In the jurisdiction of England and Wales, a criminal conviction is often viewed as the final chapter of a legal battle. However, for those who have suffered a miscarriage of justice, the law provides a narrow but powerful gateway for recourse: the introduction of fresh evidence. Under Section 23 of the Criminal Appeal Act 1968, the Court of Appeal possesses the discretionary power to receive evidence that was not adduced during the original trial.
At TSABI, we define fresh evidence not merely as information that is “new” to the defendant, but as evidence that meets a stringent statutory threshold. It must be evidence that was not available at the time of the trial, is capable of belief, and is of such significance that it might have led the jury to reach a different verdict. Our firm specialises in the forensic excavation of trial records to identify these missed opportunities, ensuring that no stone is left unturned in the pursuit of a quashed conviction.
The Court of Appeal does not grant hearings lightly. To successfully introduce new material, an appellant must satisfy the court on several specific legal fronts. At TSABI, our expert solicitors frame our applications to meet these high judicial standards.
When we identify potential material to support an appeal, we evaluate it against the criteria established by the Criminal Appeal Act. The court will consider:
The identification of fresh evidence requires a proactive and investigative mindset. TSABI does not simply review the papers; we conduct a “top-to-bottom” forensic audit of the entire prosecution history.
In many cases involving murder or manslaughter, the police gather vast amounts of data that never make it to the courtroom. This is known as unused material. Our solicitors at TSABI are experts at identifying “disclosure failings.” We look for:
What was considered “state-of-the-art” five years ago may now be obsolete. TSABI maintains relationships with leading forensic scientists to re-examine old evidence.
It is a common misconception that any evidence not heard by the jury is “fresh.” The law makes a sharp distinction, as outlined in the table below:
| Feature | New Evidence (Often Inadmissible) | Fresh Evidence (TSABI Focus) |
| Availability | Known to the original legal team but not used for tactical reasons. | Unknown or unavailable at the time of the trial despite due diligence. |
| Scientific Status | Based on established science used during the trial. | Based on new scientific techniques or post-trial breakthroughs. |
| Witness Status | A witness who was available but the defence chose not to call. | A witness who has only now come forward or has recanted a false statement. |
| Legal Threshold | High risk of being rejected as a “tactical failure.” | Likely to be admitted if it renders the conviction unsafe. |
When a client instructs TSABI for an appeal, we follow a rigorous, multi-staged process to ensure the strongest possible grounds are submitted to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) or the Court of Appeal.
Appeals are significantly more complex than trials. While a trial focuses on facts, an appeal focuses on legal safety and procedural integrity. TSABI is uniquely positioned to handle these high-stakes challenges.
Our firm has a dedicated department for high-profile criminal matters:
At TSABI, we believe that the legal system must be held accountable. Our solicitors act as a “second pair of eyes,” identifying the incompetence of representation or police misconduct that led to a wrongful conviction. We are not just your lawyers; we are your advocates in a system that is often reluctant to admit mistakes.
H3: Frequently Asked Questions on Fresh Evidence
What if my previous lawyer missed the evidence?
If your original legal team failed to follow a clear lead or ignored obvious evidence, this may constitute incompetence of counsel. While the bar is high, TSABI can argue that this failure led to a manifestly unfair trial.
Can “New” witness testimony be used?
Yes, but the court will view it with caution. If a witness has changed their story (recantation), we must provide a clear explanation as to why they lied initially and why they are telling the truth now.
Does fresh evidence guarantee a new trial?
Not necessarily. The Court of Appeal may quash the conviction entirely if the evidence is so strong that no reasonable jury could convict. Alternatively, they may order a retrial if they believe a jury should decide the weight of the new evidence.
The path to overturning a conviction is paved with procedural hurdles and strict legal tests. Success requires more than just the truth; it requires the ability to package that truth into a compelling legal argument that the Court of Appeal cannot ignore.
TSABI stands at the forefront of criminal defence in England and Wales. Our expert solicitors combine years of trial experience with a sophisticated understanding of appellate law. Whether you are dealing with a serious assault, a complex fraud, or a motoring offence, we provide the investigative depth and legal brilliance necessary to challenge the status quo.
The safety of your conviction is our priority. If you believe that vital evidence was missed, ignored, or simply didn’t exist until now, TSABI is ready to fight your corner.