FAQ
Home / FAQs / Probate / Is Mediation Mandatory Before Taking Probate Disputes to Court?

Is Mediation Mandatory Before Taking Probate Disputes to Court?

As of 2026, there is no single Act of Parliament that states mediation is a “blanket” mandatory requirement for every probate claim. However, the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) and recent landmark judicial rulings have created a regime of mandatory consideration. The courts now operate under the principle that any dispute capable of a negotiated outcome must be explored through ADR before a judge will allocate precious court time to a full trial. 

The Impact of Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil [2023] 

The most significant turning point in this area was the Court of Appeal’s decision in Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil. This ruling overturned years of legal uncertainty by confirming that the court has the power to stay proceedings and order parties to engage in mediation, even if one party is initially unwilling. The court’s “Overriding Objective” is to deal with cases justly and at a proportionate cost. In the context of contentious probate, where emotions run high and estate values can be quickly depleted, the court views mediation as the primary tool for achieving this objective. At TSABI, we ensure our clients are positioned on the “right side” of this judicial expectation from the moment we lodge a caveat.  

Consequences of Unreasonable Refusal to Mediate 

Even if a court does not explicitly “order” you to mediate, the cost consequences of refusing an offer to negotiate are draconian. The general rule is that “costs follow the event” (the loser pays the winner). However, this rule is frequently ignored if the winner is found to have acted unreasonably by refusing to mediate.  

Judicial Sanctions and Cost Orders 

If you reject an offer of mediation without a compelling legal reason, such as an urgent need for an injunction, you may find yourself in a position where: 

  1. Cost Deprivation: Even if you win your case at trial, the judge may refuse to order the other side to pay your legal fees. 
  1. Indemnity Costs: You could be ordered to pay the other side’s costs on a “punitive” basis, which is significantly higher than the standard rate. 
  1. Wasted Costs: The court may view the entire trial as a “waste of resources” that could have been settled in a day of mediation, leading to direct financial penalties against the party who blocked the process.  

The Role of the Pre-Action Protocol 

Before a claim is even issued, the Pre-Action Protocol for Inheritance Act Claims and the ACTAPS Code of Conduct (The Association of Contentious Trust and Probate Specialists) require parties to state whether they are willing to mediate. Silence is often treated as a refusal. At TSABI, our solicitor advocates prepare your “Mediation Case” simultaneously with your “Trial Case,” ensuring that we are always the ones demonstrating reasonableness to the court.  

Comparison Table: Court Litigation vs. Mediation in Probate 

Feature Court Litigation (Chancery Division) Mediation (ADR) 
Control A Judge makes the final decision. The Parties control the outcome. 
Privacy Usually a public record (high exposure). Entirely confidential and private. 
Cost High (could consume 25-50% of estate). Fixed/Low (usually split between parties). 
Flexibility Rigidly follows the Wills Act 1837. Can include “non-legal” family solutions. 
Speed Can take 18-24 months to reach trial. Can be arranged in weeks. 
Finality Results in a Winner and a Loser. Focuses on a Tomlin Order or Settlement. 

The Mediation Process: What to Expect 

Mediation in a contentious probate context is a structured negotiation facilitated by a neutral third party (the mediator). It is a “without prejudice” environment, meaning nothing said in the room can be used against you in court if the mediation fails.  

The Stages of a Probate Mediation 

  1. The Preparation Phase: Parties exchange position statements and key evidence (such as medical records or Larke v Nugus statements). 
  1. The Opening Session: The mediator meets everyone (often remotely or in separate rooms) to set the ground rules. 
  1. The Shuttle Diplomacy: This is the core of the day. The mediator moves between private rooms to test the strengths and weaknesses of each side’s case and explore potential settlement figures.  
  1. The Settlement (Tomlin Order): If a deal is reached, it is drafted into a legally binding contract. We typically use a Tomlin Order, which stays the court proceedings while keeping the specific terms of the settlement confidential.  

Why TSABI is the Premier Choice for Mediation Advocacy 

TSABI provides a unique, multidisciplinary advantage that transforms mediation from a simple meeting into a high-stakes strategic victory. We do not approach mediation as a “soft option”; we approach it as an opportunity to secure a win without the litigation risk of a trial. 

The In-House Barrister Advantage 

The most critical differentiator at TSABI is our unified legal model. While other firms must hire an external barrister to attend a mediation, adding thousands to your disbursements, we have in-house barristers and solicitor advocates. This means: 

  • Counsel-Led Negotiation: You have a trial-hardened barrister negotiating your settlement, someone who knows exactly how a judge would rule if the case went to trial. 
  • Cost Efficiency: Because our advocates are in-house, we eliminate the “briefing fees” and communication lag associated with external chambers. 
  • Immediate Trial Readiness: If the other side is being unreasonable at mediation, our barristers can pivot immediately to High Court litigation. The opposition knows we are “trial-ready,” which often forces them to make better settlement offers. 

Forensic Mastery Across All Sectors 

Probate disputes are rarely about “just the Will.” They often involve property portfolios, criminal allegations of fraud, or landlord and tenant issues. 

  1. Property & Land: If the estate includes land, our property specialists can handle the “conveyancing” of a settlement in real-time. 
  1. Criminal Background: In cases involving forgery or coercion, our criminal defence team provides a level of forensic scrutiny that uncovers the “smoking gun” needed to force a settlement. 
  1. Civil Litigation Expertise: We treat mediation as a strategic theatre. We use quantum analysis and litigation risk management to ensure that any deal you sign is the best possible outcome for your financial future. 

Bespoke Advocacy and Fiduciary Integrity 

We understand that contentious probate is deeply personal. Our team provides legal representation while maintaining the fiduciary integrity required to protect the estate. We help you navigate the “emotional noise” of family disputes to focus on a strategic settlement. By choosing TSABI, you are not just getting a solicitor; you are getting a litigation powerhouse dedicated to securing your inheritance through strategic precision and authoritative representation. 

The Strategic Value of Mediation 

Mediation is practically mandatory because the alternative, a full trial, is financially and emotionally ruinous. The court now expects you to try every available avenue to settle before seeking a judgment.  

At TSABI, we embrace this shift. We use mediation as a tool to protect the estate, resolve hostility, and secure bespoke legal solutions that a judge simply cannot provide. Whether you are contesting a Will based on lack of capacity or claiming under the 1975 Act, our solicitors, advocates, and barristers are on hand to guide you. We ensure that you enter the mediation room with the strongest possible hand, backed by the full weight of a unified legal team. Contact TSABI today to discuss how we can resolve your probate dispute with efficiency, confidentiality, and professional excellence. 

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
What Are the Legal Duties of a Will Trustee?
A Will Trustee is the designated legal custodian appointed under a last will to hold, manage, and protect specific assets for the benefit of third parties after the initial estate administration is...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Is a Trustee Different From an Executor?
The fundamental difference between an executor and a trustee lies in the temporal scope and the specific statutory objectives of their roles: the executor is the short-term officer responsible for...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can a Beneficiary Also Act as a Will Trustee?
A beneficiary acting as a Will Trustee is a dual-role fiduciary arrangement where an individual holds the legal title to trust assets while simultaneously possessing a beneficial interest in the residue of...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Many Trustees Should Be Appointed in a Will?
Will Trustees are the individuals or corporate entities legally appointed within a last will to hold, manage, and protect specific assets known as the trust fund for the benefit of...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Happens if a Will Trustee Dies or Resigns?
The death or resignation of a Will Trustee triggers a formal process of fiduciary succession, governed primarily by the Trustee Act 1925, to ensure the continuous management of trust assets...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link