One of the most pressing concerns for individuals and businesses considering litigation is the potential financial burden of legal proceedings. In England and Wales, the principle of “costs follow the event” applies, meaning that the losing party is typically ordered to pay the winning party’s legal costs. However, this is not an absolute rule, and there are important exceptions and considerations that may affect the recovery of costs. Navigating this landscape requires careful legal strategy to protect your fiscal interests.
Under the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), the general rule is that the unsuccessful party will be ordered to pay the costs of the successful party. This principle, often referred to as “costs follow the event,” is designed to ensure fairness and to discourage frivolous claims or defences. In practical terms, this means that if you win your case, the court will usually order the other side to pay your reasonable legal costs. However, the court retains discretion to make a different order depending on the circumstances of the case, as outlined in the Civil Procedure (Amendment) Rules 2013 (SI 2013/262).
The costs recoverable under a costs order are known as “inter partes costs.” These are the costs that are related to the litigation itself and are typically paid by one party to another. They generally include a wide range of expenses, such as:
It is important to distinguish these from “solicitor and own client costs,” which are the costs you agree to pay your solicitor under your specific retainer agreement. The court’s costs order relates only to the inter partes costs, which must be assessed to ensure they are reasonable and proportionate to the issues in the case.
When assessing costs, the court may apply either the “standard basis” or the “indemnity basis.” On the standard basis, costs must be both reasonably incurred and proportionate to the matters in issue. This often results in the recovery of only a portion of the total legal costs. On the indemnity basis, proportionality does not apply, and the receiving party is more likely to recover a greater sum, although the court still requires costs to be reasonably incurred. The indemnity basis is typically reserved for cases where one party has engaged in particularly unreasonable conduct.
The court has significant discretion in awarding costs, and winning the case does not guarantee full recovery. Several key factors may influence the extent to which costs are recoverable:
The court will consider the conduct of both parties before and during the proceedings. For example, unreasonable behaviour, failure to comply with court rules, or refusal to engage in genuine settlement discussions may lead to a reduction in the costs awarded to a successful party. The court can penalise a party for a lack of cooperation or for making spurious arguments, even if they ultimately win the case. The use of “without prejudice” offers, which are made in an attempt to settle a dispute, can be a crucial part of this.
The court assesses whether the costs incurred are proportionate to the value, complexity, and importance of the claim. Disproportionate costs, even if reasonably incurred, may not be recoverable. This acts as a check to prevent parties from spending an excessive amount on legal fees for a relatively minor dispute.
Part 36 of the CPR allows parties to make formal settlement offers. If a party rejects a Part 36 offer and subsequently fails to achieve a better outcome at trial, they may face significant adverse costs consequences. For example, a claimant who rejects a defendant’s offer and then wins but is awarded less than the offer may be ordered to pay the defendant’s costs from the date the offer expired. Conversely, a claimant who makes a Part 36 offer that is not accepted and then beats their own offer at trial is entitled to enhanced costs and interest.
A common concern for successful litigants is the risk of winning a case but being unable to recover costs because the losing party is insolvent or has no assets. In such situations, the court’s order for costs is of little value. However, protective measures may be available. For example, a successful party may be able to apply for a “security for costs” order, which requires the other party to provide security (e.g., a payment into court) to cover potential costs liabilities, particularly where there is reason to believe they may not be able to pay if they lose.
At TSABI Law Firm (Solicitors, Advocates, and Barristers Inc.), we understand the financial complexities of litigation and are committed to providing strategic advice from the very outset to maximise your chances of a favourable costs order. Our expert team of solicitors, advocates, and barristers works to protect your commercial interests at every stage of the dispute. Our services include:
While the general rule in England and Wales is that the losing party pays the winner’s costs, the court’s discretion and various exceptions mean that outcomes can vary significantly. Professional legal guidance is essential to navigate these complexities and build a strategy that not only aims for success on the merits but also seeks to secure a favourable costs order. Contact TSABI Law Firm today for a consultation to discuss your specific case and ensure your commercial interests are protected from the outset.