Home / News / Criminal Defence / Navigating Reasonable Procedures Defences in 2026 Fraud Trials

Navigating Reasonable Procedures Defences in 2026 Fraud Trials

17 May, 2026 | TSABI Team
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

Table Of Contents

The Statutory Framework of the Failure to Prevent Fraud Offence  +
Defining the "Large Organisation" Threshold 
Specified "Base Fraud" Offences 
Establishing the Reasonable Procedures Defence  +
The Six Principles of Fraud Prevention 
Tactical Challenges in 2026 Fraud Trials  +
Challenging the Inference of Benefit 
How TSABI Law Can Assist Your Organisation  +
Expert Counsel from Solicitors and Barristers 
Compliance Audits and Litigation Support 

The legal landscape for UK corporations changed fundamentally with the full implementation of the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023 (ECCTA). As of 2026, large organisations face a new reality where they are held criminally liable if an “associated person” such as an employee, agent, or subsidiary commits fraud to benefit the business. This “failure to prevent fraud” offence marks a significant shift toward corporate accountability in England and Wales. 

At TSABI, we provide the clarity and confidence required to handle these rigorous legal demands. Our firm stands as a trusted expert in criminal litigation, offering a unique integrated model where seasoned solicitors and expert barristers work side-by-side. We recognise that an investigation can be a major challenge to your business continuity. Our team provides a robust defence strategy to ensure your organisation meets the highest standards of legal compliance while protecting your reputation and operations. 

The Statutory Framework of the Failure to Prevent Fraud Offence 

The “failure to prevent fraud” offence is a strict liability crime. This means the prosecution does not need to prove that senior management knew about the fraud; they only need to prove that a fraud occurred and the organisation lacked adequate prevention measures. 

At TSABI, our solicitors provide this service by helping organisations identify their specific risks under this Act. We define this offence as a legal mechanism that holds a company responsible for fraudulent acts committed by its representatives for the company’s gain. 

Defining the “Large Organisation” Threshold 

The Act specifically targets “large organisations” to ensure that the regulation is proportionate. Your business falls under these rules if it meets at least two of the following criteria in the financial year before the offence: 

  • Turnover: More than £36 million. 
  • Balance Sheet Total: More than £18 million. 
  • Number of Employees: More than 250. 

At TSABI, we assist boards in auditing their corporate status to confirm whether they meet these thresholds. If your group of companies meets these requirements collectively, every part of the group may be at risk. 

Specified “Base Fraud” Offences 

The offence covers a wide list of underlying crimes. These include: 

  • Fraud by false representation or abuse of position. 
  • Cheating the public revenue (Tax fraud). 
  • False accounting. 
  • Fraudulent trading. 

Our barristers possess extensive experience in defending these specific “base” allegations, ensuring that if the underlying fraud is not proven, the corporate charge cannot stand. 

Establishing the Reasonable Procedures Defence 

The only way for a large organisation to avoid a conviction is to prove the “reasonable procedures” defence. An organisation is not guilty if it can show it had in place prevention procedures that were reasonable to expect in its specific circumstances. 

At TSABI, our solicitors provide this service by conducting comprehensive gap analyses of your current internal controls. We define this defence as a legal safe harbour for companies that have taken active, documented steps to stop criminal activity within their ranks. 

The Six Principles of Fraud Prevention 

The UK government has provided a framework of six core principles to determine if procedures are “reasonable.” 

  1. Top-Level Commitment: The board must show a zero-tolerance culture. 
  1. Risk Assessment: You must identify where your business is vulnerable to fraud. 
  1. Proportionate Procedures: Controls must match the scale of the risk. 
  1. Due Diligence: You must vet agents and partners thoroughly. 
  1. Communication and Training: Staff must understand the rules and their duties. 
  1. Monitoring and Review: You must test your systems regularly to ensure they work. 

Tactical Challenges in 2026 Fraud Trials 

In 2026, the Serious Fraud Office (SFO) and the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) look beyond “paper policies.” They examine whether your compliance is an active part of your daily business. 

Challenging the Inference of Benefit 

A company is only liable if the fraud was intended to benefit the organisation. We define the “benefit test” as the requirement for prosecution to show the crime was meant to gain an advantage for the company rather than just the individual. 

At TSABI, our solicitors and barristers provide this service by scrutinising the flow of funds. If we can show the company was a victim of the fraud, or that there was no intent to benefit the firm, the prosecution case loses its foundation. 

The Burden of Proof for the Defence 

In these trials, the burden of proof shifts. Once the prosecution proves a fraud happened, the company must prove its procedures were “reasonable.” This requires an evidential trail that is ready for court. Our advocates assist in preparing this documentation, ensuring every training log and risk report is persuasive and admissible. 

How TSABI Law Can Assist Your Organisation 

A conviction for failing to prevent fraud can lead to unlimited fines and being banned from public contracts. TSABI offers a specialised shield to prevent these outcomes. 

Expert Counsel from Solicitors and Barristers 

Our firm provides a rare advantage: an integrated team of solicitors, advocates, and barristers. At TSABI, our solicitors and barristers provide this service by working as one unit from the first day of an investigation. 

  • Our Solicitors: Handle the detailed preparation, evidence gathering, and initial enquiries. 
  • Our Barristers: Provide high-level courtroom advocacy and strategic advice on how the law applies in the Crown Court. 

This model ensures a seamless defence where no detail is lost in transition. We offer personalised attention to every client, ensuring you are never just a case number. 

Compliance Audits and Litigation Support 

Whether you want to prevent a future problem or are currently facing a trial, TSABI is your partner in resilience. We provide: 

  • Pre-emptive Audits: Testing your “reasonable procedures” before the authorities do. 
  • Response Strategies: Providing immediate legal cover if an “associated person” is suspected of wrongdoing. 
  • Court Representation: Delivering a robust defence aimed at securing a successful case outcome. 

Protect your business with the expertise and track record of TSABI. We bring together the best legal minds in England and Wales to give you the results you need. 

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link