The calculation and recovery of these costs are governed by the indemnity principle, which dictates that a successful party cannot recover from their opponent more than they are liable to pay their own legal representatives. In the context of cross-border claims, the calculation of costs becomes a sophisticated exercise in both domestic procedural law specifically, Part 44 and Part 47 of the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) and international logistical accounting.
Unlike many other jurisdictions, England and Wales operates on the “loser pays” principle, formally known as costs follow the event, meaning the court generally orders the unsuccessful party to pay the reasonable and proportionate costs of the winner. However, in international litigation, the “reasonableness” of costs is subjected to intense judicial scrutiny, particularly concerning the additional expenses necessitated by geographic distance, foreign language requirements, and the need for foreign law experts.
At TSABI, we recognise that managing the financial exposure of a cross-border dispute is as critical as the legal strategy itself, ensuring that our clients’ recovery is maximised through costs management and high-calibre advocacy.
The calculation of legal costs in England and Wales is not arbitrary; it is a highly regulated process defined by the Senior Courts of England and Wales and the Civil Procedure Rules.
Under CPR Part 44.3, the court has a wide discretion regarding the awarding of costs. The primary constraint on this discretion is the proportionality test. A court will only allow costs that are proportionate to the matters in issue, regardless of whether they were necessarily incurred. In international litigation, where costs can escalate due to complex jurisdictional hurdles, TSABI ensures that every hour billed and every disbursement incurred is justifiable under this strict standard, preventing a “costs bloodbath” at the conclusion of a trial.
The indemnity principle is the bedrock of inter partes (between parties) costs recovery. It ensures that the costs system remains compensatory rather than punitive. When calculating costs for a cross-border claim, we must ensure that the underlying fee agreement between the client and TSABI whether it be an hourly rate, a Conditional Fee Agreement (CFA), or a Damages Based Agreement (DBA) is legally robust. If the fee agreement is flawed, the opponent may argue that no costs are recoverable at all, as there is no underlying liability to pay.
The most common method for calculating solicitor fees in the High Court is through the application of hourly rates. These are often benchmarked against the Guideline Hourly Rates (GHR) set by the Master of the Rolls.
In London, where most international litigation is centered, the GHR is divided into categories based on the location of the firm (e.g., London 1 for high-value commercial work). Solicitors are categorised by experience:
For a complex partnership dispute or high-stakes insurance claim, TSABI utilises a strategic mix of fee earners to ensure the “blended rate” remains proportionate while providing the elite expertise required for success.
Depending on the length of the hearing, costs are calculated through either a Summary Assessment (concluded by the judge at the end of a short hearing) or a Detailed Assessment. A Detailed Assessment is a separate proceeding before a Costs Judge in the Senior Courts Costs Office (SCCO). This involves the preparation of a formal Bill of Costs, which the opponent can challenge through Points of Dispute. TSABI’s barristers are experts in both defending our clients’ bills and aggressively attacking the disproportionate costs of our opponents.
Cross-border claims involve a “premium” of costs specific disbursements that are rarely seen in domestic litigation but are essential for the pursuit of justice across borders.
In many international litigation cases, the English court must apply a foreign lex causae (law of the case). In England and Wales, foreign law is treated as a “fact” that must be proven by expert evidence. The fees of a foreign lawyer providing a witness statement or expert report on their domestic law are recoverable as a disbursement. TSABI coordinates with an elite network of global experts to ensure this evidence is of the highest standard.
When serving proceedings on a defendant in a non-English speaking country, the Hague Service Convention or bilateral treaties often require certified translations of the Claim Form and Particulars of Claim. These costs can be substantial, especially in documents running to hundreds of pages. TSABI manages this process efficiently, ensuring translations are certified to a standard that prevents the defendant from raising a procedural challenge based on defective service.
The “basis” of assessment dictates how much of the “spent” money a client actually recovers.
| Feature | Standard Basis (The Default) | Indemnity Basis (The Penalty) |
| Doubt Resolution | Resolved in favor of the Paying Party. | Resolved in favor of the Receiving Party. |
| Proportionality | Costs must be proportionate and reasonable. | Proportionality is not a requirement. |
| Recovery Rate | Typically 60% to 75% of actual spend. | Typically 90% to 100% of actual spend. |
| Trigger | Successful conclusion of a claim. | Unreasonable conduct or breach of an Offer to Settle. |
A unique feature of cross-border litigation in England and Wales is the ability to apply for Security Costs under CPR 25.12.
If a claimant is based outside the jurisdiction in a country where enforcement of an English costs order is difficult, the defendant may ask the court to order the claimant to pay a sum of money into court (or provide a bank guarantee) as “security.” This ensures that if the defendant wins, their costs are already covered. TSABI frequently acts for international defendants to secure these orders, effectively neutralising “nuisance” claims by requiring the claimant to put their “money where their mouth is.”
The court calculates the quantum of security based on a realistic estimate of the defendant’s costs up to trial. This involves the preparation of a Costs Budget (Precedent H). TSABI’s budgeting ensures that our clients are fully protected from the risk of a “judgment proof” foreign claimant.
TSABI is a premier law firm in England and Wales where our expert solicitors and barristers are on hand in providing legal services such as civil litigation. We bring a “commercial lens” to the calculation of costs, ensuring that the legal spend is always balanced against the potential quantum of recovery.
In property disputes, particularly those involving overseas landlords or developers, the costs of surveying and expert evidence on land registration can be high. TSABI ensures that these costs are accurately budgeted and recovered, protecting your real estate investment from being eroded by the expense of the dispute.
High-value partnership disputes often involve forensic accounting to determine the value of a departing partner’s share. When these partners are located abroad, the costs of international asset tracing are significant. TSABI specialises in recovering these investigative costs as part of the overall settlement or court award.