If the executor of an estate is not performing their duties, a beneficiary or other interested party has several legal options available to them, ranging from informal communication to formal court applications for the executor’s removal. An executor has a strict fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the estate and its beneficiaries, and a failure to do so, whether through unreasonable delay, misconduct, or neglect, constitutes a breach of that duty. The courts take such matters seriously and have the power to intervene to ensure the deceased’s estate is administered properly.
An executor’s role is a position of significant legal responsibility. Their powers are derived from the will itself, and they are officially confirmed by a Grant of Probate. The duties are not optional; they are a legal obligation that must be carried out with reasonable care and diligence.
The primary duties of an executor include:
There is no strict, statutory deadline for an executor to complete their duties. However, the law provides for a reasonable period, often referred to as the “executor’s year,” which is 12 months from the date of death. This timeframe is considered a reasonable period to get all the necessary work done. If an executor fails to distribute the estate within this time, beneficiaries have the right to challenge the delay and may be entitled to claim interest on their legacies. While some delays are justifiable for complex estates (e.g., waiting for a property to sell), an unreasonable and unexplained delay can be a ground for legal action.
When an executor is not performing their duties, the first step is almost always to try and resolve the issue informally before resorting to legal action. This can often save significant time and money.
A beneficiary should begin by communicating their concerns with the executor in a polite and constructive manner. It is often the case that an executor is not acting out of malice but is simply overwhelmed, inexperienced, or unaware of the extent of their duties. If this informal communication fails to produce a satisfactory result, the next step is to send a formal letter outlining the concerns and requesting a detailed account of the administration of the estate. This letter should be sent via recorded delivery to create a clear paper trail for any future legal proceedings.
In cases where a potential dispute is foreseen and the Grant of Probate has not yet been issued, a beneficiary can lodge an executor’s caveat with the Probate Registry.
What is an ‘executor’s caveat’? A caveat is a legal notice that prevents the issue of a Grant of Probate for a period of six months. Its purpose is to give an interested party time to investigate a dispute, such as the validity of a will or the suitability of an executor, before the executor gains the legal authority to act. Lodging a caveat is an inexpensive way to pause the process and prevent a problematic executor from accessing the estate’s assets.
In the most serious circumstances, where an executor’s conduct is causing significant harm to the estate, or they are refusing to act at all, the only option may be to apply to the court for their removal.
Yes, an executor can be removed by a court order. The court, however, will not do this lightly, as it respects the wishes of the deceased in appointing the individual. The court will generally only remove an executor if there is compelling evidence of one of the following:
An application for removal is made to the High Court under Section 50 of the Administration of Justice Act 1985. This is a complex application that requires a detailed witness statement setting out the grounds for the removal and a copy of the will and the Grant of Probate. The court’s primary concern in making a decision is the welfare of the beneficiaries and the proper administration of the estate as a whole.
Let’s consider a hypothetical case of Ms. Jones, a beneficiary of her mother’s estate. Her brother, Mr. Jones, is the sole executor. Four years have passed since their mother’s death, and Mr. Jones has still not completed the administration. He has obtained the Grant of Probate but has failed to sell the house, which is the main asset of the estate. The house is falling into disrepair, and he has not provided a single account of his actions.
Dealing with a difficult or non-performing executor can be a stressful and emotionally taxing experience. The legal processes for addressing such issues are complex, and a mistake can be costly. At TSABI, our team of expert solicitors, advocates, and barristers specialises in contentious probate and estate administration, providing professional guidance and support throughout every stage.