A breach of contract can have severe repercussions for any business. Beyond the immediate disruption, the most significant and damaging consequence is often the loss of expected profits. When a supplier fails to deliver, a key client pulls out unlawfully, or a partner breaches a crucial term, the financial fallout can threaten your company’s stability and future growth.
While the English legal system provides a remedy for such situations, successfully claiming for loss of profit is a complex and nuanced area of law. It is not enough to simply state that you have lost money; you must navigate a series of rigorous legal tests. This guide, prepared by the commercial litigation experts at TSABI, will outline the key legal principles that a business in England and Wales must understand when considering a claim for lost profits.
The Legal Foundation: Establishing Your Right to Claim
- At its core, a ‘loss of profit’ claim is a legal action to recover the net profits you would have reasonably expected to earn had the contract not been breached. It is a form of consequential loss, meaning it is a damage that flows indirectly from the breach itself. To establish your right to claim these damages, you must satisfy several fundamental legal tests.
- A primary question any court will consider is: “Is my loss a direct result of the breach?” This is the legal principle of causation. You must be able to demonstrate, on the balance of probabilities, that the defendant’s breach of contract was the direct cause of your inability to earn the profits in question. If the loss would have occurred anyway due to market conditions or other unrelated factors, your claim will likely fail.
- Furthermore, even if causation is established, the loss must not be too remote. This raises another critical question: “Was the loss of profit a foreseeable consequence?” The law in England and Wales, established in the landmark case of Hadley v Baxendale, sets out a two-part test for remoteness. To be recoverable, the loss must be a type that:
- Arises naturally, according to the usual course of things, from the breach itself; or
- Was something that could reasonably be supposed to have been in the contemplation of both parties, at the time they made the contract, as the probable result of the breach of it.
The Duty to Mitigate: What the Court Expects from You
Following a breach of contract, you cannot simply stand still and allow your financial losses to escalate. The law imposes a duty on the claimant to mitigate their loss. This often leads clients to ask, “Do I have to do anything to reduce my losses after the breach?”
The answer is unequivocally yes. You are legally required to take all reasonable steps to minimise the financial impact of the breach. For example, if a key supplier fails to deliver essential components, you are expected to make reasonable efforts to find an alternative supplier, even if at a slightly higher cost. A court will scrutinise your actions and will not award damages for losses that could have been reasonably avoided. Failing to mitigate your loss can significantly reduce the amount of compensation you are ultimately able to recover.
Proving Your Claim: The Challenge of Quantification
- A claim for lost profits cannot be based on speculation or guesswork. The most challenging aspect of these claims is often proving the exact amount of profit that has been lost. This process, known as quantification, requires robust and credible evidence.
- So, “How do I actually calculate my lost profits?” There is no single formula, but common methods involve comparing the business’s financial performance before and after the breach, presenting detailed financial projections that were created before the breach occurred, or analysing the performance of similar businesses in the market. The goal is to present the court with a logical and evidence-backed calculation of what the business would have earned.
- To do this, you will be asked, “What kind of evidence will I need to provide?” Your claim must be supported by clear documentation. This includes, but is not limited to, audited accounts, management reports, profit and loss statements, business plans, sales forecasts, and relevant correspondence. In many cases, the complexity of the calculation will necessitate an expert report from a forensic accountant to provide an independent and authoritative assessment of the loss.
- In some situations, a business might even ask, “Can I claim for the loss of a future opportunity?” The law does recognise claims for the ‘loss of a chance’. For instance, if a breach prevented you from bidding on a lucrative contract, you may be able to claim for the lost opportunity. However, the evidential standard for such claims is very high, and you must prove that you had a substantial, not just a speculative, chance of securing that opportunity.
How TSABI Law Firm Can Secure Your Claim
Navigating the complexities of causation, remoteness, mitigation, and quantification demands specialist legal expertise. At TSABI, our commercial litigation team possesses the deep knowledge and strategic experience required to build and win loss of profit claims. We assist our clients by providing:
- Initial Case Assessment: Our experts will conduct a thorough review of your contract, the nature of the breach, and the surrounding circumstances. We provide a clear, honest, and commercially astute appraisal of the merits of your potential claim.
- Strategic Evidence Gathering: We work with you and your team to collate the necessary financial documentation. Where the case demands it, we instruct leading forensic accountants to prepare a robust, court-ready report that precisely quantifies your losses.
- Expert Negotiation & Litigation: As skilled solicitors, advocates, and barristers, we are formidable negotiators who can effectively represent you in pre-action discussions and mediation. Should litigation become necessary, we will pursue your claim vigorously through the courts to secure the maximum compensation you deserve.