The issue of legal costs is a critical consideration in any form of commercial litigation. Understanding the principles that govern the recovery of these costs is essential for making informed strategic decisions about whether to pursue, defend, or settle a claim. The rules for costs recovery in England and Wales are comprehensive, and while there is a general principle, the outcome is never guaranteed.
The General Principle: “Costs Follow the Event”
- The starting point for a court in England and Wales is the principle that “costs follow the event.” In simple terms, this means that the unsuccessful party will be ordered to pay the successful party’s legal costs. This rule is enshrined in the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) and serves to compensate the winner for the expense they were forced to incur to vindicate their rights or defend a claim.
- However, it is crucial to understand that this is a general rule, not an absolute one. The court retains a very wide discretion to make any order as to costs that it deems appropriate in the circumstances of the case. A party who is successful on the main issue of the claim may not necessarily be awarded all of their costs if, for example, they were unsuccessful on several smaller arguments.
The Court’s Discretion and the Conduct of the Parties
The court’s discretion will be heavily influenced by the conduct of the parties, both before and during the legal proceedings. The court can, and often will, depart from the general rule to reflect unreasonable behaviour. Conduct that may negatively impact a costs award includes:
- Failing to comply with court rules, directions, or orders.
- Exaggerating a claim or pursuing arguments that have no merit.
- Refusing to engage in Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), such as mediation, without good reason.
- Engaging in unnecessarily aggressive or uncooperative litigation tactics.
- A party can “win” the case but still be penalised on costs—for instance, by having their recoverable costs reduced or even being ordered to pay a portion of the loser’s costs—if their conduct is judged to have been unreasonable.
The Basis of Assessment: Standard vs. Indemnity Costs
Even when a costs order is made in your favour, it does not usually mean you will recover 100% of the legal fees you have paid. The amount you can recover is determined by the “basis of assessment” ordered by the court. There are two primary bases:
- The Standard Basis: This is the default and most common basis for assessment. Under this basis, you can only recover costs that have been reasonably incurred and are proportionate to the matters in issue. Any doubt as to whether costs were reasonably or proportionately incurred is resolved in favour of the paying party. In practice, recovery on the standard basis often results in a shortfall, with the successful party typically recovering between 60% and 80% of their total legal expenditure.
- The Indemnity Basis: An order for costs on the indemnity basis is more favourable to the receiving party and is generally made as a mark of the court’s disapproval of the paying party’s conduct. Under this basis, the test of proportionality does not apply, and any doubt as to whether costs were reasonably incurred is resolved in favour of the receiving party. This almost always results in a significantly higher recovery rate than the standard basis.
The Impact of Settlement Offers (Part 36)
One of the most powerful tools influencing costs orders is a formal settlement offer made under Part 36 of the Civil Procedure Rules. These offers carry significant costs consequences designed to encourage parties to settle disputes. In summary:
- If a claimant makes a Part 36 offer which the defendant rejects, and the claimant goes on to win an amount equal to or greater than their offer at trial, the court will usually order the defendant to pay costs on the more punitive indemnity basis from the date the offer expired, plus enhanced interest.
- Conversely, if a defendant makes a Part 36 offer which the claimant rejects, and the claimant fails to obtain a judgment more advantageous than the offer, the claimant will be ordered to pay the defendant’s legal costs from the date the offer expired.
How TSABI Law Firm Manages and Optimises Costs Recovery
At TSABI, we view costs management as an integral part of our litigation strategy. We assist our clients by:
- Providing Transparent Costs Advice: From the outset, we provide clear and realistic estimates of potential legal costs and the likely level of recovery.
- Strategic Use of Part 36: Our expert litigators are adept at deploying and advising on Part 36 offers to maximise our clients’ costs position and apply pressure on opponents.
- Focusing on Proportionality and Conduct: We conduct litigation in a robust but proportionate manner, ensuring our clients’ conduct throughout the proceedings strengthens their position when the court comes to decide on costs.
- Expert Negotiation and Assessment: We are skilled in negotiating favourable costs agreements as part of a settlement and, where necessary, rigorously pursuing our clients’ interests in the formal “detailed assessment” process to maximise the final recovery.