A Governing Law Clause (also known as a choice of law clause or lex causae) determines the substantive rules that will be used to interpret the contract and define the parties’ obligations. Conversely, a Jurisdiction Clause determines the specific judicial forum or “room” in which the dispute will be adjudicated. While these two clauses often appear together, they are legally distinct.
An English law clause dictates the “how” of the legal analysis, but without a robust, exclusive jurisdiction clause, it does not dictate the “where.” Consequently, it is entirely possible and often tactically problematic for a foreign judge in a jurisdiction such as France, Singapore, or New York to preside over a case while attempting to apply English Law principles as a matter of “foreign fact.”
To understand why an English law clause is not a guarantee of a UK court, one must forensicially examine the different functions these clauses serve in international litigation.
The Governing Law clause is the “DNA” of the contract. It ensures that terms such as indemnity, force majeure, and limitation of liability are interpreted according to the established precedents of the English Courts. In England and Wales, the common law provides a high degree of commercial certainty.
However, if a dispute is brought before a foreign tribunal, that tribunal will treat English Law not as “law” in the traditional sense, but as an evidentiary fact. This often requires the appointment of expert witnesses usually senior barristers to explain to a foreign judge how an English court would rule. This process is expensive, prone to misinterpretation, and lacks the inherent reliability of a native English judiciary.
The Jurisdiction Clause is the procedural anchor. It specifies which court system has the authority to issue a binding judgment. In the absence of an exclusive jurisdiction clause, a claimant may engage in forum shopping, initiating proceedings in a country that offers procedural advantages, such as wider disclosure rules or more favorable statutes of limitation, even if the contract is governed by English Law. TSABI solicitors emphasise that the forum often matters more than the law itself, as the procedural rules of the court (lex fori) can significantly impact the final quantum of an award.
There are several legal scenarios where an English law clause fails to prevent a dispute from being dragged into a foreign court.
As noted, if a foreign court establishes that it has jurisdiction perhaps because the defendant is domiciled there or the “harm” occurred there it will not dismiss the case simply because the contract says “English Law.” Instead, the foreign judge will attempt to apply English principles. This creates a high risk of judicial error. At TSABI, we frequently intervene in such cases to provide the high-level advocacy required to stay foreign proceedings in favor of the London High Court.
If a contract contains an English law clause but either lacks a jurisdiction clause or uses “non-exclusive” language, the doors to international forums remain open. A non-exclusive clause allows a party to sue in England but does not forbid them from suing elsewhere. This can lead to lis alibi pendens (parallel proceedings), where the same dispute is fought in two different countries simultaneously.
In 2026, the Hague Choice of Court Convention 2005 is the primary international treaty protecting contractual certainty in England and Wales post-Brexit.
Under this Convention, if a contract contains an exclusive jurisdiction clause designating the courts of England and Wales, other contracting states (including all EU member states) are legally mandated to stay their proceedings and refer the parties back to London. This is a powerful tool, but it only triggers if the clause is explicitly “exclusive.” TSABI provides a rigorous audit of our clients’ contracts to ensure their jurisdiction clauses meet the high threshold required for Hague Convention protection.
Even with an exclusive clause, a party might challenge the forum by arguing forum non conveniens that another country is clearly more appropriate for the interests of the parties and the ends of justice. While English courts are hesitant to grant a stay of proceedings when an exclusive clause exists, foreign courts may be more willing to do so if they perceive a breach of natural justice or public policy.
| Feature | Governing Law (Lex Causae) | Jurisdiction (Lex Fori) |
| Primary Function | Determines the rules of interpretation. | Determines the physical court and judge. |
| Legal Status abroad | Treated as an evidentiary “fact.” | Treated as a procedural mandate. |
| Risk of Misuse | High risk of foreign judicial error. | Risk of “Forum Shopping” if non-exclusive. |
| Enforcement Basis | Contractual Intent. | Hague Convention 2005 / CPR. |
| Key Jargon | Breach of Contract, Construction. | Stay of Proceedings, Anti-Suit Injunction. |
TSABI is a premier law firm in England and Wales where our expert solicitors and barristers are on hand in providing legal services such as civil litigation. We understand that the strength of your legal position is only as good as the court that enforces it.
In property disputes, the principle of lex situs often dictates that the court where the land is located has jurisdiction. However, if a development contract involves international investors and an English law clause, an overseas party may try to litigate in their home country. TSABI ensures that boundary disputes and land-ownership claims are anchored in the Business and Property Courts of England, protecting the integrity of the UK’s Land Registry system.
Cross-border partnerships often involve members residing in multiple jurisdictions. When a partnership dispute arises, an English law clause is not enough to stop a disgruntled partner from suing in a “friendly” foreign forum. TSABI specialises in managing these corporate deadlocks, utilising Anti-Suit Injunctions to force the dispute back to the jurisdiction where the business is registered.
When a party attempts to bypass an English jurisdiction clause, the courts of England and Wales provide robust remedial measures.