In the legal jurisdiction of England and Wales, a company is recognised as a separate legal personality, distinct from its shareholders and the individuals who manage it. This means that when a director causes financial harm to the entity through negligence or a breach of duty, the proper claimant to seek redress is the company itself. This principle, established in the landmark case of Foss v Harbottle, dictates that the company owns the cause of action.
While a director’s liability is often discussed in the context of third-party creditors, the most potent legal actions often arise from the company pursuing its own “officers” to restore the corporate treasury. Whether through a board-led resolution following a change in control, a liquidator’s intervention during insolvency, or a shareholder-led derivative action, the legal system provides a robust framework for recovering losses resulting from misfeasance, ultra vires acts, or the misappropriation of corporate opportunities.
The primary grounds for a company to initiate litigation against its directors are codified in the Companies Act 2006, specifically within Sections 171 to 177, which outline the fiduciary duties owed to the company.
Under Section 174, a director must exercise the care, skill, and diligence that would be exercised by a reasonably diligent person with both the general knowledge expected of their role and the specific skills they possess. If a director makes a grossly negligent investment or fails to oversee a critical transaction, resulting in a quantifiable financial loss, the company can sue for damages. This is an objective-subjective test that TSABI solicitors navigate to hold directors to the highest professional standards.
Directors are strictly prohibited from using company property, information, or opportunities for personal gain without prior board approval. Under Section 175, if a director diverts a lucrative contract to a personal vehicle or accepts an unauthorised commission (a secret profit), the company is entitled to an account of profits or equitable compensation. The law in England and Wales is uncompromising on this point: the director must hold such gains on constructive trust for the company.
Because the directors are the ones who usually decide if a company goes to court, suing a sitting director presents a procedural paradox. Several mechanisms exist to overcome this hurdle.
The most straightforward route occurs when there is a change in the board of directors—perhaps following a hostile takeover or a significant share acquisition. The new board, acting as the company’s mind and management, can pass a resolution to sue former directors for past misfeasance. At TSABI, we frequently assist new management teams in auditing historical transactions to identify recoverable losses.
When a company enters liquidation, the power to sue shifts to the liquidator under Section 212 of the Insolvency Act 1986. The liquidator can bring a summary action against directors for misfeasance or breach of fiduciary duty. This is a powerful tool for creditors to recoup losses when a company has been “asset-stripped” prior to its collapse.
Under Section 260 of the Companies Act 2006, a minority shareholder can apply to the court for permission to bring a claim in the name of the company. This is known as a derivative action. Since the claim is “derived” from the company’s right to sue, any financial recovery goes directly back into the company’s bank account, not to the shareholder personally.
The nature of the claim significantly dictates the types of remedies the court will grant and the burden of proof required.
| Feature | Standard Negligence (Sec 174) | Fraudulent/Dishonest Breach |
| Legal Basis | Failure to meet the standard of care. | Intentional self-dealing or deceit. |
| Limitation Period | Usually 6 years from the loss. | Often no limitation for fraud. |
| Primary Remedy | Damages (Common Law). | Equitable Compensation / Account of Profits. |
| Causation | Strict “But For” test applies. | Often a more flexible equitable test. |
| Insurance | Usually covered by D&O policies. | Excluded by most D&O policies. |
| Director Conduct | Error of judgment vs. Negligence. | Breach of fiduciary duty and trust. |
When a company succeeds in its claim against a director, the court aims to restore the company to the position it would have occupied had the breach not occurred.
Directors are not without defense. The Companies Act 2006 provides a statutory “safety valve” for directors who may have technically breached a duty but acted in good faith.
Under Section 1157, a court may relieve a director from liability, either wholly or in part, if it appears that the director acted honestly and reasonably, and that, having regard to all the circumstances of the case, they ought fairly to be excused. TSABI‘s expert barristers are adept at both challenging this “honesty” defense on behalf of companies and successfully invoking it for directors facing unfair prosecution.
A company may, in certain circumstances, ratify a director’s breach of duty through a resolution of the shareholders. If a breach is ratified, the company’s right to sue is effectively extinguished. However, the law of England and Wales strictly prohibits the “wrongdoers” (the director and their associates) from voting on such a resolution.
TSABI is a premier law firm where our expert solicitors and barristers are on hand to provide world-class legal services in civil litigation. We understand that corporate litigation against directors is often personal and highly sensitive.
In high-value litigation, winning a judgment is only half the battle; the director must have the means to pay.
Most professional directors carry D&O Insurance. TSABI forensically reviews these policies to ensure that the claim is framed in a way that triggers the indemnity (covering negligence) while being mindful of exclusions related to “dishonest acts.” This ensures that when our client, the company, wins, the insurance company provides the actual financial recovery.
If a director is being sued and believes the claim is vexatious or that the company (if insolvent) cannot pay their legal fees if they win, they may apply for security for costs. We manage these tactical hurdles to ensure our clients’ claims remain viable and aggressive throughout the litigation process.