Home / News / Property / Avoiding Common Disputes over Shared Access and Easements

Avoiding Common Disputes over Shared Access and Easements

05 May, 2026 | TSABI Team
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

Table Of Contents

Defining Shared Access and Easements +
Different Types of Easements You Should Recognise 
Recurring Sources of Disagreement Between Neighbours  +
Maintenance Responsibilities and Financial Contributions 
Physical Interference and Obstruction of Access 
Practical Steps to Prevent Legal Battles  +
Reviewing Official Records and Title Deeds 
Establishing Formal Boundary Agreements 
Professional Legal Assistance from TSABI  +
Expert Representation by Our Property Solicitors and Barristers 

Key Points

  1. Easements vs. Licences: An easement is a permanent legal right tied to the land itself, whereas a licence is only personal permission that can be revoked.
  2. The 20-Year Rule: Using a neighbor's land openly and without permission for 20 years can create a permanent, legally binding "prescriptive easement."
  3. Substantial Interference: Legal action can only be taken if an obstruction, like a locked gate or fence, significantly hinders your ability to use a right of way.
  4. The TSABI Advantage: Our in-house team of Solicitors and Barristers provides a high-stakes defence to clarify complex deeds and resolve boundary disputes with precision.

Sharing access to land is a fundamental part of property ownership. Whether it involves a shared driveway, a pedestrian path, or essential utility piping, these arrangements ensure that properties remain functional and accessible. However, without clear legal boundaries and documented rights, these shared spaces frequently lead to friction between neighbours. TSABI has established a significant presence in resolving high-stakes property disagreements, ensuring that homeowners and commercial entities maintain their rights without falling into prolonged legal battles. 

The key to preventing conflict lies in a clear grasp of your legal position. Many owners assume that a verbal agreement or a historical pattern of use is sufficient to secure their rights. In reality, land law is specific about how these rights are created, maintained, and enforced. By addressing potential issues early, you protect the value of your asset and ensure peace of mind. Our approach at TSABI is to provide direct, professional advice that clarifies these obligations for all parties involved. 

Defining Shared Access and Easements

An “easement” is a right enjoyed by one landowner over the land of another. It is important to distinguish this from a “licence,” which is a personal permission that can be revoked. An easement is a proprietary interest in the land itself. This means that once an easement is correctly established, it usually “runs with the land,” staying in place even when the property changes hands. 

For a right to qualify as an easement, it must satisfy four essential criteria established in the historical case of Re Ellenborough Park [1955]: 

  1. A Dominant and Servient Tenement: There must be two distinct pieces of land. The “dominant” land benefits from the easement, while the “servient” land is the one burdened by it. 
  1. Accommodation of the Dominant Tenement: The right must benefit the land itself, rather than being a personal benefit to the owner. For example, a right to use a path to reach a front door benefits the house, whereas a right for a specific person to park a commercial van might be seen as a personal business arrangement. 
  1. Diversity of Ownership: The dominant and servient owners must be different people. You cannot have an easement over your own land. 
  1. Capable of Being Granted: The right must be specific and clearly defined. It cannot be too broad or vague, such as a “right to a nice view.” 

Different Types of Easements You Should Recognise 

Easements are not all created in the same way. The method of creation often dictates how easy it is to prove the right or, conversely, how to challenge it if a dispute arises. 

Express Easements within Property Deeds 

Express easements are created through a formal written document, usually a Deed of Grant or a Transfer Deed (Form TR1). These are the most secure forms of access. When a portion of land is sold, the seller may “reserve” a right for themselves or “grant” a right to the buyer. These rights are then registered at HM Land Registry. At TSABI, our solicitors focus on the precise wording of these deeds to ensure that no ambiguity exists regarding the width of the access, the times of day it can be used, or the types of vehicles allowed. 

Prescriptive Easements from Long-term Usage 

A prescriptive easement arises when a person uses a neighbour’s land for a long period without a formal agreement. Under the Prescription Act 1832, if a right has been exercised for at least 20 years continuously, it can become a permanent legal right. This use must be “as of right,” which means it happened: 

  • Without Force (Nec Vi): No fences were broken or locks cut. 
  • Without Secrecy (Nec Clam): The use was open and visible to the landowner. 
  • Without Permission (Nec Precario): No formal licence or verbal consent was given. If you gave your neighbour permission to use the path, they cannot claim a prescriptive easement because their use was not “as of right.” 

Implied Easements and Access of Necessity 

Implied easements are not written in deeds but are assumed by law to exist based on the circumstances of a land sale. 

  • Easements of Necessity: These occur when a piece of land is sold in a way that leaves it completely landlocked. The law implies a right of way over the seller’s remaining land because, without it, the sold land would be unusable. 
  • The Rule in Wheeldon v Burrows [1879]: If you sell part of your land, the buyer automatically receives all “continuous and apparent” easements that you used for the benefit of that part while you owned the whole. 
  • Section 62 of the Law of Property Act 1925: This statute can accidentally turn a temporary permission into a permanent easement when a property is conveyed, unless the deed explicitly excludes it. 
Type of Easement Source of Right Evidence Required Difficulty in Dispute 
Express Written Deed Title Register / TR1 Form High 
Prescriptive 20+ Years of Use Witness Statements / Photos Medium 
Implied Circumstance of Sale Historical Mapping / Site Layout Medium 
Necessity Landlocked Status Title Deeds / Access Maps High 

Recurring Sources of Disagreement Between Neighbours 

Disputes often start when the physical reality of land use changes—for instance, when a neighbour builds an extension, installs a gate, or starts a home business that increases traffic. 

Maintenance Responsibilities and Financial Contributions 

A major point of contention is who pays for the upkeep of a shared driveway or private road. The general common law rule is that the owner of the burdened (servient) land is not required to maintain the easement for the benefit of the neighbour. However, the neighbour (the dominant owner) has an implied right to enter the land to carry out repairs themselves. 

Conflict arises when one party wants to resurface a driveway and expects the other to pay. This is governed by the principle in Halsall v Brizell [1957], which suggests that if a person takes the benefit of an easement, they must also share the burden of its maintenance. If a deed is silent on costs, the following guidelines usually apply: 

  1. Usage Proportions: Costs should generally be split based on how much each party uses the access. 
  1. Level of Repair: One party cannot unilaterally choose a premium finish (e.g., expensive cobblestones) and demand the other party pay half if a standard tarmac finish would have sufficed. 
  1. Standard of Maintenance: The access must be kept in a condition that allows the easement to be exercised safely. 

Physical Interference and Obstruction of Access 

Disagreements frequently occur when the servient owner places an obstacle in the way of the access. This could be a new fence, a locked gate, or even overgrown vegetation. 

To take legal action, the obstruction must be a “substantial interference.” A minor inconvenience—such as a gate that is easy to open or a slight narrowing of a path that still allows vehicles to pass—may not be enough for a court to grant an injunction. However, if a neighbour parks a car on a shared driveway so that you cannot get your vehicle out, this is almost always considered a substantial interference with your right of way. 

  • Actionable Obstructions: Locked gates without providing keys, bollards, skips left for long periods, or building over the easement area. 
  • Non-Actionable Obstructions: Unlocked gates, speed bumps (if reasonable), or temporary scaffolding with prior notice. 

Preventing a dispute is significantly less expensive than resolving one in court. At TSABI, we encourage an inclusive and proactive approach to property management. 

Reviewing Official Records and Title Deeds 

Everything begins with the paperwork. You must check the official Title Register and the Title Plan held by HM Land Registry. 

  • The Red Line: Remember that the red line on a Title Plan only shows “general boundaries.” It does not provide the exact inch of ownership. 
  • The Charges Register: Look for entries that mention “Subject to rights of way” or “Together with a right of way.” 
  • Filed Deeds: Often, the register refers to a “Conveyance dated X.” You must obtain a copy of this original document, as it contains the specific rules and limitations of the easement. 

Establishing Formal Boundary Agreements 

If you and your neighbour are currently on good terms but are unsure about the exact boundary or access rules, you can create a formal Boundary Agreement. This document clarifies the position on the ground and can be submitted to HM Land Registry. This prevents future owners from reopening the dispute. 

Steps for a Successful Resolution: 

  1. Initial Survey: Hire a professional surveyor to map the access way accurately. 
  1. Informal Meeting: Discuss the issue with your neighbour. Often, they may not realise they are infringing on your rights. 
  1. Letter of Claim: If informal talks fail, a formal letter from a solicitor at TSABI outlines the legal position and the consequences of continuing the interference. 
  1. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR): Mediation is a highly effective way to settle property issues without the stress of a courtroom. 
  1. Injunctions: If the interference is urgent (e.g., someone is building a wall over your only access), we can apply for an emergency court order to stop the work. 

Property law is an area where small mistakes in documentation lead to massive financial losses. At TSABI, we pride ourselves on our visibility as a leading authority in property litigation. Our experts ensure that your land remains your own, and your rights are never ignored. 

Expert Representation by Our Property Solicitors and Barristers 

The advantage of working with TSABI is our integrated team. While many firms only offer solicitors, we provide direct access to advocates and barristers who understand how these cases are viewed by judges. This allows us to provide a high-stakes defence from the moment a dispute begins. 

Our defence solicitors assist with: 

  • Challenging Prescriptive Claims: If a neighbour is trying to claim a right through long-term use, we help gather evidence to show their use was interrupted, or that permission was granted. 
  • Interpreting Complex Deeds: We break down old, difficult language in historical conveyances to tell you exactly what you can and cannot do. 
  • Tribunal Representation: We represent clients at the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), which handles most disputes regarding Land Registry entries. 
  • Injunctions and Damages: If your rights have been breached, we fight to restore your access and secure compensation for any loss of value to your property. 

Protecting your home or business requires more than just knowing where the fence is. It requires a legal team that can provide authoritative, professional guidance. If you are facing a disagreement over shared access or need to formalise an easement, contact TSABI today. Our solicitors and barristers are ready to secure your property interests with the precision and excellence your investment deserves. 

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link