FAQ
Home / FAQs / Probate / What Are the Grounds for Claiming Lack of Capacity? 

What Are the Grounds for Claiming Lack of Capacity? 

The concept of testamentary capacity refers to the specific mental threshold a person (the testator) must meet to execute a legally binding and valid Will. To claim a lack of capacity is to assert that at the precise moment the Will was signed, the testator did not possess the requisite soundness of mind, memory, and understanding to dispose of their assets. This is not a general medical assessment of “sanity” but a targeted legal evaluation of the testator’s cognitive ability to grasp the consequences of their testamentary decisions. When capacity is successfully challenged, the Will is declared void, and the estate is distributed according to a previous valid Will or the Rules of Intestacy. 

The Judicial Benchmark: Banks v Goodfellow (1870) 

Despite the passage of over 150 years, the cornerstone of contentious probate remains the landmark case of Banks v Goodfellow. While the Mental Capacity Act 2005 governs decisions made for the living (such as Lasting Powers of Attorney), the courts consistently revert to this common law test when determining if a testator had the mental fortitude to create a Will. 

At TSABI, our legal experts frequently highlight that capacity is task-specific. A person might be capable of choosing their daily meals but lack the complex cognitive function required to understand a multi-million-pound estate. To prove a lack of capacity, a claimant must demonstrate that the testator failed in one or more of the following four limbs. 

Understanding the Four Limbs of the Testamentary Test 

  1. Nature of the Act and Its Effects: The testator must understand that they are making a document that will distribute their property upon their death. If they believe they are signing a mere letter or a temporary contract, the Will fails. 
  1. Extent of the Property: The testator must have a reasonable understanding of the size and nature of their estate. They do not need to know the exact balance of every bank account to the penny, but they must grasp the scope of their wealth, including property, investments, and personal belongings. 
  1. The Claims of Others: The testator must be able to comprehend and weigh the moral claims of those who might expect to inherit. This involves considering family members, dependants, or charities and making a reasoned decision to include or exclude them. 
  1. Freedom from Insane Delusions: The testator must not be suffering from a disorder of the mind that poisons their affections or influences their will. If a testator disinherits a child because of a baseless, irrational delusion (e.g., believing the child is an alien or a spy), the Will may be set aside for lack of capacity. 

Distinguishing Between Legal Frameworks 

One of the most complex areas of probate litigation is the interplay between common law and modern statutes. Claimants often confuse the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA) with the testamentary test. It is essential to understand how these frameworks apply differently in the courts.

Comparison Table: Banks v Goodfellow vs. Mental Capacity Act 2005 

Feature Banks v Goodfellow (Common Law) Mental Capacity Act 2005 (Statute) 
Primary Application Determining the validity of a Will after death. Making decisions for living persons (LPA, Court of Protection). 
Burden of Proof Initially on the person propounding the Will, then shifts to the challenger. Presumption of capacity unless proven otherwise. 
Threshold Focuses on the understanding of assets and moral claims. Focuses on the ability to communicate, retain, and weigh information. 
Key Objective To protect the testator’s true intentions. To protect the best interests of a vulnerable person. 

At TSABI, our solicitors and barristers are adept at navigating this distinction. We ensure that our clients do not fall into the trap of using the wrong legal test, which could lead to an immediate dismissal of the claim in the High Court. 

Common Grounds and Evidence for a Lack of Capacity Claim 

To build a robust legal strategy, one must move beyond suspicion and gather admissible evidence. The courts require high-quality proof to overturn a Will, as they are generally reluctant to interfere with testamentary freedom. 

Medical Evidence and the Golden Rule 

The most persuasive evidence often comes from medical records. We look for diagnoses of vascular dementia, Alzheimer’s disease, or other neurological conditions that were active at the time of the Will’s execution. Furthermore, we examine whether the drafting solicitor followed the Golden Rule. This “rule” suggests that when a testator is elderly or ill, the solicitor should have a medical practitioner witness the Will or provide a contemporaneous report confirming capacity. Failure to follow this rule does not automatically invalidate a Will, but it significantly weakens the defence of the document. 

Identifying Cognitive Red Flags 

Claims are often supported by a pattern of behavior that indicates a failing mind. These “red flags” include: 

  • Radical Departures: Making a new Will that completely contradicts long-standing previous Wills without a logical explanation. 
  • Confusion Regarding Assets: Evidence that the testator was unaware of significant assets, such as a family home or a business. 
  • Vulnerability to Influence: While distinct from “undue influence,” a lack of capacity often makes a testator more susceptible to the suggestions of others. 
  • Incoherent Instructions: If the notes taken by the drafting solicitor show that the testator was confused or erratic during the meeting. 

The Procedural Pathway to Challenging Capacity 

Challenging a Will is a multi-stage process that requires precision and timing. At TSABI, we manage every aspect of this journey to ensure our clients’ interests are protected from the outset. 

  1. Entering a Caveat: The first step is to stop the Grant of Probate. By entering a caveat at the Probate Registry, we prevent the executors from distributing the assets while the investigation is ongoing. 
  1. The Larke v Nugus Request: We issue a formal request to the solicitor who prepared the Will. This requires them to provide a detailed statement regarding the circumstances of the Will’s execution, their assessment of the testator’s capacity, and their meeting notes. 
  1. Expert Medical Reports: We often commission retrospective capacity reports from consultant psychiatrists who specialise in old-age psychiatry. They review the testator’s medical history to provide an opinion on whether they likely met the Banks v Goodfellow criteria. 
  1. Pre-Action Disclosure: Before full litigation, we use civil litigation tactics to obtain bank statements, emails, and witness testimonies that paint a picture of the testator’s mental state. 

How TSABI Provides Superior Advocacy in Contentious Probate 

TSABI is uniquely structured to handle high-stakes inheritance disputes. Unlike traditional firms that act as intermediaries, we provide a comprehensive, in-house litigation powerhouse. 

Seamless Integration of Legal Expertise 

At TSABI, we house Solicitors, Solicitor Advocates, and Barristers in one firm. This means that the strategic advice you receive at day one is perfectly aligned with the trial advocacy performed in the Chancery Division. We do not need to “brief” outside counsel; our barristers are involved in the evidence-gathering phase, ensuring that every witness statement is prepared with the final trial in mind. 

Multidisciplinary Insight Across Property and Civil Law 

Capacity disputes rarely exist in a vacuum. They often intersect with Property Law (disputed deeds) or Landlord and Tenant issues (estates involving rental portfolios). Our expertise in civil litigation and criminal defence allows us to provide bespoke legal strategies that high-street firms simply cannot match. We understand the litigation risk management required to settle cases through Mediation while remaining “trial-ready” if the opposition refuses to yield. 

Protecting Your Legacy with Strategic Precision 

We recognise that these cases are deeply personal and often involve family conflict. Our team provides empathetic yet assertive representation. By leveraging our in-house resources, we reduce the procedural friction often found in legal disputes, providing our clients with a clear, direct path to justice. Whether you are seeking to set aside a Will made in error or defending the wishes of a loved one, TSABI offers the authoritative representation needed to navigate the complexities of the laws. 

Acting with Urgency 

Claims for lack of capacity are time-sensitive. Delay can lead to the dissipation of estate assets or the loss of crucial witness memories. If you suspect that a Will does not reflect the true, capable intentions of the deceased, immediate action is required. By combining the procedural rigour of expert solicitors with the courtroom dominance of seasoned barristers, TSABI stands as the premier choice for those requiring robust advocacy in the face of testamentary injustice. 

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
What Are the Legal Duties of a Will Trustee?
A Will Trustee is the designated legal custodian appointed under a last will to hold, manage, and protect specific assets for the benefit of third parties after the initial estate administration is...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Is a Trustee Different From an Executor?
The fundamental difference between an executor and a trustee lies in the temporal scope and the specific statutory objectives of their roles: the executor is the short-term officer responsible for...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can a Beneficiary Also Act as a Will Trustee?
A beneficiary acting as a Will Trustee is a dual-role fiduciary arrangement where an individual holds the legal title to trust assets while simultaneously possessing a beneficial interest in the residue of...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Many Trustees Should Be Appointed in a Will?
Will Trustees are the individuals or corporate entities legally appointed within a last will to hold, manage, and protect specific assets known as the trust fund for the benefit of...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Happens if a Will Trustee Dies or Resigns?
The death or resignation of a Will Trustee triggers a formal process of fiduciary succession, governed primarily by the Trustee Act 1925, to ensure the continuous management of trust assets...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link