Adverse costs represent the most significant financial risk for an unsuccessful claimant. These are the legal costs that the losing party must pay to the winning party. This liability is not limited to the winning party’s solicitor’s fees but also includes disbursements, which are out-of-pocket expenses incurred during the litigation. Common disbursements include fees for expert witnesses, barrister fees, court fees, and the cost of obtaining documents. The court will assess these costs for reasonableness and proportionality, often through a process known as “detailed assessment.”
Under the CPR, costs must be proportionate to the matter’s value and complexity. If the court finds that costs are disproportionate, it may reduce the amount a party can recover. This principle is a double-edged sword: while it can protect a losing party from excessive costs, it can also limit the amount a winning party can recover, potentially leaving them with a shortfall. The court’s discretion in applying proportionality is a key element of the financial risk assessment.
Since the implementation of the Jackson reforms, cost management has become a central feature of civil litigation. Under CPR 3.13, parties in most multi-track cases are required to submit and agree upon a costs budget, outlining their estimated legal costs for the litigation. The court then approves this budget, and any costs incurred that exceed the approved budget may not be recoverable from the other side. This process forces parties to forecast their costs accurately and provides greater certainty regarding their potential financial exposure.
To address the financial risks of litigation, various funding mechanisms and insurance products are available:
Part 36 of the CPR provides a powerful mechanism for encouraging settlement and managing cost liability. A Part 36 offer is a formal, without-prejudice offer to settle the entire claim or a part of it. The costs consequences of a Part 36 offer are significant:
Before commencing litigation, a thorough risk assessment is essential. This involves a multi-faceted analysis of numerous factors:
TSABI Law Firm specialises in guiding clients through the complexities of litigation finance. The firm conducts an initial risk assessment to provide a clear and candid evaluation of the claim’s merits, potential costs, and the likelihood of a successful outcome. Clients receive transparent, itemised cost estimates from the outset, ensuring they are fully aware of their financial exposure at every stage.
TSABI assists clients in securing the most appropriate funding and insurance solutions for their specific case. The firm has extensive experience in negotiating Conditional Fee Agreements (CFAs) and arranging bespoke After the Event (ATE) insurance policies. By leveraging its network and expertise, TSABI ensures that clients can access justice without being unduly burdened by the risk of adverse costs.
Beyond just legal representation, TSABI provides strategic litigation management. The firm offers proactive advice on settlement negotiations, including the tactical use of Part 36 offers. By managing the litigation process and providing continuous risk analysis, TSABI empowers clients to make informed decisions that optimise their chances of success and minimise their financial risk.