objective Burden of Proof 
Breach of Contract Common Law (Indemnity) Recovery of the liquidated sum or loss. On the claimant to prove the loss falls within the policy. 
Late Payment Damages Section 13A IA 2015 Compensation for losses caused by delay. On the claimant to prove “unreasonable time” and causation. 
Fair Presentation Insurance Act 2015 Challenging an insurer’s avoidance of the policy. On the insurer to prove a material misrepresentation. 
Breach of Statutory Duty FSMA 2000 / ICOBS Seeking damages for regulatory failure. On the claimant to prove a breach of FCA rules. 

Suing for Breach of the Duty of Fair Presentation 

If an insurer attempts to “void” or “avoid” a policy because they claim you failed to disclose a material fact at the start, you can sue to have the policy reinstated or the claim paid proportionately. 

The Shift from “All or Nothing” to Proportionate Remedies 

Before 2015, any innocent mistake in a proposal form could lead to the policy being canceled from the start. Now, if the non-disclosure was neither deliberate nor reckless, the court applies proportionate remedies. If the insurer still provided the policy but charged a higher premium, they must pay the claim but can reduce the payout by the percentage of the premium they missed out on. TSABI specialises in negotiating these “proportionate” outcomes, preventing insurers from walking away with a windfall. 

CIDRA 2012 for Consumer Claims 

For individuals, the Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012 (CIDRA) protects against unfair denials. An insurer can only deny a claim if the consumer was “dishonest” or “careless” in their representations. We often handle cases where insurers have applied commercial standards to consumer policies, successfully forcing them to adhere to the more lenient consumer protections. 

How TSABI Can Assist in High-Stakes Insurance Litigation 

TSABI is a premier law firm where our expert solicitors and barristers are on hand in providing legal services such as civil litigation. We understand that an insurance dispute rarely exists in a vacuum and often intersects with other complex legal issues. 

Property and Boundary Disputes 

In many property disputes, an insurance policy is the primary source of funding for remediation. If an insurer denies a claim for subsidence, structural damage, or a boundary dispute involving land titles, TSABI provides the technical mastery to challenge the denial. We ensure that the subrogation rights of the insurer do not prejudice your personal interests in the property. 

Partnership, Shareholder, and Insolvency Disputes 

  • Partnership Disputes: We litigate denials on Directors and Officers (D&O) policies, ensuring that individual partners are not left personally liable for corporate failures when an insurer attempts to cite “insured vs. insured” exclusions. 
  • Insolvency: We represent liquidators and creditors in recovering insurance assets for insolvent estates, ensuring that the statutory waterfall of payments is respected and that insurers do not use insolvency as an excuse to avoid indemnity. 
  • Insurance & Civil Litigation: From professional indemnity claims to complex business interruption, TSABI is the best choice for your civil litigation needs. 

International Litigation and Asset Recovery 

For global entities, TSABI manages international litigation in the London courts. We represent overseas clients whose UK-based insurers have failed to honor policies. We navigate the complexities of Private International Law to ensure that jurisdictional challenges by insurers are defeated, providing a seamless bridge for global asset recovery. 

The Procedural Roadmap to Issuing a Claim 

Suing an insurer requires strict adherence to the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) and the Pre-Action Protocol for Professional Negligence or Debt Recovery. 

  1. Letter of Claim: We draft a formal letter under the Pre-Action Protocol, detailing the quantum, the breach, and the evidence. 
  1. The Response Period: The insurer has a set time (usually 90 days in complex cases) to investigate and provide a “Letter of Response.” 
  1. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR): We often engage in mediation or the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) for smaller claims to save time and costs. 
  1. Issuing the Claim Form: If ADR fails, we issue the Claim Form in the High Court, typically the Commercial Court for high-value disputes. 
  1. Forensic Disclosure: We seek disclosure of the insurer’s internal underwriting notes and claims handling files to identify “bad faith” patterns or inconsistencies. 

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
Is Mediation Compulsory Before Taking a Property Dispute to Court? 
Mediation in the legal system of England and Wales is a process of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) where a neutral, independent third party the mediator assists disputing parties in reaching a mutually acceptable settlement. Unlike a judge in...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Are the Legal Remedies for a Breach of Lease Agreement?
A breach of a lease agreement occurs when either the landlord or the tenant fails to perform the obligations, conditions, or covenants set out in the leasehold contract. In the legal jurisdiction of England and...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can I Claim Compensation for Encroachment on My Registered Land? 
Encroachment on registered land is a form of trespass to land occurring when a neighbor or third party constructs a building, fence, or other structure that extends across the boundary line and onto your...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Do I Resolve a Dispute Over a Shared Property Driveway?
A shared property driveway in England and Wales is a legal arrangement where two or more parties possess the right to use a specific strip of land for access, typically to reach a garage...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Is the Pre-Action Protocol for Residential Property Disputes? 
The Pre-Action Protocol in the legal system of England and Wales refers to a set of procedural requirements that parties must satisfy before initiating formal court proceedings in the Civil Courts. Established under the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR),...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link