In England and Wales, mediation is a structured, voluntary, and confidential form of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) where an independent, neutral third party, the mediator facilitates negotiations between parties in conflict. In the context of complex commercial licensing agreements, mediation serves as a tactical forum to resolve disputes involving intellectual property (IP) breaches, royalty miscalculations, territorial infringements, or technical non-performance.
Unlike a trial, mediation does not result in a judgment imposed by a court; instead, it aims for a Settlement Agreement that is contractually binding once signed. Under the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), mediation is now virtually a prerequisite for litigation, offering a “without prejudice” environment where commercial parties can explore creative solutions that a judge simply does not have the jurisdiction to grant.
The English courts have undergone a seismic shift in how they view mediation. It is no longer merely an “optional” step but a central expectation of the Business and Property Courts.
Historically, the case of Halsey v Milton Keynes General NHS Trust suggested that forcing parties to mediate might violate the right to a fair trial. However, the landmark 2023 Court of Appeal ruling in Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil CBC has clarified that the courts of England and Wales can indeed stay proceedings and order parties to engage in ADR.
The Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) mandate that before a claim is issued, parties must exchange information and attempt to settle. Mediation is the “gold standard” for this compliance. Failing to engage in mediation during the pre-action phase can lead to the court denying the recovery of legal costs later in the litigation lifecycle.
Licensing agreements for software, pharmaceuticals, or franchises are often too technical for a standard court to resolve efficiently. Mediation offers a specialised alternative.
Licensing is often a long-term partnership. A public “day in court” can permanently destroy a brand’s reputation and end a lucrative royalty stream.
In International Litigation, commercial licenses often span multiple countries. TSABI utilises mediation to create a single, global settlement that covers all jurisdictions simultaneously, avoiding the “litigation lottery” of fighting separate court battles in different nations.
Choosing between the courtroom and the mediation room involves a strategic assessment of risk, cost, and time.
| Feature | Mediation (ADR) | High Court Litigation |
| Control | Parties decide the outcome | Judge imposes a decision |
| Confidentiality | Private and confidential | Open court / Public record |
| Speed | Can be arranged in weeks | Often takes 12 to 24 months |
| Cost | Fixed mediator fee / Shared costs | High; Costs follow the event |
| Flexibility | Non-legal remedies allowed | Strictly limited to law/equity |
| Tone | Collaborative / Negotiatory | Adversarial / Combative |
At TSABI, we do not treat mediation as a “soft” option; we treat it as rigorous advocacy designed to secure the best financial result for our clients.
Success in mediation is built on preparation. We compile a mediation bundle that mirrors a trial bundle but focuses on the “commercial pressure points” of the opponent.
The mediation day usually follows a set structure:
A licensing dispute is rarely a simple “breach of contract.” It is often a symptom of broader commercial friction. TSABI provides the sophisticated civil litigation support required to turn mediation into a victory.
Our firm is uniquely positioned because our solicitors understand how licensing conflicts intersect with other areas of England and Wales law:
TSABI is the leading choice for complex, multi-sector litigation:
Mediation is a financial tool as much as a legal one. TSABI uses specific tactical maneuvers within the Civil Procedure Rules to put pressure on the other side.
Even during mediation, we often advise issuing a Part 36 Offer. This is a formal settlement offer made under the CPR.
While mediation has an upfront cost (the mediator’s fee and venue), it is a fraction of the cost of a 10-day trial in the High Court. By resolving a complex licensing dispute through mediation, TSABI saves clients thousands in court fees and barristers’ costs, allowing those funds to be reinvested into the business.
If you are facing a licensing conflict, TSABI recommends the following immediate steps: