A fiduciary relationship is a unique bond of absolute trust and loyalty that the laws of England and Wales protect with extreme rigour. It arises whenever one party, the fiduciary, undertakes to act in the interests of another, the principal, in a manner that provides the fiduciary with the power to affect the principal’s legal or practical interests. Because the fiduciary has the opportunity to abuse this power, the Chancery Division imposes strict obligations to ensure they do not put their own interests above those of the person they represent.
At the heart of this relationship are two prohibitive rules: the no-conflict rule and the no-profit rule. A breach occurs at the moment when a fiduciary allows a personal interest to conflict with their duty or when they secure an unauthorised benefit from their position. The law does not require the principal to prove that the fiduciary acted with malice or dishonesty; the mere existence of the conflict or the secret profit is sufficient to trigger a claim for equitable relief.
When a breach is identified, the legal remedies available are remarkably broad and often more powerful than standard contractual damages. Because these remedies are rooted in equity, they are designed not just to compensate for loss but to strip the fiduciary of any ill-gotten gains and to restore the integrity of the relationship. This dual approach ensures that fiduciaries are deterred from temptation and that the principal is made whole through both personal and proprietary avenues of recovery.
Before a court can award a remedy, it must establish the exact nature of the fiduciary obligation. In England and Wales, fiduciary duties are often found in established categories such as partnerships, company directorships, trusteeships, and solicitor-client relationships. However, the court can also find a fiduciary duty in “ad hoc” commercial relationships where there is a clear expectation of uberrima fides (the utmost good faith).
The law provides that a fiduciary must not place themselves in a position where their personal interest conflicts, or possibly may conflict, with the interest of the principal. This is a prophylactic rule intended to prevent the fiduciary from even being tempted to act self-interestedly. Similarly, the no-profit rule dictates that a fiduciary must not exploit their position to obtain a benefit for themselves. If a director takes a corporate opportunity for their own side-business, or a partner receives a secret commission, they have breached these core tenets.
Unlike common law remedies, which are often available as a right, equitable remedies are discretionary. A judge in the Business and Property Courts will consider the conduct of both parties, including whether the principal has delayed in bringing the claim (the doctrine of laches) or whether they have “unclean hands.” TSABI’s expert solicitors understand how to present a case that appeals to the court’s conscience, ensuring that the discretionary power of the court is exercised in our client’s favour.
A personal remedy is a claim against the fiduciary themselves. It creates a debt that the fiduciary must satisfy from their own assets. These are the most common forms of relief in civil litigation involving commercial agents or employees.
While similar to damages in contract or tort, equitable compensation has a different focus. It aims to restore the principal to the position they would have been in had the breach not occurred. The standard of causation in equity is often less stringent than at common law. For example, the court may apply the “but for” test without the restrictive common law rules on remoteness of damage. This allows for a more comprehensive recovery of losses stemming from mismanagement of trust property or diverted business.
An account of profits is a powerful deterrent because it focuses on what the fiduciary gained, rather than what the principal lost. Even if the principal actually made a profit or suffered no financial harm, the fiduciary must disgorge any unauthorised benefit they received. This is a restitutionary remedy that prevents the fiduciary from being unjustly enriched. TSABI utilises forensic accounting to identify these hidden profits, ensuring that every penny of the fiduciary’s illicit gain is identified and reclaimed.
Proprietary remedies are often the “gold standard” in fiduciary litigation. Instead of just giving you a right to sue the person, the court gives you a legal interest in a specific piece of property or a specific fund of money.
If a fiduciary buys a house using money stolen from a partnership, the court can impose a constructive trust over that house. This means that, in the eyes of equity, the principal is the true owner of the property. A proprietary remedy provides two massive advantages:
Tracing is the process by which the court follows the value of the principal’s property through various changes in form. If a fiduciary takes money, buys shares, sells those shares, and buys a car, TSABI can assist in tracing those funds into the car. In the Chancery Division, we can use equitable tracing, which is much more flexible than common law tracing and allows for recovery even when funds have been mixed in a bank account with the fiduciary’s own money.
The following table distinguishes between the two main categories of relief to help you understand which strategy fits your specific commercial dispute.
| Feature | Personal Remedies | Proprietary Remedies |
| Target | The Fiduciary as an individual. | A specific Asset or Property. |
| Primary Goal | Equitable Compensation for loss. | Recovery of the Actual Property. |
| Insolvency Risk | High; you are an unsecured creditor. | Low; you own the Trust Asset. |
| Asset Growth | Usually limited to interest. | You gain any Increase in Value. |
| Legal Basis | Debt or Account of Profits. | Constructive Trust or Lien. |
Sometimes, money is not enough to resolve the breach. The court has the power to issue orders that stop the breach from continuing or undoing the damage caused by the fiduciary’s actions.
If a fiduciary enters into a contract with the principal without disclosing a conflict of interest such as a director selling their own land to the company the principal can choose to rescind the contract. This “voids” the transaction from the beginning, returning the parties to their original positions. This is an essential tool for TSABI when dealing with property disputes where a fiduciary has engaged in self-dealing.
In urgent cases, we can apply for an interim injunction to stop a fiduciary from continuing a breach. This might involve a freezing order (Mareva injunction) to prevent them from moving assets abroad or a prohibitory injunction to stop them from using confidential information to compete with the principal. These orders are vital in international litigation where assets can be moved across borders in seconds.
A breach of fiduciary duty is rarely a standalone event. It often involves the misappropriation of land, the collapse of a partnership, or complex insurance claims. TSABI provides a high-level litigation shield that addresses every angle of a commercial betrayal.
Our firm is uniquely positioned in England and Wales because our expert solicitors and barristers handle the full spectrum of civil litigation. We understand that a fiduciary breach in a family office might involve property and boundary disputes, while a breach in a tech firm might involve international licensing conflicts.
Many fiduciaries attempt to hide their tracks by moving funds through offshore structures. TSABI excels in international litigation, working with global partners to enforce the judgments of the High Court across the world. Whether your dispute involves insurance litigation over a failed policy or a boundary disagreement linked to a trust property, our firm provides the rigorous advocacy needed to prevail.
Filing a claim for breach of fiduciary duty requires a disciplined adherence to the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR). A mistake in the early stages can lead to the loss of your right to a proprietary remedy.