In the legal jurisdiction of England and Wales, the allocation of legal costs is a fundamental pillar of the civil justice system. Legal costs encompass the various expenditures incurred by a party during a dispute, including solicitor fees, barrister (counsel) fees, court fees, and the costs associated with expert witnesses. The governing philosophy in high-value commercial litigation is the indemnity principle, which dictates that a party cannot recover more in costs than they are liable to pay their own legal representatives.
Furthermore, the English system operates on a “loser pays” model, formally known as cost-shifting, which serves both as a deterrent against meritless claims and as a compensatory mechanism for the successful litigant. Managing these costs requires strict adherence to the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), particularly regarding proportionality and the necessity of the work performed.
The starting point for any costs discussion in the High Court or County Court is found in CPR Part 44. While the court has wide-reaching discretion, certain established norms dictate how financial liability is distributed.
The general rule is that the unsuccessful party will be ordered to pay the costs of the successful party. However, this is not an absolute right. The court will look at the conduct of the parties before and during the proceedings. If a claimant wins their case but acted unreasonably for example, by refusing to engage in Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) or by exaggerating the claim, the court may reduce the costs award or even order the winning party to pay a portion of the loser’s costs.
When exercising its discretion, the court evaluates:
In high-value Multi-Track cases (typically those valued over 25,000), the court takes an active role in “managing” the budget of the litigation through a process called Costs Management.
Parties are required to exchange and file a Precedent H form. This is a highly detailed document that breaks down the estimated future costs into specific phases, such as disclosure, witness statements, and the trial itself. TSABI solicitors are experts in this technical forecasting; an inaccurate budget can result in a party being unable to recover thousands of pounds in legal fees, even if they win the trial.
During a Case Management Conference (CMC), the judge will review the budgets and may “approve” or “amend” them. The resulting Costs Management Order (CMO) effectively caps the recoverable costs for each phase. If a party spends more than the approved budget in a specific phase, they will generally not be able to recover that excess from the opponent unless they can show a “significant development” in the litigation that justifies an amendment.
When the court orders one party to pay another’s costs, it must decide the “basis” on which those costs are assessed. This decision significantly impacts the percentage of total spend that the winner actually recovers.
| Feature | Standard Basis (Default) | Indemnity Basis (Punitive) |
| Recovery Rate | Typically 60 percent to 70 percent of total spend. | Typically 80 percent to 95 percent of total spend. |
| Proportionality | Costs must be both reasonable and proportionate. | The requirement for proportionality is waived. |
| Burden of Proof | The winner must prove costs are reasonable. | The loser must prove costs are unreasonable. |
| Trigger | Standard conclusion of a successful claim. | Unreasonable conduct or breach of court orders. |
The process of “quantifying” the exact amount of costs to be paid usually happens in one of two ways.
For shorter hearings (lasting less than one day), the judge will often perform a summary assessment at the conclusion of the hearing. Parties must provide a statement of costs (Form N260) to the court 24 hours in advance. This allows for an immediate order for an interim payment on account, providing the client with immediate cash flow during the litigation.
For a full trial, costs are handled through detailed assessment. This is a separate procedural “mini-trial” where a specialist Costs Judge reviews the bill of costs line by line. TSABI ensures that our bills are drafted to withstand this scrutiny, utilising expert costs draftsmen to maximise the recovery of our clients’ expenditures.
High-value litigation is as much about risk management as it is about the law. CPR Part 36 provides a powerful mechanism for shifting the burden of costs.
If a claimant makes a Part 36 offer to settle and the defendant refuses, but the claimant later secures a judgment at trial that is “at least as advantageous” as their offer, the consequences for the defendant are severe. The defendant may be ordered to pay interest on the damages at up to 10 percent above the base rate and pay the claimant’s costs on the indemnity basis from the date the offer expired.
Conversely, if a defendant offers to settle and the claimant refuses, but fails to beat that offer at trial, the claimant—even though they “won” the case—must pay the defendant’s costs from the date the offer expired. At TSABI, we use these offers as a strategic shield and sword, forcing opponents to evaluate the commercial reality of their position early in the dispute.
TSABI is a premier law firm where our expert solicitors and barristers are on hand to provide world-class legal services in civil litigation. We understand that in commercial disputes, the legal cost is often as significant as the claim value itself.
In partnership disputes, costs can escalate quickly due to the need for forensic accounting. We manage these budgets tightly, ensuring that the recovery of the debt or equity is not consumed by the legal bill. In property and boundary disputes, we handle the significant costs of expert surveyors and land registry forensics, utilising costs management to keep the litigation proportionate to the land’s value.
To ensure maximum recovery, TSABI follows a structured chronological checklist for every high-value claim: