FAQ
Home / FAQs / Probate / Can I Challenge a Will?

Can I Challenge a Will?

Navigating the aftermath of a loved one’s death is an emotionally taxing time, and discovering that their will doesn’t align with their known wishes or that you’ve been unfairly excluded can be deeply distressing. This leads many people to ask the critical question: can I challenge a will? The short answer is yes, but only under specific legal grounds and within strict timeframes. In England and Wales, the law provides clear pathways for disputing a will, which we will explore in detail. This article will serve as a comprehensive guide to understanding the legal grounds for a challenge, the process involved, and how our expert team at TSABI (The Solicitors Advocates and Barristers Inc.) can assist you in protecting your interests.

Understanding the Grounds for Challenging a Will

Challenging a will is not simply about disagreeing with its contents; it must be based on a legally recognised ground. These grounds generally focus on issues with the testator’s (the person who made the will) state of mind or the process by which the will was created.

Lack of Testamentary Capacity

A fundamental requirement for a valid will is that the testator must have the testamentary capacity to make it. This means they must be of sound mind, memory, and understanding at the time the will was executed.

The Banks v Goodfellow Test

The legal test for testamentary capacity stems from the landmark case of Banks v Goodfellow (1870). To have capacity, a testator must understand:

  • The nature of the act of making a will and its effects.
  • The extent of their property of which they are disposing.
  • The people who might reasonably expect to benefit from their will, known as their dependants and beneficiaries.
  • That they are not suffering from a “disorder of the mind” that would poison their affections or pervert their sense of right, preventing the natural use of their faculties.
  • Challenging a will on these grounds often involves obtaining medical evidence, such as doctors’ notes or expert opinions, to demonstrate that the testator was not of sound mind when they made the will. This is particularly relevant in cases involving conditions like dementia or severe mental illness.

Undue Influence or Duress

A will can be challenged if it can be proven that the testator was coerced into making it by another person. Undue influence is a very high standard to meet in court. It requires showing that the testator’s own free will was overcome by the influence of another, to the extent that the will no longer reflects their true wishes.

What Constitutes Undue Influence?

It is not enough to show that a person simply had influence over the testator; the influence must have been “undue.” This often involves:

  • A relationship of trust, such as a caregiver, family member, or close friend.
  • Evidence of manipulation, threats, or emotional pressure.
  • A will that significantly deviates from prior testamentary intentions, with no logical explanation.
  • The burden of proof rests on the claimant to prove undue influence, which is why it is one of the more difficult grounds to succeed on. It is not about a person being encouraged to change their will; it is about their will being entirely overborne by another person’s actions.

Formal Invalidity or Fraud

For a will to be valid in England and Wales, it must comply with specific formalities outlined in the Wills Act 1837. If these formalities are not met, the will can be challenged as formally invalid.

The Wills Act 1837 Requirements

A will must:

  • Be in writing.
  • Be signed by the testator or another person in their presence and at their direction.
  • Be witnessed by two or more people who are present at the same time and who also sign the will in the testator’s presence.
  • The witnesses, or their spouses, must not be beneficiaries under the will.
  • Any deviation from these rules, even a minor one, could render the will invalid. A common example is a will that has been signed without two witnesses being present at the same time.
  • Similarly, if it can be proven that the will was forged or that the testator was a victim of fraud, the will can be declared invalid. Forgery often involves expert forensic analysis of signatures and handwriting.

The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975

Even if a will is legally valid, it can still be challenged under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. This Act allows certain individuals to claim that the will (or the rules of intestacy) failed to make “reasonable financial provision” for them.

Who Can Make a Claim?

The Act defines a specific class of eligible claimants, including:

  • A spouse or civil partner of the deceased.
  • A former spouse or civil partner who has not remarried.
  • A child of the deceased (of any age).
  • Any person who was treated as a child of the deceased’s family.
  • Any person who was being maintained by the deceased immediately before their death.

The court will assess a range of factors when considering a claim, including the claimant’s financial needs, the size and nature of the estate, and the deceased’s reasons for their testamentary provisions. A key point to remember is the strict time limit: a claim must be brought within six months of the date of the grant of probate.

The Process of Challenging a Will

If you believe you have a valid claim, the process begins with legal advice and strategic action.

Initial Steps and the Caveat

The very first step should always be to seek specialist legal advice. Your solicitor will assess the merits of your potential claim and advise on the best course of action. If there are grounds to challenge the will, your solicitor will likely recommend lodging a caveat with the Probate Registry.

What is a Caveat?

A caveat is a legal notice that prevents the grant of probate from being issued. It effectively puts a hold on the administration of the estate, giving the potential claimant time to investigate their claim. A caveat lasts for six months and can be renewed. Once a caveat is in place, the executors cannot legally administer the estate, which is a powerful tool in a dispute.

Mediation and Court Proceedings

The vast majority of will disputes are resolved through negotiation and mediation, rather than in court. This is because litigation is expensive, stressful, and uncertain. Your solicitor will engage with the executor of the will and the beneficiaries to try and reach a settlement.

If a settlement cannot be reached, the dispute may proceed to court. This is a complex and formal process where a judge will hear evidence from both sides and make a final binding decision. The court may choose to declare the will invalid or make an order for financial provision under the 1975 Act.

How TSABI Can Assist You

Will disputes are highly specialised and can be emotionally charged. Our team at TSABI (The Solicitors Advocates and Barristers Inc.) are not only seasoned content writers but also expert solicitors in England and Wales with extensive experience in contentious probate matters. We offer compassionate and strategic legal support to clients at every stage of the process.

Our Client-Centric Approach

At TSABI, we understand the sensitivity of these issues. We begin with a thorough, confidential consultation to understand your unique circumstances and provide a candid assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of your potential claim. We believe in providing clear, transparent advice so you can make informed decisions.

Our Services Include:

  • Case Assessment: We will review all relevant documents, including the will, medical records, and other evidence, to determine if you have a strong legal basis for a challenge.
  • Caveat and Warning: We will handle the administrative process of lodging a caveat on your behalf and, if necessary, responding to a warning issued by the opposing side.
  • Negotiation and Mediation: We are skilled negotiators who will work tirelessly to resolve the dispute outside of court, aiming for a cost-effective and timely settlement that meets your objectives.
  • Court Representation: If litigation becomes unavoidable, our team of experienced solicitors and advocates will represent you in court, building a robust case to secure the best possible outcome.
  • After an initial investigation and legal correspondence, the caregiver was faced with the strength of our case. She chose to enter into a mediation, where we negotiated a settlement that saw her receive a small, fair amount in recognition of her caregiving, while the bulk of the estate was rightfully returned to the children, reflecting Mr. Jones’s original intentions. This case illustrates the power of a strategic legal approach in achieving a just outcome without the need for a full-blown and expensive trial.

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
What Are the Legal Duties of a Will Trustee?
A Will Trustee is the designated legal custodian appointed under a last will to hold, manage, and protect specific assets for the benefit of third parties after the initial estate administration is...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Is a Trustee Different From an Executor?
The fundamental difference between an executor and a trustee lies in the temporal scope and the specific statutory objectives of their roles: the executor is the short-term officer responsible for...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can a Beneficiary Also Act as a Will Trustee?
A beneficiary acting as a Will Trustee is a dual-role fiduciary arrangement where an individual holds the legal title to trust assets while simultaneously possessing a beneficial interest in the residue of...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Many Trustees Should Be Appointed in a Will?
Will Trustees are the individuals or corporate entities legally appointed within a last will to hold, manage, and protect specific assets known as the trust fund for the benefit of...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Happens if a Will Trustee Dies or Resigns?
The death or resignation of a Will Trustee triggers a formal process of fiduciary succession, governed primarily by the Trustee Act 1925, to ensure the continuous management of trust assets...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link