In the legal jurisdiction of England and Wales, a fiduciary duty is a position of trust and confidence where a director is legally obligated to act in the best interests of the company, putting those interests above their own personal gain. By definition, a director occupies a “corporate office” which carries with it a suite of statutory and common law responsibilities. When a director fails to uphold these standards whether through self-dealing, negligence, or a conflict of interest, it constitutes a breach of fiduciary duty. Removing such an individual requires precise navigation of the Companies Act 2006, the company’s Articles of Association, and potentially employment law. Because a director often wears “two hats” as an office holder and an employee, the process of removal must be handled with surgical precision to avoid secondary claims for unfair dismissal or unfair prejudice.
The grounds for removal are almost always rooted in a violation of the codified duties found in Sections 171 to 177 of the Companies Act 2006. These duties form the benchmark against which a director’s conduct is measured in the High Court.
To determine if a breach has occurred, the board and shareholders must evaluate the director’s actions against the following statutory requirements:
Typical triggers that justify an immediate move for removal include misuse of corporate opportunities (such as a director taking a contract for their own new business), misappropriation of company assets, or a persistent failure to disclose a conflict of interest. When these breaches occur, the company has a right to seek restitutory relief, such as an account of profits or damages caused by the loss.
Under the law of England and Wales, shareholders possess the ultimate power to remove a director via a specific statutory procedure, regardless of any agreement between the company and the director.
The process under Section 168 of the Companies Act 2006 is highly procedural and must be followed to the letter to be legally valid:
While Section 168 provides a path for removal, sophisticated Articles of Association may contain Bushell v Faith clauses. These clauses give the director “weighted voting rights” on any resolution for their removal, effectively making them impossible to remove via an ordinary resolution. TSABI experts forensically review the company’s constitution to identify these hurdles and devise alternative strategies, such as seeking an interim injunction or filing a petition for unfair prejudice.
The method chosen for removal often depends on the level of cooperation within the board and the specific wording of the company’s internal documents.
| Feature | Section 168 Removal (Statutory) | Removal via Articles of Association |
| Notice Period | Mandatory Special Notice (28 days). | Usually much shorter (as per Articles). |
| Voting Threshold | Ordinary Resolution (50 percent+). | Can vary (often 75 percent or specific event). |
| Director’s Rights | Statutory right to protest and speak. | Limited to what is written in the Articles. |
| Vulnerability | Cannot be “contracted out” of. | Can be blocked by Bushell v Faith clauses. |
| Typical Use | Hostile removals or majority shareholder action. | Administrative or agreed “bad leaver” scenarios. |
A critical pitfall in director removal is failing to distinguish between the director’s “statutory office” and their “contract of employment.”
Removing someone as a director does not automatically terminate their employment. If the director has a service agreement, removing them from the board without complying with employment law could result in a claim for wrongful dismissal or unfair dismissal. TSABI ensures that the “removal from office” is synchronised with a lawful “termination of employment,” typically citing gross misconduct arising from the breach of fiduciary duty.
In many cases, it is commercially prudent to negotiate a settlement agreement. This involves the director resigning in exchange for a sum of money, coupled with a release of claims. TSABI specialises in drafting these agreements to include robust post-termination restrictions (non-compete and non-solicitation clauses) to protect the company’s trade secrets and client base after the “rogue” director has departed.
TSABI is a premier law firm where our expert solicitors and barristers are on hand to provide high-calibre legal services in civil litigation.
We resolve “boardroom deadlocks” where a director’s breach of duty has paralysed the company. TSABI utilises the High Court to appoint interim managers or secure freezing orders to protect company assets while the removal process is underway. We are experts in resolving the friction between minority and majority shareholders during these transitions.
To ensure a procedurally perfect removal that withstands judicial scrutiny, TSABI follows a structured chronological path: